• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Mirror, Mirror Conundrum

It's also fairly obvious that there was a split somewhere along the way. Earth wasn't always that way, but became so because of something. My money is on the reaction to the Eugenics war was different somehow, making everyone more prone to violence.
ENT's FC callback seems to strongly imply that the canonical split point was Zefram Cochrane's response to first contact with the Vulcans.
I used to think there was a point of divergence between the Prime Universe and the MU, but now I think why should there be? It's a parallel universe, not an alternate timeline, and we shouldn't treat them as though they're the same thing.

I now think it's much more intriguing to imagine a Mirror Universe where history was always different from our version, but it's just similar enough to the Prime Universe to be disturbing. When Gardner Fox first introduced Earth-3 in JLA #29 (where the Crime Syndicate existed instead of the Justice League or the Justice Society), he teased that their history was significantly different, with Christopher Columbus discovering Europe, the British winning their independence from America, and actor Abraham Lincoln assassinating President John Wilkes Booth. Who's to say that history didn't unfold in some twisted parallel to our own in the MU?

It also had shots of a warlike past in the opening titles, and Mirror Phlox noted that their famous works of literature were similar but different.
This is the way. :techman: I remember in Diane Duane's TNG novel Dark Mirror, she had a sequence where Picard looked at the collected Shakespeare in his counterpart's ready room and discovered that in the Mirror Universe version of "The Merchant of Venice," Shylock actually collected his pound of flesh, so the implication was that the MU was different from at least 1596.
 
Goes even farther back than that. Picard notes that Aristotle is unchanged, but, in the MU Iliad, Achilles kills Priam on his knees rather than letting him take Hector's body back to Troy for burial. A check of the other books in Mirror Picard's library shows that divergences become more common as the books come closer to present day. Some are unchanged (Kipling, for example), but Picard decides not to check out the King James Bible. I don't think I'd want to know what the MU version of that book looks like, either.
 
In a TOS-only continuity, I like to think that the Mirror Universe is a direct result of McCoy, City on the Edge of Forever, and the Nazis winning World War 2. The ISS Enterprise never found the Time Planet, and was thankfully not there for the stranded landing party to contact.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top