• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Last Classic Who Story you watched

The linkage is mainly down to reshoots during Planet. Originally it just ended with the Doctor saying he was going after the Daleks.

Was that the result of Delgardo's death and the plan to follow on from Frontier in Space not being possible?
 
Was that the result of Delgardo's death and the plan to follow on from Frontier in Space not being possible?

No, because there was no plan for the Master to return in the very next story, and because Delgado died a month after "Planet of the Daleks" concluded its broadcast run, while he was filming a miniseries in Turkey. It was a later story that had to be scrapped.
 
Yeah it wasn't till I was reading up on Frontier after finishing it that I realised it was Delgado's last appearance :(
 
The TARDIS Wiki says that originally the two stories were going to be a single 12-part serial (although I'm not sure I believe that, given that the two serials have different writers). The reshoots were for a different reason, because Barry Letts was unsatisfied with the Ogron eater monster in the climactic episode and wanted to cut down its screen time.
Not quite sure how that's different. The ending was reshot during Planet so as to cut down use of the Ogron eater, which the Doctor originally appeared as thanks to use of the fear device. The book preserves something close to the original ending, though Hulke has the Ogron eater as a T-Rex-like creature.
 
No, because there was no plan for the Master to return in the very next story, and because Delgado died a month after "Planet of the Daleks" concluded its broadcast run, while he was filming a miniseries in Turkey. It was a later story that had to be scrapped.
The series can (or could be) found on youtube, as La Cloche Tibetaine.
 
Not quite sure how that's different. The ending was reshot during Planet so as to cut down use of the Ogron eater, which the Doctor originally appeared as thanks to use of the fear device. The book preserves something close to the original ending, though Hulke has the Ogron eater as a T-Rex-like creature.

I mean the reshoot was not done for the purpose of linking two unconnected stories together. "Frontier" was always going to lead into "Planet." The reshoot just changed the timing of how it happened.


The series can (or could be) found on youtube, as La Cloche Tibetaine.

Oh, I was wondering if Delgado's death had any effect on the miniseries's completion. Wikipedia says he only had a minor role in one episode, which makes it all the more tragic.
 
I mean the reshoot was not done for the purpose of linking two unconnected stories together. "Frontier" was always going to lead into "Planet." The reshoot just changed the timing of how it happened.
Originally, the ending was just going to be the Doctor deciding that going after the Daleks was more important than taking the Master back to jail and heading off, uninjured, without any closing TARDIS scene.
Oh, I was wondering if Delgado's death had any effect on the miniseries's completion. Wikipedia says he only had a minor role in one episode, which makes it all the more tragic.
Possibly he was going to be in more episodes, but that's only a guess.
 
Last edited:
Logopolis
I do like it when we see other parts of the TARDIS. Even when it's just a corridor

Me too, except in "The Invasion of Time" when it was just a disused hospital or whatever. It bugged me that we went through the entire first Russell T. Davies era and two whole incarnations and never saw anything but the console room (and maybe one glimpse at the wardrobe?).
 
Me too, except in "The Invasion of Time" when it was just a disused hospital or whatever. It bugged me that we went through the entire first Russell T. Davies era and two whole incarnations and never saw anything but the console room (and maybe one glimpse at the wardrobe?).
There is a transition: brick roundels. But still not great. However a strike at the BBC messed up the usual recording order (after Underworld overspent on the spaceship in episode one, Williams was pressured to end the series early. He worked it out by saving money on Underworld and Invasion).
 
Logopolis
I do like it when we see other parts of the TARDIS. Even when it's just a corridor

Me too, except in "The Invasion of Time" when it was just a disused hospital or whatever. It bugged me that we went through the entire first Russell T. Davies era and two whole incarnations and never saw anything but the console room (and maybe one glimpse at the wardrobe?).
Yeah, it kind of buggs me that we see so little of the TARDIS, especially compared to other sci-fi shows like the Star Treks or Farscape, where they were constantly showing us tons of different parts of their ships. It's a big ship, and really important to the show, but we rarely ever see more than the one room.
 
I suspect the thinking is that, much like the Doctor's backstory, the specifics of the rest of the TARDIS are best left to the viewers' imagination.
 
I suspect the thinking is that, much like the Doctor's backstory, the specifics of the rest of the TARDIS are best left to the viewers' imagination.

Yeah, but they eventually filled in the Doctor's backstory. When a show runs for decades, you have to fill in the gaps sooner or later or it gets repetitive.

And the two don't really go together. When the show started, the Doctor's origins were a complete mystery (they didn't even explicitly establish he was nonhuman until the Troughton era), but we were shown very early where the TARDIS crew slept and got their meals. It was only later that the focus narrowed to the console room exclusively.
 
Yeah, but they eventually filled in the Doctor's backstory. When a show runs for decades, you have to fill in the gaps sooner or later or it gets repetitive.

And the two don't really go together. When the show started, the Doctor's origins were a complete mystery (they didn't even explicitly establish he was nonhuman until the Troughton era), but we were shown very early where the TARDIS crew slept and got their meals. It was only later that the focus narrowed to the console room exclusively.
While I'm fine with seeing more of the TARDIS, I feel a good 90% of established Doctor/Gallifrey backstory has only made things less interesting.
 
While I'm fine with seeing more of the TARDIS, I feel a good 90% of established Doctor/Gallifrey backstory has only made things less interesting.

I dunno, I think a mystery can only take you so far before you have to mix it up and try something else. That something else won't always succeed, but just asking the same unanswered question over and over would get stale eventually.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top