• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Lost 5x12: "Deas is Dead"

Grade the episode...


  • Total voters
    19
I voted Excellent for this episode.

No idea what "Dead Is Dead" is going to be like, though...
 
Apparently Desmond adding an extra A to his name wasn't enough to throw Ben off his trail! :eek:

Hopefully Pennny is still okay.
 
^ I voted below average! This episode was a Yawn. It did have it's good points, but I wished I could have seen the rest of the cast. The peeps in the 70's are more interesting to me then Ben, Locke, etc.
 
I voted excellent because we got 'answers' regards the smoke monster and I thought its judgement of Ben was a very cool scene that made the Monster seem very scary and it harked back to Eko's death and the time he was confronted by the Monster and we saw the images within the smoke.

We always knew it was tied to the Island and this showed just how much so and unlike the impression before were we thought Ben could control it we see he really was scared by it and had no control but merely could summon it.

Still its motivations are vague and scary. Was Ben spared in his judgement because it judged him right, did it want Alex dead afterall and the fact he allowed her death to occur meant he was freed. Or was it because Penny was spared by Ben in the end. Which was another bit of a cop out bu the writers. Sorta glad but at the same time. Or will Ben merely get a stay of execution. Eko did eventually get thrashed badly by the Monster in the end.

Plus we [think we] know Ben doesn't know the others were in Dharma back then. Obviously a reset button but he did go back to the Dharma village so is it the case they were not there? Has La Fleur and Kate's actions jepordised their standing in Dharmaville?

Plus Locke really seems to have the will of the island.

One nitpick is that Widmore's banishment was a bit lame.

Is the Temple waht lies in the shadow of the statue? Didn't think the statue casted much of a shadow nowadays.

Want to see the Temple now. Really would love if we could find out about that far off civilisation. The whomever others from Ancient times.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top