• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Maps "canon" thoughts

Which map is more "canon"

  • Star Trek Star Charts book

    Votes: 11 36.7%
  • This one - [url]http://www.stdimension.org/int/Cartography/Atlas.htm[/url]

    Votes: 2 6.7%
  • Neither

    Votes: 17 56.7%

  • Total voters
    30
The 1980 Star Trek Maps had that great guide to navigation booklet. When I first read it I spent weeks figuring courses between star systems out to the tenth decimal point. Fun.
 
Because it actually makes an attempt to show the space involved in three dimensions. And it's not cluttered up with a bunch of post-TOS stuff.
 
There's nothing to say Cardassians wern't "around" in the TOS era. We just never saw them - just like the Suliban and the Xindi. Remember we only saw the TOS universe from the perspective of one ship. Who knows? Had Enterprise carried on we may have gotten a first contact episode.

Don't forget there was a Cardassian in exile on Vulcan right around the time of Enterprise. First Contact with Cardassia probably wasn't the 24th Century.
 
There's nothing to say Cardassians wern't "around" in the TOS era. We just never saw them - just like the Suliban and the Xindi. Remember we only saw the TOS universe from the perspective of one ship. Who knows? Had Enterprise carried on we may have gotten a first contact episode.

Don't forget there was a Cardassian in exile on Vulcan right around the time of Enterprise. First Contact with Cardassia probably wasn't the 24th Century.

That's why I go with the "trade embargo" theory. That allows for Iloja of Prim, and a passing knowledge of the race, but if that's forbidden territory for Federation trade, that would explain why we hear almost nothing until the turn of the 24th century where the first REAL contact was--when the Federation's borders finally butted up against the Cardassian border to the point where the Union took it as a threat.
 
In DS9, it also looks like Cardassia would enjoy a thick buffer of vassal states and allies in the spaces surrounding Bajor (at least Klaestron, Kressari, Xepolite, Yridian, perhaps also Ferengi). Perhaps the Union preferred to interact through such intermediaries for most of the early centuries of Earth starflight?

Timo Saloniemi
 
Shouldn't it be "neither...reflect"?

"A does not reflect, and B does not reflect, in fact, nether of them reflect..."

Neither [ONE] . . . reflects. The "one" is implied.

It doesn't matter how many "of them" there possibly are. For instance: Only one person out of a million winS in the lotto. The "out of a million" is irrelevant. Just the subject, "one" is relevant. So it takes a singular verb ending in "s." (The "s" at the end of singular verbs can stand for "singular," as a mnemonic device, if we need one btw.

Another example: Either of the two choices IS acceptable to me. "One" is implied. Either one IS acceptable. It doesn't matter that it's out of two (or two thousand) choices.

Only one out of a thousand people knowS this rule, btw.

BONUS: What does Kirk do grammatically wrong in the famous prologue he recites in the opening credits? It flooded the NBC switchboards, since many people knew grammar in '66. Anybody else out there know?
 
Well, split infinitives were considered wrong in standard English because they are impossible. If one's view of correct grammar is how people actually speak, then of course s-i's are fine. But then, so are overused apostrophe's.

They are of the devil, but many (most?) people do them.
 
split infinitives are not wrong in English. it's Latin where you can't split the infinitive.

Agreed. The Victorians can take their split infinitives and shove them where the sun doesn't shine.

Indeed. This was a Latin rule imposed upon a Germanic language because of some academics' dumb idea that Latin and its grammar represented the epitome of all languages. And Germanic languages, for the most part, do split infinitives. Some even REQUIRE them at certain times and if you don't, you sound like...well, what is "n00b" in German? ;)
 
They are of the devil, but many (most?) people do them.
Indeed. So many philistines pronounce the silent letter in "often" that some dictionaries now list that as an acceptable alternate pronounciation.
That is the sort of behavior up with which I shall not put.
 
They are of the devil, but many (most?) people do them.
Indeed. So many philistines pronounce the silent letter in "often" that some dictionaries now list that as an acceptable alternate pronounciation.
That is the sort of behavior up with which I shall not put.

Ask them what they are lisTening to on their iPod, and see if they get the hint. They won't.

O tempora! O mores! How far must civilization decline before the Roddenb-era of perfectness begins? Then all will be right again. LisTen - I can hear him coming now. Let me hasTen to my window so I may see the Great Bird as he return's with heeling in his wing's.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top