Poll Need help choosing a primary hull design

[Soran77]

So I'm going with either one or the other, the one on the left is wider, and a bit more beefy, the one on the right is sleeker though, Both have primary impulse engines, the secondary impulse engines are on the wings! Please cast your vote!

 

[Michael]

I like both, but the one on the left looks more "right" to me. Reminds me a bit of the Norway (?) class, but the nacelle pylons on your design are more unique.

 

[Bry_Sinclair]

Left looks more substantial.

 

[Santaman]

The left one, I really think it looks better for the ship.

 

[Forbin]

Pictures are blocked here at work so I can't see them, but as a conservative, I say go with the right one.

 

[fireproof78]

Well, I went right because my eye was immediately drawn to it. After more thorough analysis, it's definitely a close tie, but I think the impulse engine placement made the difference for me.

 

[Soran77]

So the left design has a HUGE lead, and I've been working quite a bit on it, I honestly like the left one better, but I figured I'd involve my art buddy's here on the Trek BBS!

 

[Soran77]

You can see I've changed the secondary Hull, redid the back on the saucer a bit, changed the impulse engines so they clear the pylons! Also moved the Nacelles forward a bit

 

[B.J.]

I like the wider hull version only partly because of the width, but also because I like what you did to the aft edge of the primary hull much better.

 

[Kaiser]

Reminds me a paper drawing ship i did once

Yours looks better though