• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Lower Decks General Discussion Thread

Rob is a great guy.

I also think he does a good job articulating criticisms of contemporary Star Trek.
 
What does his tweet say? I’m blocked by him on twitter even though I have literally never, ever posted a single tweet myself. :borg:
 
What does his tweet say? I’m blocked by him on twitter even though I have literally never, ever posted a single tweet myself. :borg:

I think this is the one...

STAR TREK is ELITIST. It's about the very best of humanity. It shows us a universe where humanity has evolved to be GREAT at what it does. For the past eleven years...TREK has been dumbed down to appeal to the every person. The trailer for LOWER DECKS is the nadir of TREK.
 
Wait, so the guy is holding up elitism as an ideal?

There's an argument to be made somewhere in that general direction for Trek, but that's about the worst way he could have phrased it.
To be fair, the early seasons of TNG (ostensibly “real” Trek) was full of smug elitism against cultures deemed to be inferior to Federation sensibilities. Particularly looking down upon any culture with a faith-based system (the Edo, Mintakans, etc.), and lest we forget that wonderful example of extreme elitism (and just about every other kind of “ism” one can think of), “Code of Honor”. :barf:
 
To be fair, the early seasons of TNG (ostensibly “real” Trek) was full of smug elitism against cultures deemed to be inferior to Federation sensibilities. Particularly looking down upon any culture with a faith-based system (the Edo, Mintakans, etc.), and lest we forget that wonderful example of extreme elitism (and just about every other kind of “ism” one can think of), “Code of Honor”. :barf:
Of course, but the sensible thing to do is to try to rebrand that as something positive, not to say, "Yay, elitism!"
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top