Most badass captain?

[stonester1]

im surprised sisko is hailed by so many as the hight of badassery. i never really saw him as much of a badass.

I guess he did things that other Captains wouldn't have dared to do... like poison a planet.

Or punch out Q.

 

[maneth]

Archer in season 3 & 4. Otherwise Kirk.

 

[captcalhoun]

Mackenzie Calhoun

James T. Kirk was moving through the market place, packed with locals. Suddenly the crowd parted, there was Mackenzie Calhoun, swinging his pathetic sword back and forth. Weary of the display, Kirk pulls his type one phaser
and casually disintergrates Calhoun. Kirk continues through the market place.

Calhoun walks up to Kirk in a bar. Punchs Kirk. Snaps his neck as he does. Walks out.

 

[KobayashiMaru13]

im surprised sisko is hailed by so many as the hight of badassery. i never really saw him as much of a badass.

I guess he did things that other Captains wouldn't have dared to do... like poison a planet.

Or punch out Q.

IMO punching Q was his real act of badassness.

 

[Vonstadt]

Kirk. either of them hands down.

With Sisko coming a very close second

Vons

 

[Withers]

Sisko did some pretty bad ass things (as mentioned- poisoning a planet, punching Q, facing down a Dominion fleet with one ship etc) but I wouldn't feel "uncool" if we were to hang out, ya know what I mean? He was bold. Sure. There's no questioning that. But was he really bad ass? When I hear that term I automatically think of Jim Kirk.

He was a womanizing, space faring cowboy who I would feel totally lame hanging out with. (Note: I'm not talking about William Shatner. I'd feel okay about hanging out with him.)

My vote goes to Kirk with Sisko in second. The other Captains, while each great in certain respects, do not meet my standard for bad-assery. I can conceede that they each had their bad ass moments though. (Janeway with her guns, Picard deciding to ram the Enterprise into the Scimitar, Archer cutting off Phloxs' head...)

-Withers-​

 

[Eleanor_zhDarjel]

Robau. I am a proud defender of his badassnes after all.

If someone could stand in his shadow it would be Sisco. I just love it when he hits Q.

 

[SilentP]

Hmmm, hard to decide, I'll have to think about this one.

One I'll have to mention though for consideration is Rachel Garrett (I think her name is), captain of the Enterprise-C. Sure in the alternate history she gets killed before she heads out to her final battle, but the intention is still there. Go back in time for certain death to avert a war that will destroy the Federation.

 

[Orcus]

Kirk - no one else can beat their opponent down with their butt like he can...

 

[Anika Hanson]

Mackenzie Calhoun

Definitley!!

In this poll I picked Kirk

 

[Vanyel]

Captain Rachel Garrett. She was ready, willing and able to take her damaged ship back into battle against 4 Romulan Warbirds knowing she would lose, just for - from her point of view - a chance to stop the Federation Klingon War before it began.

 

[vess]

Easily, Jean-Luc Picard. Easily.

 

[KobayashiMaru13]

i guess the robau fans have come out of hiding, since he's suddenly catchin up.

 

[Amasov]

Sisko. When he fights, it's just awesome. "HOO! HWA! RAH!"

 

[Geckothan]

Robau as badass as he may be, only appeared for a couple of minutes in an awful movie, so he doesn't count. My vote goes to Sisko.

 

[Training]

Robau - Redshirt
Sisko - Poisoned a planet. Took on 2,000 ships with a tiny one. Lead a war,punched Q and was complicit in the murder of a completely innocent man.

 

[ndcarlin]

Kirk, followed closely by Jellicoe for laying down the law on the Enterprise

 

[Flying Spaghetti Monster]

You do whatever it takes, Mister Worf."

--Sisko

 

[Infinitus]

The Sisko is the most badass. He punched Q, an omnipotent being. You can't out awesome that.

 

[Aquarius]

No joke, it's Jim Kirk. He went through more alien women and Red Shirts than the rest of 'em!