• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

If a Ninth Planet is discovered in the Outer Solar System, should it be called Hercules?

What Roman deity would you choose?


  • Total voters
    29
I'd call it "Bob". Fuck the Romans.

Do you care if it falls? The Roman empire...

Earth wasn't named after a Roman god or goddess but the name was from a mix of English and Germanic words, so I think a new planet name from a different pantheon could follow that naming convention. I vote for Loki.

True, the name Earth isn't Roman, but Terra is. Further, it's derived from the Greek goddes Hera.

In regards to the original post, I'm kinda partial to Diana. Similar to the Greek goddess Artemis, it was said that any mortal man who looked upon her naked form would be struck dead.
 
Do you care if it falls? The Roman empire...



True, the name Earth isn't Roman, but Terra is. Further, it's derived from the Greek goddes Hera.

In regards to the original post, I'm kinda partial to Diana. Similar to the Greek goddess Artemis, it was said that any mortal man who looked upon her naked form would be struck dead.

Or turned into a stag and chased down and killed by his own dogs.
 
How about Ishtar aka Inanna? Female deity from Western Asia (Mesopotamia, to be precise). Since she was responsible for both love and war, she'd fit with everyone's ideals.
Ishtar has already been identified with the planet Venus, and the planet even has an Australia-sized "continent" named Ishtar Terra.

Actually, it’s been theorized since January 2015 (five years ago) that there may be two planets beyond Neptune’s orbit, and I’m a proponent of this derivative hypothesis:

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2015/01/17/two-planets-beyond-pluto/21912521/

The first (Planet Nine) is expected to have a semi-major axis of around 200 astronomical units and a mass between that of Mars and Saturn. And of course, I've voted Persephone on the poll.

Persephone itself is expected to be in an orbital resonance with another planet even further out, with a mass of 10 Earth masses and a semi-major axis of 250 astronomical units. This time, I’m not fully sure on what to name that second planet (Vulcan is unfitting because he is a fire deity and recently an asteroid with an orbit fully within the orbit of Venus has been discovered, and I honestly want it to be named Vulcan; Oceanus is unfitting too because it was proposed by the egocentric fringe astronomer Thomas Jackson Jefferson See, Minerva as also unfitting because she has nothing much to do with the underworld).
 
Last edited:
if the rumour is true that the starwars planet is named after hermann hoth (for his professional experience with snow) that won't gonna fly
The cloud planet where "Lando Kadar" lives was called "Hoth" in the first draft of The Empire Strikes Back by Leigh Brackett. There's even a line in that screenplay about the name "Hoth" possibly meaning "cloud." So, that "rumor" of yours, assuming that there even is such a thing, is totally bogus.
 
The cloud planet where "Lando Kadar" lives was called "Hoth" in the first draft of The Empire Strikes Back by Leigh Brackett. There's even a line in that screenplay about the name "Hoth" possibly meaning "cloud." So, that "rumor" of yours, assuming that there even is such a thing, is totally bogus.
  • it was big in the german press when the empire strikes back came out. i didn't say it's true - i said it existed (might as well be our 'sensibilities')
  • who's lando kadar? calrissian?
edit to add:

the daily beast talked about it as late as 2015 - click -
The original film’s astounding lack of diversity is particularly odd considering it was inspired by the events of World War II. Stormtroopers, of course, borrow their name from Nazi stormtroopers, or the Sturmabteilung; the uniforms of Imperial officers like Peter Cushing’s Grand Moff Tarkin resemble the Wehrmacht; there are entire planets named after famous Germans, like Hoth (see: Hermann Hoth, panzer commander in the German Army) and Kessel, a German term referring to a trapped military force with little chance of escape.
 
Last edited:
  • it was big in the german press when the empire strikes back came out. i didn't say it's true - isaid it existed (might as well be our 'sensibilities')
  • who's lando kadar? calrissian?
edit to add:

the daily beast talked about it as late as 2015 - click -
Ah, so they are just repeating the rumor. Sloppy. Well, it lacks foundation in fact. Hoth could not have been assigned to the snow planet because of a WWII general's exploits in the snow, because the name "Hoth" was originally assigned to the cloud planet.

Yes, obviously the character named "Lando Kadar" in the first draft was evolved into Lando Calrissian.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top