• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

My July Contest Entry

PSGarak

Commodore
Commodore
His Strongest Weakness


Enabran Tain sat in his home office, superficially occupied with some minor reports that weren't time sensitive enough to warrant his full attention at the Obsidian Order Headquarters. Less obviously he was waiting for his housekeeper, Mila. At his right hand sat one glass of rokassa juice. Across the desk directly in front of him sat another.


Although he didn't glance up from the data pads, he was aware of her in the doorway the moment she arrived. Peripheral vision caught everything he needed to see, the way she ever so briefly hesitated at the sight of the rokassa juice, her firm step forward to cover the hesitation, the hand that protectively cupped at her belly beneath her loose shift before dropping back to her side with a small twitch of her fingers. He saw it all and found himself disappointed at her lack of subtlety. To punish her for it, he made her wait until he finished scanning two more reports.


“Ah, Mila, I didn't hear you come in,” he said with a smile that never reached his dark eyes. “Please, have a seat. Make yourself comfortable.”


The chair in question was anything but comfortable, lacking a cushion and straight backed, slightly too low, and positioned directly across from Tain. He had seen Guls tremble in that chair, an invitation to Tain's personal office neither honor nor privilege. He had a reputation for viciousness that gave even his superiors pause. Mila perched on the edge with her knees together and her hands folded in her lap. She met his dark gaze with her light one. Whatever hesitation she showed upon arrival was now subsumed behind a mask of calm curiosity.


Tain took a sip of his rokassa juice and smacked his lips. Still holding the glass, he said, “Perhaps you'd like to drink with me?” He gestured at the glass closest to her.


“I'm not thirsty at the moment,” she demurred.


“Suit yourself,” he said, as though it were nothing more than a triviality. Setting his glass aside, he laced his fingers over his flat belly and leaned back in his seat. “How long have you been with me now, Mila? I confess the days escape me.”


“I very much doubt that,” she said mildly, a brief spark of something defiant in her level blue gaze.


Who else would I allow even that? Tain wondered. “Indulge me,” he said, his voice smooth and soothing. “How long?”


“Three years,” she replied, “eleven weeks, and five days to be precise.”


“In all that time, I don't think I've ever seen you dress in that fashion,” he continued, gesturing at her shift. “Indeed, you've hardly changed at all. Your food is still mediocre, your cleaning services adequate, your discretion impeccable. I'd say were it not for that last, you wouldn't still be here. Do you think that's a fair assessment?”


“I think you know your own mind,” she replied.


He dropped all pretense of cordiality. “How long did you think you could keep it from me?” he asked.


She hesitated. He saw the protest trying to form behind her gaze, then the lie, both in less time than it took for him to draw a complete breath. Wisely, she chose neither course of action. “Until my body betrayed me,” she said, sounding resigned. “I take it you want me to leave.”


“On the contrary. You're an asset. I never willingly depart with assets. I don't want you to leave. I want you to get rid of that,” he said, this time gesturing at the gentle swell of her belly beneath the shift.


Her gaze dropped from his and settled on the glass of rokassa juice. She swallowed thickly but made no move to reach for it. “Even though it's yours?” she asked in a low voice.


“Especially because it's mine. Mila, of all people, I didn't think I would have to explain this to you. Make this easy on yourself. Drink the juice. The miscarriage will be painful, but you will live to see another day. I chose a drug that ensures that. Otherwise, more drastic measures will be necessary.”


He watched her stand slowly and reach for the glass. He was taken off guard by the flood of relief he felt at the sight. The thought that he might actually be attached to this woman was intolerable. She lifted it and turned it so that glass and juice both caught the dim light then suddenly flung it to the floor, sending shards skittering.


Tain reached her in two strides around the desk and seized her throat in a powerful hand, pinning her wrists with his other. “You idiot woman,” he hissed, so close to her face that he could feel her restricted breath flutter over his lips. “Do you think I'm giving you a choice?”


“I'm giving...you one,” she gasped and glared at him with bulging eyes. “You want the baby gone...then kill me.”


He tightened his grip until no more breath escaped. She jerked and shuddered, struggling in earnest. Her tongue protruded wet and pink between rapidly blackening lips. Tain stared deeply into her eyes, the bloom of subconjunctival hemorrhages darkening the whites. His hands began to shake.

Do it, he thought. You can always find a better housekeeper. Do it! You can't afford this attachment. You're already too close, and you know it. Best to get it done with now!

Despite his thoughts, his hands mutinied. He flung her backwards. She hit the chair and toppled over sideways, lying on the floor and coughing violently. As she spasmed, he backed up and startled himself by bumping his desk. Never in his life had he allowed himself to back down from what was necessary. Never? the insidious thought came, colored with amused contempt. Be honest with yourself now.

Growling under his breath, he strode for the door. “Clean up this mess!” he bellowed at the prostrate woman without once glancing back.


The next several days were tense ones in the Tain household. Neither spoke of the incident in the office, but every time Tain looked at Mila, her blood darkened eyes and bruised neck and wrists silently accused him, not of the assault, but of his failure. He avoided her as much as he could by day. By night he obsessively examined the memory from every angle. Each time her reached the point where his hands began to tremble and then betrayed him, he tried desperately to grasp exactly what impulse caused the breach of willpower.



It can't possibly be love, he thought, and yet, how would he really know? He had closed himself off so thoroughly to such indulgences, he wondered if he would recognize one that managed to breach his defenses. It was a troubling thought for a man unused to being troubled. Most confounding of all, he could trust no one with his dilemma. His sole confidant was the source of the trouble.


After another sleepless night, Tain descended the broad, curved staircase leading to his well appointed parlor. Mila swept the floor near the kitchen door close to the base of the steps, keeping her head down. “Why are you still here?” he growled, pausing on the third step from the floor.


“You haven't sent me away,” she said simply, not looking up.


He heard, or at least thought he heard, a silent accusation after the response, and you didn't kill me. “Nothing is keeping you here,” he flared. “I don't pay you that well. I don't need you that much. Why don't you just leave?”


She stopped sweeping and leaned on the broom. Some of the spark of spirit he admired about her flashed in her damaged eyes. “Go where? Do what? I know too much to think for one instant you'd let me waltz out of here free to pursue other employment. If anything, it would just give you an excuse to kill me and feel justified. No. Enabran, if you want me gone, you're going to have to do it yourself, with no excuses and no justification other than what you can come up with on your own.”


He felt himself grow deadly still. “What did you just call me?”


Sighing, she leaned the broom against the wall and spread her arms. “I can't do this,” she said. “I'm pregnant. It's stressful enough without our playing these games. If you don't know how I feel about you by now, it has to be because you don't want to know. Precious little escapes your famous attention. I'm carrying your child. Decide what you want to do about it and stick to it. You owe me that much.”


The trembling returned. He tucked his hands behind his back and clenched them into tight fists. She was right about one thing. He had to decide. I'm carrying your child. Family, the one thing those deep within the Order could never afford, was nevertheless a strong temptation. If he gave into this weakness, he wouldn't be the first of the Order to do so in secret, but oh, the costs if he was discovered! It could bring down everything he had worked his whole life to achieve, expose the secrets from his carefully obscured past, and destroy any chance he had of ascending to head the Order, unless....



I could raise the child as my replacement, give it all of the advantages I never had, make it into what I could only hope to be. Yes, he thought, seizing upon this idea like a drowning man to floating wreckage. Sentiment already has me. I'm lost, but I could spare that child all of this. I could create the perfect operative, a fitting heir, an empty vessel filled with nothing but loyalty to Cardassia and the will to do anything necessary to protect it.

He realized the truth of it as he looked at the woman confronting him more bravely than most with years of training could manage. He couldn't kill her that night because he loved her. His body knew it before his impressive intellect, a fact that was damning, crushing, and strangely freeing all at once. Nothing would ever be the same. He dropped his arms to his sides and descended the remaining three steps, still towering over Mila at floor level. “You know when it's born, it can't stay here,” he said, pausing and adding, “and neither can you. Cardassians can never know a child of Enabran Tain walks among them.”


She reached a hand up, lightly brushing her fingertips across the ridge of his jaw. “They'll never learn it from me,” she said, letting her hand drop back to her side. “Now, will you be wanting fish juice this morning?”


“Did you make it?” Tain asked.


“No,” she said. “I bought it at the market yesterday.”


“Then yes,” he said. “I do want fish juice.” Things were far from normal, far from routine, and yet life went on. Wasn't that the Cardassian way?
 
This is a fascinating look inside the mind of a man faced with an excruciating choice. I was glad he made the right one in the end, though I wonder if he'll ever show his love for the mother of his child in a way that goes beyond simply sparing her life.
 
And you were so worried about your writing!

This is GOOD!!!

And that "empty vessel" is very much what I think Garak was. I mean, you compare him to someone like Tekeny Ghemor and it's deadly obvious. (And I think that's part of why Ghemor hated Garak.)
 
This is a fascinating look inside the mind of a man faced with an excruciating choice. I was glad he made the right one in the end, though I wonder if he'll ever show his love for the mother of his child in a way that goes beyond simply sparing her life.

Thanks so much for the feedback. I've actually never liked Tain, at ALL, which was one reason I found myself drawn to write about him. I wanted to see if I could find anything at all sympathetic. I'm glad you enjoyed it!
 
And you were so worried about your writing!

This is GOOD!!!

And that "empty vessel" is very much what I think Garak was. I mean, you compare him to someone like Tekeny Ghemor and it's deadly obvious. (And I think that's part of why Ghemor hated Garak.)

Thanks so much! As much as I've enjoyed reading your Cardassian fanfic, that's really high praise. Ghemor and Garak couldn't be more different I think. What decency Garak does have had to come from Mila, which is why I saw her as a strong person. I thought, "What kind of woman could someone like Enabran Tain love?" And she just sort of...got there.
 
And you were so worried about your writing!

This is GOOD!!!

And that "empty vessel" is very much what I think Garak was. I mean, you compare him to someone like Tekeny Ghemor and it's deadly obvious. (And I think that's part of why Ghemor hated Garak.)

Thanks so much! As much as I've enjoyed reading your Cardassian fanfic, that's really high praise. Ghemor and Garak couldn't be more different I think. What decency Garak does have had to come from Mila, which is why I saw her as a strong person. I thought, "What kind of woman could someone like Enabran Tain love?" And she just sort of...got there.

You're welcome!

There are definitely people who write some good Garak fics. But he's really chilling, when you think about it: even freaking DUKAT had other attachments, and a side of him that ALMOST started to make sense. I could never allow myself to get near Garak--I'm not even sure his decency is decency. Now, Garak as he appeared in AJR's novel...I COULD see something decent in him. But by canon evidence only? Nope.

Tekeny, on the other hand...I would literally trust him with my life, the way the character was depicted.

Indeed, you couldn't come up with two more opposite characters.
 
There are definitely people who write some good Garak fics. But he's really chilling, when you think about it: even freaking DUKAT had other attachments, and a side of him that ALMOST started to make sense. I could never allow myself to get near Garak--I'm not even sure his decency is decency. Now, Garak as he appeared in AJR's novel...I COULD see something decent in him. But by canon evidence only? Nope.

Tekeny, on the other hand...I would literally trust him with my life, the way the character was depicted.

Indeed, you couldn't come up with two more opposite characters.

Oh, yeah. There is no way I'd ever trust Garak with my back. He is an ultimate survivor, which means Garak is numero uno for Garak, always. I think Robinson had to find some decency in the character he played, and I loved his book. It would be very hard to play a character truly devoid of decency.

Of course, Alaimo took his liking of Dukat a bit far, I think, having been quoted as saying he saw Dukat as the hero of DS9! Dukat had a method to his madness, but really from the get-go, he had such little self awareness that he was doomed to make mostly bad decisions. Garak is at least self aware, and though he is a survivalist, I always got the impression that he finds himself loathsome.
 
The thing with Dukat was this...and what I think Alaimo saw (though oh BOY did he express it badly--unless he was saying those things for shock value?): that character was one of the type who had the potential either for great glory or great ignominy. And if only he had made better choices...he could have become someone really, truly incredible. Dukat's greatest fear was himself, I believe. There were times I thought I saw flashes of it...and I actually am of the theory that HE saw flashes of it, in Ziyal. But he never could face what that meant to him. And when Ziyal died, that took out his last connections to whatever in him might have been salvageable.

I don't know if you've seen it yet...but some of my Catacombs of Oralius stories feature a version of Dukat who led a life that you would THINK would offer a lot more "justification" for someone turning out as horribly as the canon Dukat. And yet this one is a very different sort of man.
 
The thing with Dukat was this...and what I think Alaimo saw (though oh BOY did he express it badly--unless he was saying those things for shock value?): that character was one of the type who had the potential either for great glory or great ignominy. And if only he had made better choices...he could have become someone really, truly incredible. Dukat's greatest fear was himself, I believe. There were times I thought I saw flashes of it...and I actually am of the theory that HE saw flashes of it, in Ziyal. But he never could face what that meant to him. And when Ziyal died, that took out his last connections to whatever in him might have been salvageable.

I don't know if you've seen it yet...but some of my Catacombs of Oralius stories feature a version of Dukat who led a life that you would THINK would offer a lot more "justification" for someone turning out as horribly as the canon Dukat. And yet this one is a very different sort of man.

I always had that feeling about Dukat, and I thought it was a true shame and a waste that he never managed to "get there". However, I will also always hold something of a grudge with the writers who took a ham-fisted, heavy-handed approach to the character with the attitude of, "He's a villain! You must hate him, so we're going to do everything in our power to be sure you do!"

When I write, the characters I develop rarely stay static. I've had heroes turn to villains and villains who actually reached deep inside and started expecting more from themselves and delivering. If the writers had been more openminded and gone with what Alaimo was putting into that character and what the fans were responding to, I think it would have been far more compelling and interesting than what they did.

That's the only section of stories of yours I haven't gotten to yet. When I actually have a chance to sit at the computer without other distractions, I'm gonna dig in. I'm Cardassian obsessed. It's an addiction. :cardie:
 
Great story.

I always wondered why Tain chose to even have a child, and this explains everything nicely.
 
Great story.

I always wondered why Tain chose to even have a child, and this explains everything nicely.

Thank you very much! I wondered that, too, many times, considering how adamant he was that he should have killed Garak. This may not be the only way that it makes sense, but it was the only way I could think of that made sense to me. I'm glad you enjoyed!
 
I always had that feeling about Dukat, and I thought it was a true shame and a waste that he never managed to "get there". However, I will also always hold something of a grudge with the writers who took a ham-fisted, heavy-handed approach to the character with the attitude of, "He's a villain! You must hate him, so we're going to do everything in our power to be sure you do!"

When I write, the characters I develop rarely stay static. I've had heroes turn to villains and villains who actually reached deep inside and started expecting more from themselves and delivering. If the writers had been more openminded and gone with what Alaimo was putting into that character and what the fans were responding to, I think it would have been far more compelling and interesting than what they did.

I don't know...I think getting fans to "buy" a conversion would've been hard. It's happened in real life (St. Paul, for instance), but even THEN it usually has to happen in a pretty extreme way to get someone like that to truly feel the weight of his sins, and I'm not sure fans would buy it, despite the real-life precedent.

But it does also make sense to me that when he lost Ziyal, he lost whatever connections he had to the part of himself that might've been redeemable. And I can accept what happened as a tragic fall, of sorts. It made sense as the result of his sins. He overreached himself once too many times. He thought he could control Bajor--he couldn't. He thought he could control the Dominion--he couldn't. He thought he could control the Pah-Wraiths...and they destroyed him.

That's the only section of stories of yours I haven't gotten to yet. When I actually have a chance to sit at the computer without other distractions, I'm gonna dig in. I'm Cardassian obsessed. It's an addiction. :cardie:

Welcome to the club! ;)
 
Quote:
That's the only section of stories of yours I haven't gotten to yet. When I actually have a chance to sit at the computer without other distractions, I'm gonna dig in. I'm Cardassian obsessed. It's an addiction. :cardie:
Welcome to the club! ;)

It's contagious! Agh! Though on a more serious note, well done on your fanfic and taking the big step in writing it. A great insight into Tabin and of course Garak's origins. good stuff.
 
Wonderful story. Very well written - you made both Tain and Mila believable to me, and it adds a dimension to Garak that's very interesting.

I look forward to more stories from you!
 
I'm going to echo everone else and say bravo to an excellent piece of CardassianLit (I could not bring myself to say CardieLit).

And it's quite interesting to read what both you and Nerys Ghemor have written about Dukat. The sense that he could have been a better man and that he could have had a better end is a powerful dramatic theme. A complex figure at the height of power in his peoples power structure with the desire and ambition to reach the top, Dukat certainly is a great character.

In fact, if I may bring B5 briefly into the discussion, he is the Anti-Londo. Basically both characters are (or claim to be) intensely loyal to their nation and would make whatever sacrifices they can to protect their people. Both have made unwise alliances (Londo with the Shadows and Dukat with the Dominion/Pah-Wraith) and both end up causing the devastation of their homeworlds and the deaths of untold millions. The difference is that Londo is truly loyal to the Centauri people and only commits such dark deeds in order to restore his people to glory. However once he realises what he has done, he undertakes to correct his mistakes even if he costs him his life (or his soul). Dukat makes the deal with the devil to ensure that he will achieve ultimate power for himself because, to paraphrase Louis XIV, he is Cardassia and his success his Cardassia's success.
This is mostly subconscious and I don't think that Dukat himself is truly aware of it but it is definitely there. Besides as PsGarak said in my thread 'why the Cardassians are the most interesting race in the Star Trek Galaxy', the average Cardassian operates on several different levels at any one time.

Please note that I would not so blindly psychoanalyse a major historical figure like Dukat in the real world as their are always other forces at work shaping us all but I think that it suits the theme of the excellent story.
Besides I have not even started on my favorite Cardassian (and usernamesake) Corat Damar...


That's the only section of stories of yours I haven't gotten to yet. When I actually have a chance to sit at the computer without other distractions, I'm gonna dig in. I'm Cardassian obsessed. It's an addiction. :cardie:
I too would like to welcome you to the Cardassian Gang we have bottles of the finest Kanar and many fine examples of Cardassian culture to enjoy.

I also hope that you'll be writing some more PSGarak you have a great talent.:bolian:
 
I don't know...I think getting fans to "buy" a conversion would've been hard. It's happened in real life (St. Paul, for instance), but even THEN it usually has to happen in a pretty extreme way to get someone like that to truly feel the weight of his sins, and I'm not sure fans would buy it, despite the real-life precedent.

But it does also make sense to me that when he lost Ziyal, he lost whatever connections he had to the part of himself that might've been redeemable. And I can accept what happened as a tragic fall, of sorts. It made sense as the result of his sins. He overreached himself once too many times. He thought he could control Bajor--he couldn't. He thought he could control the Dominion--he couldn't. He thought he could control the Pah-Wraiths...and they destroyed him.

It is so odd that you mentioned Paul, formerly Saul of Tarsus, because I have often made the association between the two in my own mind. I saw Ziyal's death as having the potential to be his wake up call rather than his dissolution. During most of his life, at least what we were given to see of it, the losses he suffered seemed to be mostly ego blows.

I think Ziyal's death, and possibly the death of his father, although I question the latter, were some of the only hits he took straight to the heart. I hoped that maybe in losing Ziyal, he would come to the awareness that some of the things he wanted to do had too high of a price and that perhaps he could become the person she saw him to be because he still loved her. However, it was not to be, and while I appreciated the tragic fall, I didn't appreciate the cartoonish handling of the Fire Caves. All it lacked was a pencil mustache, a monocle, and a top hat to be over the top cliche villain.
 
Last edited:
It's contagious! Agh! Though on a more serious note, well done on your fanfic and taking the big step in writing it. A great insight into Tabin and of course Garak's origins. good stuff.

:lol: Quite contagious!

Thank you very much! It did feel like a big step. Although I would have liked to have more time, it was a situation where I literally awakened out of sleep and pretty much had it in my head. That doesn't happen to me often, but when it does, I've found the best way to exorcise it is just to write. I'm very glad to hear you enjoyed it.
 
Wonderful story. Very well written - you made both Tain and Mila believable to me, and it adds a dimension to Garak that's very interesting.

I look forward to more stories from you!

Thank you, and likewise! When I read your story, I found myself liking the nuversions of everyone pretty much instantly. The reworked universe has a lot of room to take things in all sorts of new directions. I hope you do a sequel so we can find out who sabotaged the ship.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top