• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Jedi Leia: A Missed Opportunity?

Leia can be a Jedi who doesn't use a light saber, just as Yoda was seemingly one, before Lucas decided fans wanted to see him twirling around with a little baby saber.
In one of the RPGs, there were different classes of Jedi - some whose powers focused more on combat, and others whose powers focused more on diplomacy, empathy, and other more non-combat related Force skills. Until directly contradicted by screen canon, the latter is how I prefer to see Leia. It isn't that she isn't a trained Jedi, she just isn't the type we've generally seen in the lightsaber combat sequences - she's more like the Jedi librarian we saw in the Prequels at one point, as far as her Force abilities are concerned.

As an aside, this explanation also could come into play in three other matters:

1. Why two Sith - aided by Clonetroopers or not - were able to wipe out 10,000 Jedi: most of those Jedi were not really combat oriented in their skills.

2. Why Rey was able to mind trick and use Force telekinesis right away: that's where her strengths lie in the Force. Perhaps she'll never be able to Force leap, for example, for crap.

3. Perhaps Jedi whose talents *are* in combat related skills are much more in danger of being seduced to the Dark Side than other Jedi? The temptation to harness anger and pain for strength, rather than letting the Force work through you, must almost always be there for most people - since that is what you would do in combat if you were just a normal non-Force-using type person.
 
Leia's lack-of-Jediing: it's deliberate to the story (later development) or perhaps Fisher has no interest in exploring that aspect of the character.

Or perhaps the writers were so wedded to the corporate mentality of "playing it safe" that they ended up copying the EU.

USS Triumphant said:
Perhaps she'll never be able to Force leap, for example, for crap.

I doubt it.
 
I forget that people take these things so seriously.
In the larger scheme of things, I don't take it very seriously AT ALL.

But from the perspective of playing inside the fandom, I take it all "very seriously". Why bother to play if you're going to half-ass it? ;)
USS Triumphant said:
Perhaps she'll never be able to Force leap, for example, for crap.

I doubt it.
I frankly do, too - but it's nice to think there might be such subtleties involved until I see evidence to the contrary. :)
 
I forget that people take these things so seriously.
In the larger scheme of things, I don't take it very seriously AT ALL.

But from the perspective of playing inside the fandom, I take it all "very seriously". Why bother to play if you're going to half-ass it? ;)

In that case...

Maybe Midichlorians just didn't like Leia that much. She got some, but Luke got most of them.

Luke was born first. Maybe Padme squeezed all the midichlorians out in the first push. :p
 
I don't think anybody can say it definitively. ;)

For all we know Leia's body created antibodies to fight the midichlorians.

Or maybe it's diet-related. Anakin and Luke both grew up on Tatooine. Maybe it's in the water.
 
With Luke and Leia being twins, they should have the potential. The fact that Leia seemingly has learned no control of the Force after 30+ years and even her own son was learning from Luke, seems like such a waste.
 
It might be cool if, in an appropriate moment, they reveal that she does have Jedi training, she's just not running around fighting people with it.
 
I could be misremembering, but didn't Leia say something to the effect that they sent Ben to Luke after they had lost him? And it was then that Ben became Kylo Ren and killed the Jedi and Luke went into hiding? If that were the case, then (again, assuming I'm remembering correctly) Leia did have some Jedi training and tried training Ben to be a Jedi. But, if I'm remembering incorrectly, please disregard this post :)
 
She said she sent Ben to Luke because Ben had too much of her grandfather in him. He was leaning in the direction of Anakin Skywalker at whatever age they sent him off to train with Luke.
 
With Luke and Leia being twins, they should have the potential. The fact that Leia seemingly has learned no control of the Force after 30+ years and even her own son was learning from Luke, seems like such a waste.

I'm still hoping for a scene in Ep. 8 or 9 where Kylo goes to give her the Han Solo treatment & she just force pushes him right off a cliff.

I could be misremembering, but didn't Leia say something to the effect that they sent Ben to Luke after they had lost him? And it was then that Ben became Kylo Ren and killed the Jedi and Luke went into hiding? If that were the case, then (again, assuming I'm remembering correctly) Leia did have some Jedi training and tried training Ben to be a Jedi. But, if I'm remembering incorrectly, please disregard this post :)

I thought I could train him just as well as Luke, I was wrong ;)
 
I think the only reason they didn't make Leia a Jedi is that they wanted Luke to have the 'Last Jedi' narrative.

But he had been in the process of training a next generation of Jedi... well until Ben got done with them.

I would've liked to see Leia at least show some force ability in the film. Perhaps she can use Battlefield Meditation.
 
I think the only reason they didn't make Leia a Jedi is that they wanted Luke to have the 'Last Jedi' narrative.

They also wanted a certain sense of familiarity. Leia is a rebel fighter. Han is a smuggler. If Leia were a Jedi knight, that would be something fairly different from what we saw before. They showed her force sensitivity with Han's death, which I thought was a nice touch they didn't have to do.
 
I think the only reason they didn't make Leia a Jedi is that they wanted Luke to have the 'Last Jedi' narrative.

They also wanted a certain sense of familiarity. Leia is a rebel fighter. Han is a smuggler. If Leia were a Jedi knight, that would be something fairly different from what we saw before. They showed her force sensitivity with Han's death, which I thought was a nice touch they didn't have to do.

It was nice, especially since, knowing Abrams, he could've just as easily had her look up at the sky and literally see Han on the other planet getting killed.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top