• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Mirror, Mirror Conundrum

Spock's Barber

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
I know it’s only an hour long episode so not every twist can be explained, but Kirk and friends are trapped in the mirror universe where situations and personalities are the opposite. Yet in both universes the Halkans seem to be of the same temperament : docile and non-belligerent.

Additionally, mirror Spock describes McCoy as “soft, sentimental”. Wait a Vulcan 🖖 second…shouldn’t mirror McCoy be cruel and inhuman?

I’m hunkered down in my cavern on Exo III, so fire your opinions and comments in my direction. Incoming!!!
 
Yet in both universes the Halkans seem to be of the same temperament : docile and non-belligerent.

Perhaps in the MU it's a front.

Additionally, mirror Spock describes McCoy as “soft, sentimental”.

Comparatively speaking - compared to MU Vulcan logic, that is. Soft = weak. Sentimental = ruled by emotions.
 
I believe the MU can only exist as a small, temporary "bubble" that was flashed into existence by the collision of ion storm and transporter beam. It's a bad Xerox copy, close in some ways (the ship, the Halkans, McCoy), but way off in others (Kirk, Sulu, the Empire...).

Spock, Scotty, Uhura, and Chekov might be exactly the same in both universes, but behaving differently because they find themselves in different moral circumstances.

The "inaccurate flash copy" theory is the only way to explain how such different Earth histories could produce lookalike individuals doing the same jobs on the Enterprise.

I do not account for spin-off excursions to the Mirror Universe (DS9, ENT), unless they too are small, temporary bubbles, "just now" flashed into existence to copy exact individuals, but somehow have a memory of Kirk's MU. It's theoretical thin ice, but Jesus those were fun episodes.
 
I know it’s only an hour long episode so not every twist can be explained, but Kirk and friends are trapped in the mirror universe where situations and personalities are the opposite. Yet in both universes the Halkans seem to be of the same temperament : docile and non-belligerent.
Calling it the Mirror Universe is really just poetic license. The episode itself makes it pretty clear that only Starfleet and the Enterprise are different in this universe. There's no reason to assume that, say, the Klingons would be peaceful, or the Vulcans would be illogical, there.

Additionally, mirror Spock describes McCoy as “soft, sentimental”. Wait a Vulcan 🖖 second…shouldn’t mirror McCoy be cruel and inhuman?
Here, I think you have to ask yourself exactly what would count as "soft and sentimental" in the Mirror Universe. Remember, Prime McCoy says that he found the sickbay of his MU counterpart to be a "chamber of horrors" with two of his assistants betting on how long it would take an injured man to pass out from the pain. That's not exactly soft.

Mirror Spock is also comparing his McCoy to Mirror Kirk when he says he has a plentitude of human weaknesses. So maybe Mirror McCoy is only soft and sentimental in comparison to Kirk.

SPOCK: I shall make that decision. Since your return from the planet, you've behaved in a most atypical and illogical manner. I want to know why.
KIRK: Shoot. You're wasting time.
SPOCK: I shall not waste time with you. You're too inflexible, too disciplined once you've made up your mind. But Doctor McCoy has a plenitude of human weaknesses, sentimental, soft. You may not tell me what I want to know, but he will.
 
Calling it the Mirror Universe is really just poetic license. The episode itself makes it pretty clear that only Starfleet and the Enterprise are different in this universe. There's no reason to assume that, say, the Klingons would be peaceful, or the Vulcans would be illogical, there.
Yeah, my interpretation is that it's a 'road not travelled' kind of story, where we see how things could've been if Federation culture represented the worst of humanity/vulcanity instead of the best. They just met the Halkans so they've had no influence on them yet, while in DS9's future everyone has been interacting with the Terrans for so long that the ripples have spread out and no one's the same anymore.
 
If you look at the Halkans, they're the worse for wear from meeting Imperial Kirk and co. I'd call that influence.

It's also fairly obvious that there was a split somewhere along the way. Earth wasn't always that way, but became so because of something. My money is on the reaction to the Eugenics war was different somehow, making everyone more prone to violence.
 
I've sometimes wondered if humanity in the MU picked up the "moral inversion" from the Vulcans. Mirror Spock is a ruthlessly logical killer, and Sulu's reaction to his Vulcan operatives line seems to indicate the rest of the Vulcan race is the same. There's nothing inherent in logic that requires you to be a pacifist; pick the proper base set of precepts, and you can make a logical argument to justify it. If Mirror Surak applied a logical approach to a martial philosophy, you could very well wind up with Mirror Spock & co. That raises the interesting possibility that the Mirror Universe doesn't have a Romulan Empire, because the more warlike ancient Vulcans would have had no pacifist culture to break away from.
 
Considering that a lot of the time the MU people have the maturity level and impulse control of a two-year-old on a sugar rush, I'm pretty sure Spock realized something had gone majorly wrong the moment Mirror Kirk stepped off the transporter pad and ordered the annihilation of the Halkans.
 
I would have liked to see more of the Empire's barbarians on the USS Enterprise and what tipped Spock into rounding them all up.
Yes. That's the main thing I wish the episode could've delved into a little more. They obviously didn't fool Spock for long, but I'd love to see if Mirror Kirk & company were crafty enough to pretend to be their counterparts for at least a little while.

BTW, it was years before I realized I was slightly mishearing Mirror Kirk at the beginning of that scene. He says "I order you... Let me go!" when the security guards are taking him to the brig, but for ages I heard it as "I own you... Let me go!" It still fit the Evil Kirk's characterization, so I never questioned it.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Some great posts in this thread. I especially like this one:
Mirror Spock is a ruthlessly logical killer, and Sulu's reaction to his Vulcan operatives line seems to indicate the rest of the Vulcan race is the same.
Yes!! There are so many wonderful dialogue and acting touches in "MM." Mirror-Sulu and Mirror-Spock are clearly communicating quite well when M-Spock delivers that operatives line and M-Sulu reacts with disgust and clear fear at the prospect of M-Spock's death being avenged in a Vulcan manner. We even see such a Vulcan operative, shadowing M-Spock down the corridor while Farrell shadows Kirk, after Kirk witnesses M-Chekov's agony booth session.

As for the Halkans, I've always viewed them as a sort of "focal point in time" like Edith Keeler, only they're a bit more of a "focal point in timelines." The intersection of the universes, or the creation of the parallel universe by the ion storm, happened in orbit around Halka (if that's the name of the planet?), so they're the same in both universes.
 
I've always said there are really only two lead actors in the franchise that truly understood what their Mirror Universe counterparts were supposed to be like: Leonard Nimoy and Colm Meaney.

Here, Nimoy understands that the Mirror Universe isn't evil by nature, they are essentially the same only with their filters removed and baser nature close to the forefront. Mirror Spock was basically exactly like our Spock, only real difference is he was more ruthless in his application of logic. It's why he was so compelling there.

Same with Meaney: same decent, hard working everyman but just no problem at all using shady methods and tactics to get the job done.


I also have to credit Vaughn Armstrong. He understood this, too. Just wasn't a lead actor. He was an honorable man (by the standards of their respective universes) in both places.
 
It's also fairly obvious that there was a split somewhere along the way. ... My money is on the reaction to the Eugenics war was different somehow, making everyone more prone to violence.
I've sometimes wondered if humanity in the MU picked up the "moral inversion" from the Vulcans.
ENT's FC callback seems to strongly imply that the canonical split point was Zefram Cochrane's response to first contact with the Vulcans.

It's not hard to imagine that the baseline cause would logically have been that the Borg and Ent-E never traveled back to that time in that universe. Riker and Troi weren't there to tell Cochrane that this visit was historic, safe, and good; so "Zee" reacted as though the aliens were invaders, setting the would-be architects of the Federation on a course of mistrust and violence.

There would have been no "noble" Federation or "straight-laced" Picard to catch Q's attention as interesting playthings, and thus no early introduction to the Borg. No Locutus, no time-missions back to Earth to prevent/preserve the formation of the UFP. No astronauts on some kind of star trek that would have ensured their own positive future.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top