• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is there some law against black people travelling through time?

Taye Diggs was stuck in a temporal loop in Day Break. He had the good fortune to start every episode with Moon Bloodgood in her underwear. That's a time travel bonus.
 
So here's what I think.

Notice how it's always white guys traveling through time? White guys don't want to mess up history--they're always worried about that happening, and they try to prevent it because let's face it, history's been awesome to the white guy. We rule the fucking world, man. Who'd want to fuck that up?

You send a brother into the past, though? He might go back to the 1700s and tell everybody slavery is bad and wrong they better knock it off. Could cause all sorts of trouble. You just don't want a black guy in the past screwing things up for whitey.

Only white men are allowed to travel through time. Anyone that's not a white guy is there to just be comic relief or a romantic interest (in the case of women.)

(What goes on with gay time travelers is an open question, I guess.)


If a black man went back to the 1700s and tried to stop slavery, he'd likely end up in chains himself, or executed, so for his sake i'd hope he'd leave it alone, one man cannot stop the machine. Where would he go to stop it anyway...Africa, Middle East, American continent, it was a very wide spread practice, not confined to southern whites.
 
So here's what I think.

Notice how it's always white guys traveling through time? White guys don't want to mess up history--they're always worried about that happening, and they try to prevent it because let's face it, history's been awesome to the white guy. We rule the fucking world, man. Who'd want to fuck that up?

You send a brother into the past, though? He might go back to the 1700s and tell everybody slavery is bad and wrong they better knock it off. Could cause all sorts of trouble. You just don't want a black guy in the past screwing things up for whitey.

Only white men are allowed to travel through time. Anyone that's not a white guy is there to just be comic relief or a romantic interest (in the case of women.)

(What goes on with gay time travelers is an open question, I guess.)


If a black man went back to the 1700s and tried to stop slavery, he'd likely end up in chains himself, or executed, .


Not if he went back in time with a nuclear submarine! Or a starship!
 
:lol: Yes, the whole Onslaught thing is what I referring to. He did technically save the X-Men but you could argue he caused something worse.

Hey, I never said he was a smart black guy who time traveled. :lol:

Oh, and John Stewart has time traveled at least a few times across various media.
 
In Eureka, Henry (Joe Morton) has time-travelled on a couple of different occasions, and Allison (Salli Richardson-Whitfield) has done so as well. There have also been time-travel storylines in the Stargate franchise that have involved characters like Teal'c and Sgt. Greer.

Really, I don't see any merit to the title question here. There are plenty of works of fiction that fit the bill. Like, what about that Denzel Washington movie, Deja Vu?
 
So here's what I think.

Notice how it's always white guys traveling through time? White guys don't want to mess up history--they're always worried about that happening, and they try to prevent it because let's face it, history's been awesome to the white guy. We rule the fucking world, man. Who'd want to fuck that up?

You send a brother into the past, though? He might go back to the 1700s and tell everybody slavery is bad and wrong they better knock it off. Could cause all sorts of trouble. You just don't want a black guy in the past screwing things up for whitey.

Only white men are allowed to travel through time. Anyone that's not a white guy is there to just be comic relief or a romantic interest (in the case of women.)

(What goes on with gay time travelers is an open question, I guess.)


If a black man went back to the 1700s and tried to stop slavery, he'd likely end up in chains himself, or executed, so for his sake i'd hope he'd leave it alone, one man cannot stop the machine. Where would he go to stop it anyway...Africa, Middle East, American continent, it was a very wide spread practice, not confined to southern whites.

What if the black guy had superpowers?



We're talking about works of fiction for Robert Maxwell's sake!
 
So here's what I think.

Notice how it's always white guys traveling through time? White guys don't want to mess up history--they're always worried about that happening, and they try to prevent it because let's face it, history's been awesome to the white guy. We rule the fucking world, man. Who'd want to fuck that up?

You send a brother into the past, though? He might go back to the 1700s and tell everybody slavery is bad and wrong they better knock it off. Could cause all sorts of trouble. You just don't want a black guy in the past screwing things up for whitey.

Only white men are allowed to travel through time. Anyone that's not a white guy is there to just be comic relief or a romantic interest (in the case of women.)

(What goes on with gay time travelers is an open question, I guess.)


If a black man went back to the 1700s and tried to stop slavery, he'd likely end up in chains himself, or executed, so for his sake i'd hope he'd leave it alone, one man cannot stop the machine. Where would he go to stop it anyway...Africa, Middle East, American continent, it was a very wide spread practice, not confined to southern whites.

What if the black guy had superpowers?



We're talking about works of fiction for Robert Maxwell's sake!

Or maybe he brought back awesome future technology, like an iPod or a Cuisinart.
 
Really, I don't see any merit to the title question here. There are plenty of works of fiction that fit the bill. Like, what about that Denzel Washington movie, Deja Vu?

I think the OP was just making a tongue-in-cheek point about Seven Days, but what trivia fan could resist coming up with counter-examples?
 
Or maybe he brought back awesome future technology, like an iPod or a Cuisinart.

Where would he plug it in?

A wall socket obviously, wtf kinda question is that Christopher?!

That was such a rudely phrased riposte that I can't tell whether you're playing along with the joke (and Robert seems to have missed that I was making a joke -- the Internet is frustrating for a deadpan comic like myself). We are talking about time travel to the 1700s, right?


Anyway, if a black man (or a woman) went back in time with a fantastic invention or scientific theory or whatnot, some white guy would probably just swipe credit for it. That's what happened to most of the women and minorities who really did make important scientific breakthroughs, like Lise Meitner and Henrietta Leavitt. Although we did get the rare exception like George Washington Carver.
 
Where would he plug it in?

A wall socket obviously, wtf kinda question is that Christopher?!

That was such a rudely phrased riposte that I can't tell whether you're playing along with the joke (and Robert seems to have missed that I was making a joke -- the Internet is frustrating for a deadpan comic like myself). We are talking about time travel to the 1700s, right?

I thought it was pretty obvious that I was just playing along with the joke. I'm not really ignorant enough to believe there were wall sockets in the 17th century.


Everybody knows electricity was wireless back then.
 
So here's what I think.

Notice how it's always white guys traveling through time? White guys don't want to mess up history--they're always worried about that happening, and they try to prevent it because let's face it, history's been awesome to the white guy. We rule the fucking world, man. Who'd want to fuck that up?

You send a brother into the past, though? He might go back to the 1700s and tell everybody slavery is bad and wrong they better knock it off. Could cause all sorts of trouble. You just don't want a black guy in the past screwing things up for whitey.

Ben Sisko in Trials and Tribble-ations as well on DS9

Speaking of Sisko and to, perhaps, prove Robert Maxwell correct, there was another time Sisko travelled through time...and screwed up things for the establishment.
 
Notice how it's always white guys traveling through time? White guys don't want to mess up history--they're always worried about that happening, and they try to prevent it because let's face it, history's been awesome to the white guy. We rule the fucking world, man. Who'd want to fuck that up?

You send a brother into the past, though? He might go back to the 1700s and tell everybody slavery is bad and wrong they better knock it off. Could cause all sorts of trouble. You just don't want a black guy in the past screwing things up for whitey.

If a black man went back to the 1700s and tried to stop slavery, he'd likely end up in chains himself, or executed, so for his sake i'd hope he'd leave it alone, one man cannot stop the machine. Where would he go to stop it anyway...Africa, Middle East, American continent, it was a very wide spread practice, not confined to southern whites.

Well, what if the black guy (or a white guy, or a black woman etc.) went further back - say to Ancient Rome or Ancient Egypt? He could set himself up as a god, ban slavery and maybe prolong the hegemony of Rome or Egypt, changing the political map profoundly and creating a slaveless social paradigm for the developed world millennia ahead of schedule.

Doctor Who almost had a black Doctor in Paterson Joseph. They probably would just have treated race as a non-issue, but certain stories would have been just begging to be told. Strangely, he might find seventeenth or eighteenth century Britain much more hospitable than the nineteenth or twentieth. Maybe it had to do with competition and the opening up of the "dark continent" to the West.
 
Well, what if the black guy (or a white guy, or a black woman etc.) went further back - say to Ancient Rome or Ancient Egypt? He could set himself up as a god, ban slavery and maybe prolong the hegemony of Rome or Egypt, changing the political map profoundly and creating a slaveless social paradigm for the developed world millennia ahead of schedule.

Part of the problem with Trek time travel episodes/scenarios is by the time we reach Voyager and with Enterprise they've established the fact that by the 31st century some SF entity monitors the past for continuity changes.

So presumably anything that might not fit with the 31st century view on what is appropriate history is stopped.

Daniels in ST Enterprise and Braxton in Voyager establishes the fact that time travel is closely monitored by the Federation.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top