• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Keiko Ishikawa O'Brien; Civilian?

Six of Twelve

Captain
Captain
Never having seen Keiko wearing a uniform, which would have been science blue because she was a botanist, I can only assume she was not a member of Starfleet, but a civilian contractor employed on Enterprise D. Not sure why they'd not have used o Starfleet science officer whose specialty was botany, though.
 
Some civilians do have jobs aboard the ship. The Enterprise was pretty much a city in her own right, with probably ongoing civilian research projects separate from those of Starfleet's, IMO. Keiko might have been doing work for a university or some other scientific organization. Considering how many planets and other astronomical phenomena the Enterprise encounters, she's probably one of the best mobile research platforms around...
 
The original idea behind TNG was that a fair portion of the Enterprise-D's crew consisted of civilian scientists and crew family members, and that it was more a research vessel than a military craft. I tend to think of it as like a university village in space. Unfortunately, all the writing-staff upheavals in the first couple of seasons meant that a lot of the original concepts were quietly dropped or forgotten, and that included the idea of civilian personnel for the most part, with occasional exceptions like Keiko and Guinan.
 
The original idea behind TNG was that a fair portion of the Enterprise-D's crew consisted of civilian scientists and crew family members, and that it was more a research vessel than a military craft. I tend to think of it as like a university village in space. Unfortunately, all the writing-staff upheavals in the first couple of seasons meant that a lot of the original concepts were quietly dropped or forgotten, and that included the idea of civilian personnel for the most part, with occasional exceptions like Keiko and Guinan.

Making it more akin to a mobile military base with families and others who lived in the neighborhood.
 
Like the ship was going out into the great unknown, replaced with cruising around the Federation much of the time.

To be fair, even the original staff dropped that idea pretty much immediately after the pilot -- "The Naked Now" was about rescuing another Starfleet ship, "Code of Honor" was about obtaining a vaccine for a Federation planet, etc.
 
465413__barry-morse-as-professor-victor-bergman_p.jpg


Certainly precedent in sci-fi for civilians. Space:1999's Professor Victor Berman was a civilian not assigned to Alpha, hence no department colour on the sleeve on his uniform.

There are also many real-world Military-led scientific expeditions that make use of civilian experts. Whereas Starfleet is of course different to the modern military by it's very nature and filled with scientists, there is nothing that precludes that TNG would require all such scientist to be Starfleet. Regula I, though Starfleet funded and supplied, never had a single Starfleet scientist in sight.
 
Certainly precedent in sci-fi for civilians. Space:1999's Professor Victor Berman was a civilian not assigned to Alpha, hence no department colour on the sleeve on his uniform.

I'm pretty sure all the Alpha personnel were civilians. They had uniforms, but they were more like NASA than the Air Force. The uniforms had department color indicators, but no rank insignias. Aside from Commander Koenig, nobody had a rank, and they were all referred to either by name (usually first name, except for Kano) or by a title like "Doctor." So it was a pretty informal operation; even "Commander" seemed more like a job title than a military rank. Alan Carter was called "Captain" once or twice, but that might have been a holdover from his previous military service in Australia or a reference to his role as an Eagle pilot.
 
Moonbase Alpha is similar to Starfleet in many ways, in that it doesn't easily slot into organisations we would have today. Starfleet is based much more on the modern Navy and it's customs of course, and appears way more 'military' while arguing they aren't.

The International Lunar Commission definitely seems to be a civilian oversight committee, and I can see Alpha being regarded similarly to NASA, although I can't imagine a civilian organisation having access to laser-equipped combat Eagles and lunar tanks. Then again, Alpha never seemed to have Hawks assigned to it, and they appeared to be specific combat designs.

Certainly though there was obviously a rigid command structure, it was also very informal. While Koenig was almost universally referred to as Commander by Alpha personnel save Russell and Bergman, (and I assume Gorski was too though perhaps less familiarity with the latter), Kano was rarely called by his first name, Matthias and Carter were referred to by both surname and first name, whereas almost everyone else like Morrow and Benes were called by their first names almost exclusively. It was more department-heads rather than ranks, although the ID pics on the Comlocks have a lot of colour-coded data, which probably actually meant nothing, except that it looked cool.

I suppose then it'd be more accurate to call Bergman Non-Alpha personnel rather than civilian.
 
I always wondered what the ratio was between Starfleet staff and civilian staff/researchers on the D.
 
Might be the ratio changed in synch with the change in mission premise. That is, the ship really was geared up for long duration research far beyond the usual reach of crew rotation, but turned back after Q made threatening noises - and some of the civilians disembarked, while others remained aboard, for a mission they otherwise would not have attended.

Random civilian specialists aboard might be standard Starfleet fare for smaller ships, too. It's just that Kirk never seemed to have any of those: his idle butterfly-catchers were all in uniform. (Then again, so were two of his decidedly non-Starfleet guests from beyond a gulf of centuries, Christopher and Khan!)

OTOH, the Prometheus of "Second Sight" seemed to either have a civilian in command, or a lax uniform code allowing the CO to wear civilian garb... I guess there's room for interpretation when it comes to the hierarchical position of people vs. their apparent choice of clothing.

Timo Saloniemi
 
In The Deadly Years, wasn't there a blonde doctor on board who wasn't part of Starfleet? If so, it would seem to indicate that as far back as 2260s, Starfleet would bring on civilian specialists on occasion.
 
If so, it would seem to indicate that as far back as 2260s, Starfleet would bring on civilian specialists on occasion.

One notable civilian specialist who came aboard the TOS Enterprise was Daystrom, the creator of the M5 computer.

The engineer, who developed the Enterprise D's engines and the woman that LaForge had a crush on, Leah Brahms, made an appearance in TNG.

I believe they were both civilian contractors. I guess there were still good jobs available in the Trek civilian economy.
 
Even if you don't earn a salary in the same way we do now, people would still take pleasure in their achievements or want to challenge themselves to learn/create more.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top