• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

I'm pretty sick of these "dumbest" polls regarding superheroes.

blockaderunner

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
To say that this thing about superheroes or that thing about superheroes is dumb is to say the history of mythology is dumb. If you look at it through a rational mind, of course its dumb. You can go back in history and say the the same thing. A warrior whose invulnerability originates from being dipped into a magical pool as a child is dumb. Some guy striking with a hammer against the clouds to create thunder is dumb. The sun being the wheel of a great chariot being pulled across the sky is dumb. Has gritty, gray toned, shaky cam downers like The Wire and BSG have made us so hard and cynical that everything that dares to tell a story with an extraordinary flair is dumb?? People with imaginations and a spirit of wonder don't care whether one aspect or another of a superhero costume or origin is dumb. And yes, I do take it personally, because, in a very big way, next to my parents, comic books helped shape my value system, my politics, and the way I see the world greater than any politician, religious leader, or sports figure has. They are our myths. Just as valid as the Epic Of Gilgamesh, Beowulf, or Arthur and his Knights of The Round Table. Beyond the origins and constumes, they speak to us. We just have to listen.
 
We should also vilify people who disagree with dorky virgins who troll the Internet and espouse how some skank is teh hottest thing ever.
 
To say that this thing about superheroes or that thing about superheroes is dumb is to say the history of mythology is dumb. If you look at it through a rational mind, of course its dumb. You can go back in history and say the the same thing. A warrior whose invulnerability originates from being dipped into a magical pool as a child is dumb. Some guy striking with a hammer against the clouds to create thunder is dumb. The sun being the wheel of a great chariot being pulled across the sky is dumb. Has gritty, gray toned, shaky cam downers like The Wire and BSG have made us so hard and cynical that everything that dares to tell a story with an extraordinary flair is dumb?? People with imaginations and a spirit of wonder don't care whether one aspect or another of a superhero costume or origin is dumb. And yes, I do take it personally, because, in a very big way, next to my parents, comic books helped shape my value system, my politics, and the way I see the world greater than any politician, religious leader, or sports figure has. They are our myths. Just as valid as the Epic Of Gilgamesh, Beowulf, or Arthur and his Knights of The Round Table. Beyond the origins and constumes, they speak to us. We just have to listen.

I agree with you.

That said, last I checked there were only two such threads here, and you aren't required by any statute to participate in them.

Ignore them and wait till some new fad pushes them off the first page.
 
So you're admitting that certain superheroes have aspects that are dumb, but you don't want people to debate which one is the most dumb? I'm sorry, but I think that is dumb.
 
I'm pretty sick of threads complaining about trends in threads no one's forcing them to read.

Huh? There's only been one?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top