• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is IDW on the edge of bankruptcy?

Extrocomp

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
I've heard that IDW Publishing hasn't made a profit in many years and its stock has dropped down to $1 per share and is still dropping. I've also heard that if the stock falls below $1 for more than 15 days, it will be delisted from the stock market.

Is any of this true? What does this mean for the future of Star Trek comics? Can IDW keep its head above water long enough to finish the current story arc or is it going to end on a cliffhanger like Early Voyages?
 
Sad that things are this way during the era when they’ve embraced ongoing series instead of miniseries.
 
If this news is true it's really too bad. Fans like me were looking forward to getting the ds9 comics. I really liked the odo Comic I got recently .I loved the artwork and the film noir mystery story.
 
Comics is a tough business. Expenses are high, margins are low. Just this month, AfterShock filed for bankruptcy so they can reorganize their debts. It's a common story.

IDW's an interesting case. For a long time, IDW really seemed to be the place that wanted to do licensed comics right. They had original properties -- notably, 30 Days of Night and Locke & Key -- but their bread and butter, month in, month out, was licensed comics. That's fine -- there's a built-in audience for the comics -- but that also comes with the expense of the license fee to the IP holder, and building their business on comics they don't own constricts their revenue over the long term to what they can sell on their own reprints. They can't option a Metal Gear Solid comic to a Hollywood studio, they can't sell the podcast rights to a Transformers comics, they can't sell My Little Pony comic art for a t-shirt, they can't sell the Spanish reprint rights to Star Trek: Boldly Go to a Mexican publisher. Other publishers were chasing Hollywood money, while IDW was chasing Hollywood with theirs. (I've seen a number of publishers come and go over my fifteen years in the industry that could be best described as Hollywood pitch farms. They made good graphic novels, but they were clearly chasing a greenlight with a graphic novel/storyboard.) IDW has moved off the heavy emphasis on licenses over the past five or six years. They publish much more original material now than they did in the past. Whether that's enough to keep them afloat financially, I don't know.
 
Yeah, I think 3.3 was the last one.
I meant, after a certain date IDW wouldn't be allowed to sell their stock of Transformers collections because they no longer had the right to sell them. This has happened to them in the past with Doctor Who and Star Wars; after their license expired, they could sell their remaining stock before a certain date, and after that they could not. Based on the past, it's just a few months.

DC, on the other hand, could (and did) sell Star Trek: Debt of Honor for years after losing the license.
 
I meant, after a certain date IDW wouldn't be allowed to sell their stock of Transformers collections because they no longer had the right to sell them. This has happened to them in the past with Doctor Who and Star Wars; after their license expired, they could sell their remaining stock before a certain date, and after that they could not. Based on the past, it's just a few months.
Oh wow !

Looks like I did the sensible thing then.

Cheers !
 
Yeah, last week I went through Comixology and bought all the IDW Transformers collections I wanted and didn't own; thankfully, they were all half off. (I guess for this very reason.) Now they are all delisted!
 
Would be a shame to see them go, but with what happened to Aftershock, it could happen.

That said they could recover. DHC was in a bad way a few years back but survived and seem to be doing well now. Like IDW they had had some bad hits from loss of licenses.
 
If you want to support IDW and consider checking if your library has access to Hoopla. IDW has 220 IDW Star Trek titles through my local library, which includes some of republished older comics.

Based on a few internet searches, I think libraries pay about $1 to $1.50 per comic borrowed with most of it going to the publisher (who may owe royalties as well).

I try to only borrow books that I plan to read. Libraries often limit borrowing to a set number of titles a month, though I fortunately live in a city with a large library budget, so I never hit the limit.
 
I guess the moral of the story for our part is to continue to support IDW as much as possible if you want to see Trek comics continue.

The license would eventually bounce to someone else, nature of the beast.
 
Mind you, that five year gap was during the franchise's waning days in the mid-2000s, where the recent TV shows weren't hits and the most recent movie was a bomb. Nowadays, the franchise has renewed life with five TV shows currently in production, granted with one ending in a few months. Someone else will scoop that license up the minute it's available.
 
I can't say I'm entirely sold yet on this new direction they've launched recently with their new ongoing Star Trek title, but I would like to see them have the opportunity to develop it and see where it goes. Not really that thrilled with the thought of another Early Voyages situation happening here. :(

Hopefully IDW can turn things around. And looking at their income charts over the last five years, it looks like they maybe have been? They are still operating at a loss, but the loss has decreased every year from 2019 to 2021 (year end results for 2022 are not yet available).
 
Is anyone here using Comixology to buy IDW Star Trek stuff, while based outside the US or UK? I'm in Poland, which at least for now is in the EU, and I did buy quite a lot of IDW Star Trek comics via the Comixology app a few years ago. But recently Amazon bought the service and they have removed the option of buying comics in the app for me, saying it's Google's fault. I can read my old stuff but can't buy new things. Has anyone here been in a similar situations and have they figured it out? The official Kindle store I'm using is amazon.com (this is mandatory for Polish Kindle users, Amazon's decision) and I have no idea if after I buy something there it will appear for me in the Comixology app... any hints? This'd seem to be the fastest way of sending some $ IDW's way...
 
Is anyone here using Comixology to buy IDW Star Trek stuff, while based outside the US or UK? I'm in Poland, which at least for now is in the EU, and I did buy quite a lot of IDW Star Trek comics via the Comixology app a few years ago. But recently Amazon bought the service and they have removed the option of buying comics in the app for me, saying it's Google's fault. I can read my old stuff but can't buy new things. Has anyone here been in a similar situations and have they figured it out? The official Kindle store I'm using is amazon.com (this is mandatory for Polish Kindle users, Amazon's decision) and I have no idea if after I buy something there it will appear for me in the Comixology app... any hints? This'd seem to be the fastest way of sending some $ IDW's way...
I've simply been buying the new IDW Star Trek monthly straight off of Amazon. I don't collect physical comics anymore. Just no room anymore. So digital i went.
 
I've simply been buying the new IDW Star Trek monthly straight off of Amazon. I don't collect physical comics anymore. Just no room anymore. So digital i went.
Sorry if I'm an idiot, but what is it that you receive if you 'buy digital on Amazon'? I'm wary I will only get something for my black and white Kindle, and I'd want something readable by a comic app, ideally something that would appear in my Comixology account...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top