Is it, though? As far as I am aware, her last name was only ever given on a computer display, where all the names were written in all-caps. It's possible Memory Alpha is just interpreting the capitalization incorrectly.
Lit/fanon inventions that became canon
- Thread starter Laura Cynthia Chambers
- Start date
Is it, though? As far as I am aware, her last name was only ever given on a computer display, where all the names were written in all-caps. It's possible Memory Alpha is just interpreting the capitalization incorrectly.
That's interesting, because I typed in "Betty Riker Star Trek" in Google and it immediately went to the TNG episode "Conundrum" and an onscreen personal file for "William Riker" that they used to establish their identity when their minds were wiped.
I believe the name also appears in the novel "Deny thy Father".
Riker's personnel file did not appear in "Conundrum".
Deny Thy Father calls her Annie instead of Betty.
Of course it's possible. I'm just saying it's never wise to assume a similarity has to be intentional, because coincidental similarities happen all the time. The name could be a novel reference, but we don't actually know that it is, because there's just as much chance that it's coincidence.
Which, again, leaves us in the position where it could be, but we can't actually know for sure.
Possible instance of citogenesis from the real-life Memory Alpha:
"Vulcans named Doug . . ." . . . and Susan?!?
O . . . . k.
Another teaser for SNW Season 3. As if I weren't already waiting for the DVD set with a worm on my tongue.
(I will note that I named the father of my novel's protagonist "Doug." And her mother "Anne." Nearly 3 decades ago.)
O . . . . k.
Another teaser for SNW Season 3. As if I weren't already waiting for the DVD set with a worm on my tongue.
(I will note that I named the father of my novel's protagonist "Doug." And her mother "Anne." Nearly 3 decades ago.)
And cousin Pete. https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Pete
Enterprise: The First Adventure had Stephen, the blonde juggling Vulcan.
Another issue was that if a particular reference work got something wrong, that mistake could be compounded when it was repeated in other media. I remember that DC's Star Trek Annual #1 incorrectly gave Dr. Boyce's first name as "Joe" instead of "Phillip" because that's what The Star Trek Concordance listed.
It occurred to me, sometime after I wrote that, that the TrekLit-forum-specific exception to the dead-thread policy should also apply to review threads in series forums, because (especially with those not broadcast on the public airwaves) people could be buying DVD sets years (or even decades) after the episodes debuted.
And movie forums, too.
I think it's a matter of volume. The episode live commentary/review threads are some of the biggest and fastest-growing ones on the board. Some of the threads on the front page of the SNW forum are 80 pages long. Even the most fervently-discussed novels (one of the Coda installments, for instance) topped out at 30 pages, filled over months instead of days. Plus, people are going to remain fresher on episodes (its faster and easier to rewatch one than to reread a book), so they'll probably remember the details for a new thread. I've had to look back for my own posts in novel review threads to try and remember what I thought about a given book, on the other hand.
TrekLit, overall, has a smaller amount of traffic than the movie and TV boards, so it makes sense to collate the discussions a bit more.
That was the third family member, I thought there were three but Memory Alpha's page for Doug only mentions him and his sister.
The sidebar mentions both, but I've added him to the text of the article.
The idea that the glowing domes at the front of warp nacelles are Bussard Collectors comes from an article on Warp Drive that Geoffrey Mandel and/or Doug Drexler wrote in Star Trek Giant Poster Book #13 back in 1977. I don't have my copy handy so I'm not sure about the authorship. They seem to have come up with the idea based on Franz Joseph's "Space Energy Matter Sink/Acquisition" terminology from the Star Fleet Technical Manual (although Franz Joseph seems to have had something else in mind). Of course Robert Bussard's concept dates back to 1960.
The ithian forests referred to in PIC: "Penance" have their roots in the ithian trees from The Never Ending Sacrifice. I think.
In fact, the Bussard collector concept was introduced to TNG by illustrator/technical consultant Rick Sternbach, who knew Dr. Robert Bussard personally and had done multiple paintings illustrating the Bussard ramjet concept for Analog in 1978, Carl Sagan's Cosmos in 1980, and Science Digest in 1983, possibly among others. We know for a fact that Sternbach got the idea from its actual inventor, Bussard himself, and was already aware of it by 1977 (since the cover for an April 1978 issue would probably have had to be painted before the end of 1977). So I doubt Mandel or Drexler had anything to do with it.
Last edited:
Someone could always make a suggestion thread about it:
Maybe to enable people to find the one they want, these threads could have a thread where they're listed by title, or a subforum.
Similar threads
