• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Military/engineering type fandom: Should DSC embrace technicality?

The Apple Store sells the newest version of Kirk's captain's log, and every time I go to CVS Pharmacy, they give me a yard-long receipt from something that looks just like Spock's science station printer. ;)

I think they're singlehandedly responsible for deforestation.
SkSOwoz.jpg
 
People come to Trek and watch Trek for their own reasons. Some people really get into the hardware and technical specifications and that's cool if you're into that kind of thing and keep it in perspective. Other people are more into the characters, or the social allegories, or the optimistic vision of the future, or the space opera excitement, or the far-out sci-fi concepts and exotic aliens or whatever. A certain degree of consistency regarding the tech is probably not a bad thing, but I suspect that most viewers aren't going to care or notice if the starboard auxiliary deflector array switches location from one series to another. :)

Says the guy who, honestly, cannot tell a Ford from a Chevy and tends to scratch my head when folks see vast differences between the various different versions of the Enterprise. As long as it's got a saucer and a couple of nacelles, it looks like the Enterprise to me . . . .

I am way way way more into Trek for its characters and stories, even its narrative history and production history, than any of the treknology. I do t get fans who get excited by the existence of the Defiant, the battles with the Borg, with what might be described as the pew pew and the boom.
BUT
As other posters have said, it does absolutely make for better world building, it absolutely is part of how the vast vast majority of Trek (basically everything from about 1984 on...when the okudas and Zimmerman and sternbach are bringing a high degree of professionalism to the job, and actually thinking about things like why and how) works. I don’t get the ‘I can’t tell the differences between the enterprises’ stuff either. There is a lineage, there are things you can see, there are design languages at play. Ds9 is absolutely the ultimate for this, with the Cardassian design language, the Bajoran styles too.
It is what seoerates trek from ray gun gothic stuff (TOS included tbh) and stuff where you stick a coffee machine on a hairdryer and stick a window on it.
My favourite episode is probably The Offspring, which depends on zero of these things (to be fair I don’t think I have a favourite episode anymore, but that used to be it.) but it is absolutely Of importanace to me as a viewer and a fan. And not paying attention to these things, at least to some extent, is just lazy.
 
Antimatter as fuel is pretty common place in SF lit. Probably where TOS nicked it.
That might be true but as I said, it's a sound engineering principle as opposed to, say, Star Wars, where a flick of a leaver activities non-specific engines to enter 'hyperspace'. Even Battlestar Galactica, which used real world equipment on the bridge, just used a made up fuel to activate hyperspace travel.
 
Ah yes, but I meant the core engineering ideas were sound.

TOS did waver quite a bit into very vague scenarios regarding power failure, engine failure, shield failure, and to this day, nobody really gets Impulse engines.

Impulse engines are pretty much explained in their name.
 
That might be true but as I said, it's a sound engineering principle as opposed to, say, Star Wars, where a flick of a leaver activities non-specific engines to enter 'hyperspace'. Even Battlestar Galactica, which used real world equipment on the bridge, just used a made up fuel to activate hyperspace travel.
One word: Dilithium.
 
One word: Dilithium.
Also true, because the amount of energy required to warp space would exceed the amount you can get from an anti-matter explosion so a fictional substance was invented to plug the science gap. It's fictional but there are scientific and engineering principles surrounding its inclusion.
 
Impulse engines are pretty much explained in their name.
It's not clear if they use ions to propel the ship or just plasma. Later movies imply plasma.

As an aside, this is why I hate elements in the reboot movies. A ship of that size and shape using a plasma drive in Earth's atmosphere looks offensive to science, although please any scientists or engineers feel free to contradict me.
 
It's not clear if they use ions to propel the ship or just plasma. Later movies imply plasma.

It’s high energy stream of something pushing the ship along...impulses...like an impellor. Newtonian basically. Mean I could be wrong, but it seems logical to me, and my speciality is words these days.
 
I said it was sound, not complicated . That said, I don't recall any other sci fi show of that era using it.
You know that there was a vast amount of written material dating back decades that skiffy shows mined, right?
 
It’s high energy stream of something pushing the ship along...impulses...like an impellor. Newtonian basically. Mean I could be wrong, but it seems logical to me, and my speciality is words these days.
Yeah, I think scientists have demonstrated that ions or plasma would work , although presumably acceleration would be an issue.
 
You know that there was a vast amount of written material dating back decades that skiffy shows mined, right?
Well yes, but I thought the thread was discussing whether a TV show should use engineering principles and technical specs to assist with world building and suspension of disbelief? I didn't think that Star Trek invented anti-matter.
 
A name based on stuff we use to store energy now, with a sound naming convention applied, Being used as basically a capacitor to control energy flow in future engines?

Makes sense to me.
Which is also basic SF. Ad a prefix to something and make it sound futuristic.
 
There are lots of things that Star Trek still overlooks, such as how the different species cope with cross-contamimated biomes, or just breathing bacteria onto another planet. Space herpes must be rife .
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top