• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Lord of the Rings TV series

In the films, Elrond doesn't believe in the nobility of Men, nor does he have any faith in or love for Aragorn despite Arwen having promised herself to him (Aragorn), which is why it's a significant turnaround for him (Elrond) to reforge Narsil and deliver it to Aragorn, which are actions he takes only because Arwen is dying.

If Arwen isn't Elrond's only child, the fact that her impending death is what convinces him to abandon his distrust of Men and offer Aragorn his support doesn't make sense.
Any parent is going to react strongly like this to a child dying, even if they are not their only child. Especially if that child is an elf who isn't supposed to ever dye.
Every one of their children is important to a parent, so they're not going to just shrug their shoulders and move on if one of them is dying.
 
I really hope that poster with the horse sword isn't referencing Rohan. I can handle pre-Shire Hobbits showing up early but Rohan's origin story is specifically tied to Gondor.

Otherwise those costumes and props look pretty damn awesome.
 
Any parent is going to react strongly like this to a child dying, even if they are not their only child. Especially if that child is an elf who isn't supposed to ever die.
Every one of their children is important to a parent, so they're not going to just shrug their shoulders and move on if one of them is dying.
I agree with this analysis. In real history, even Victorians such as Charles Darwin could be traumatised by the death of a single child even if they had other children and child mortality back then was a persistent fact of life.

Talking of elves dying, like men, their spirits supposedly go to the Halls of Mandos in Valinor unless they are specifically excluded from Aman by the Valar as Galadriel is until she was forgiven after the War of the Ring ended. After some time in the Halls, elves would be re-embodied and dwell in Aman, unlike the spirits of men who go to some other realm known only to Mandos and Manwë. I'm not sure what happens to the spirits of excluded elves who suffer physical death in Middle-earth.
 
Regarding the poster of a figure wearing Elvish-esque armour and clasping a duel gold and silver sword hilt…
CR03__IGStory_TikTok-768x1365.jpg
…web speculation is that this hilt comprises stylised gold and silver representations of the two trees of Valinor - Laurelin (the golden tree) and Telperion (the silver tree) - as seen distantly in the initial image released by Amazon, some months ago:

220119121117-the-rings-of-power-lord-of-the-rings-amazon-large-169.jpg


Makes sense, and also speculated that the wielder of this sword may well be Galadriel herself.
 
Last edited:
Ha, that's one of Sauron's forms I presume. His fair form, Annatar, was lost to him following the destruction of Númenor and the reshaping of Arda towards the end of the Second Age.

Yeah, not the longest hilt, so likely a dagger - although, cross-guard-wise, many elvish blades possessed no guards, as per the below:
To me, it looks like vestiges of guards are there, although they are tiny, more like nubs. Perhaps they were deemed unnecessary by elves, who go for the first-strike kill against their enemies and don't waste time in parrying.

The two-trees motif on the weapon's pommel in the new teaser photo is exquisitely designed.
 
Last edited:
I was watching some of the stuff about the locations from Two Towers on the Extended Edition DVD, and it got me wondering if we see locations from the movies, if they will go back to film at the same places.
 
I was watching some of the stuff about the locations from Two Towers on the Extended Edition DVD, and it got me wondering if we see locations from the movies, if they will go back to film at the same places.
Perhaps with CGI modification but not much of the action might take place there. If one compares Tolkien's maps of Middle-Earth from before and after the destruction of Númenor and the reshaping of Arda in SA 3319, one sees that Middle-earth was larger and included Beleriand. The topography of the parts that survived were probably somewhat different and, of course, the island of Númenor itself still existed. I assume there will be lots of new filming locations to cover Beleriand and Númenor. Osgiliath, not Minas Arnor (later renamed as Minas Tirith), was the capital of Gondor from SA 3320 until TA 1640. Minas Arnor was renamed Minas Tirith in TA 2002 after Minas Ithil was captured by the Ringwraiths and became Minas Morgul. I'm not sure of the timespan of the new series but I assume it will follow events mostly in the Second Age*.

*According to the standard chronology, Sauron arises again in Middle-earth circa SA 500; guided by Sauron as Annatar, the Rings of Power are forged between circa SA 1500 and 1600; Sauron establishes himself as Zigûr circa SA 3300; Númenor is destroyed and Arda is reshaped in SA 3319; Isildur defeats Sauron in SA 3441.
 
Last edited:
On the note of the chronology, I wouldn't be opposed to the TV show basically compressing the major events of the Second Age (spanning from the forging of the Rings to the War of the Last Alliance) into a shorter span of time, just so they don't have to constantly recycle the actors playing Númenóreans and other Men. It's fine for everything to take 2000 years in the books but not so fine for a movie/show.
 
I could see them condensing things like that, or they could do it as more of anthology, with the immortals sticking around from season to season, but with new mortal characters each season.
 
Given by whom - the Tolkien literary canon (both father and son) or the TV series? The former gives approximate or exact dates in the SA; the latter we don't know yet.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top