If I remember correctly, there are no love triangle episodes for TOS. (e.g. Kirk likes the girl but she likes Spock.) Is there some reason why they didn't use this common plot device?
Love triangle episode?
- Thread starter Laura Cynthia Chambers
- Start date
Cos Shatner does not share.....
Not between series regulars as far as I know, but McCoy does call the tragic relationship between Kirk/Rayna/Flint an 'eternal triangle'.
If Edith Keeler hadn't been flattened there might have been some triangle with Kirk and McCoy.
That totally counts as a love triangle! There's a few others as well.
-Wink of an Eye. Deela & Kirk...and Rael(one of the few episodes where Kirk actually get his boots knocked off)
-Is there no truth in beauty? Almost a love quadrilateral, between Spock, Kollos, Dr. Miranda Jones, and Kirk...wait...and that other guy who loved Miranda.
That other episode with Diane Muldaur has a love triangle between the three aliens.
If you use your imagination, Day of the Dove maybe.
All our Yesterdays sort of has a love triangle angle.
There's a definite love triangle in the episode where Kirk lose his memory and becomes a Native American.
Kirk becomes a 3rd wheel in The Cloud
Minders.
City on The Edge could have had that scenario if Edith had survived the truck agreed, what about Kirk, Nona and Tyree though? Kirk didn't want to step on Tyree's toes but Nona wanted Kirk's powers and weapons so used the roots and her allure to draw him in! Kellinda and Rojan were also triangles as were The Scalosians in Wink of an eye but the best one has to be Requiem For Methuselah with Kirk, Rayna and flint as you said!
JB
JB
Most of those involve two alien/guest characters though, not rivalry among the big 3 while two or more compete for the affections of the same girl.
Last edited:
I would agree that Kirk and Mara's interactions in 'Day of the Dove' bordered upon romance. Joanne Linville's Romulan commander in 'The Enterprise Incident' seemed to have "tension" with Kirk and Spock that went beyond espionage and galactic cold-war intrigue
TOS had a love triangle baked into the premise: Kirk, girl of the week, and the Enterprise.
True, but the Enterprise didn't try to kill or at least argue with the girl.
The best love triangle never happened. If Helen Noel had been the ship's doctor instead of McCoy, her constant interactions with Kirk and Spock would have been fascinating. Big "McCoy" episodes, especially "The Empath," would have been twice as electric.
Elaan put Kirk in a sort of triangle, with their getting involved while she was going off to be married.
Enterprise saved her captain, too.
Enterprise saved her captain, too.
I agree with Laura. Between the leads and a woman, it never happened. I disagree with the suggestions.
The Enterprise Incident? I don't recall any spark between Kirk and the Commander.
City on the Edge? Between Edith, Kirk, and McCoy? Nope.
All Our Yesterdays? Between Spock, McCoy, and Zarabeth? I didn't detect any attraction between McCoy and Zarabeth.
The Enterprise Incident? I don't recall any spark between Kirk and the Commander.
City on the Edge? Between Edith, Kirk, and McCoy? Nope.
All Our Yesterdays? Between Spock, McCoy, and Zarabeth? I didn't detect any attraction between McCoy and Zarabeth.
Remember, McCoy was just coming out of his overdosed state. Give him a little time sober and he might be attracted to her compassion for others...
Two men, one woman. If they had been trapped back in time long enough, McCoy would feel like the lonely third wheel.
McCoy was already asking Edith out, but Edith politely turned him down. I saw no sparks between them the way that she and Kirk had both felt something.
He might have developed one-sided feelings for her...she's got "stars" in her eyes because of Kirk at the moment.
Similar threads
