• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

I want to see "X-Men: Days of Future Past"...on the big screen

JacksonArcher

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Screw spin-offs. Screw prequels. With Terminator Salvation on the horizon, I was thinking: Since that movie is doing post-apocalyptic and perhaps even "bringing it back", I was thinking of X-Men after re-watching the movie in HD a few hours ago. And the two conjoined...

What if they did an X-Men 4, but loosely adapted the "Days of Future Past" storyline? I know many of you are probably shuddering at the thought, and perhaps adequately so. They screwed up my favorite comic-book storyline of all time in the last movie ("Dark Phoenix Saga"), so who's to say they won't screw up "Days of Future Past", but it is ripe for a big-screen treatment, and especially with Transformers proving you can do big scary giant robots, and not laugh (mostly), I think the time is right for "Days of Future Past" to hit the big screen.

You could even build from the last movie, as difficult as that might sound, and plus, you can do it in an interesting and provocative way that might even "reset" the events of X-Men: The Last Stand without it appearing like a giant-sized "reset button". Hear me out:

In the story, there's a future where all mutants are in concentration camps, after a bill that's signed outlawing mutants (my memory is a bit rusty since it's been a while since I've read the story, so forgive me if my details are shady or incorrect). Sentinels police the United States, and mutants have "tags" on them identifying them much like the Holocaust and the treatment of the Jews. Kitty Pryde is sent back in time to prevent this cataclysmic occurrence in history. She ends up preventing the attempted assassination of Senator Robert Kelly, who used that as a springboard to initiate his "fuck all mutants" act.

Again, my details are dim, but naturally some things would need to be changed. Since Robert Kelly is dead, it makes it difficult to include him, unless he was being impersonated by Mystique, but by going by the events of The Last Stand, she's powerless, so nix that idea. What if...after the Cure, it was revealed that the serum did not work, and began to wore off on some mutants. This caused a stir, and the government initiated "Project Wideawake" as a last resort in containing the mutant problem...Naturally there's going to have to be a bigger impetus than the Cure wearing off, but whatever.

So, flash-forward, and Sentinels run the show, and mutants are imprisoned. Kitty Pryde goes back in time, and get this: She goes back in time before the events of X-Men: The Last Stand, and must stop the creation of the Cure, which leads to Project Wideawake and Sentinels. This way, doing so, allows you to bring back Xavier, Scott, et al, and basically wash away everything that happened in TLS. The ending is ambigious, much like the story, where the X-Men question whether or not they were successful, and if history had been "repaired" or "changed".

This then allows you a clean slate for X-Men 5. It allows us to see one of the best X-Men storylines adapted to film, and furthermore, allows it to actually fix and repair the franchise as it stands now...because let's face it, the way X-Men: The Last Stand ended, the only way to continue the franchise is the way it is currently going: with spin-offs and prequels.

What does everyone think?
 
I have LONG thought that a strict adaptation of DoFP would rule. The movie would practically write itself.

I mean, who doesn't want to see Wolverine getting his skin melted off?

I'm not saying your changes wouldn't work Archer, but in this case, greater adherence to the source material would work just as well, imo.

So what if it clashes with X3 continuity...I say screw movie continuity.

141kl6.png


142up0.jpg



Ah, Marvel was the shit back then, eh?
 
Something like this?

I've had this saved on my computer for a few years. Probably from after X-men 3 came out. Can't remember the artist. Can't make out the signature but want to give credit where its due.

Sounds like a great idea to me! Getting the right director would be the key in pulling it off.
2006-06-17_163449_XDOFPMovie.jpg
 
that pic is f*&#in awesome!

i'd say if you want a political assassination in it, use Trask. after Gyrich was offed in 1 and Kelly was as well, he seems the obvious choice. Trask is a senator or something and gets killed, and blam.
 
Something like this?

I've had this saved on my computer for a few years. Probably from after X-men 3 came out. Can't remember the artist. Can't make out the signature but want to give credit where its due.

Sounds like a great idea to me! Getting the right director would be the key in pulling it off.
2006-06-17_163449_XDOFPMovie.jpg

That's jaw-dropping. I think, with a little tweaking, that would be a fantastic teaser poster. It reminds me of the poster artwork for the forthcoming Watchmen adaptation.
 
For me, another X-Man movie would be a waste. They don't need to reset the second and third movies. They could just do classic X-Men, where the Sentinels really belonged.

Or they could get over the tiresome Wolverine obsession and just make a better movie. They could ignore who's dead or depowered as they wish. But, until the makers get past their belief the way Wolverine's little soldiers stand to attention is inexhaustibly fascinating, X-Man movies just aren't going to be very good.
 
That pic is uber cool.

I also thought DOFP would make a great X4. And seen as X3 was essentially "the Phoenix Saga" (for what its worth) it would make sense for DOFP to follow it, as it did in the comics.
It's also interesting that the lineup at the end of X3 is almost exactly the same as in DOFT. Jean is dead, and Cylcops went off to sort his head out leaving- Storm, Wolverine, Collosus, Kitty, Angel and Nightcrawler.
Substitute Beast/Iceman for Nightcrawler and it's a match
XTeam2.jpg
 
Something like this?

I've had this saved on my computer for a few years. Probably from after X-men 3 came out. Can't remember the artist. Can't make out the signature but want to give credit where its due.

Sounds like a great idea to me! Getting the right director would be the key in pulling it off.
2006-06-17_163449_XDOFPMovie.jpg

That's jaw-dropping.


Jaw-droppingly rediculous. It's photoshopped fanwank crap like this which is the reason why Days Of Future Past shouldn't be done (And X4...oops..I mean XO: Wolverine doesn't look good either).

But, in the unlikely chance that it might happen, I'd wait 15 to 20 years from now so that the memories of Jackman, Singer, Rothman, Ratner, leather suits and toads and lightning will be just that. A memory.
 
I'm all for it, the only thing that is kinda scary is that they would have to put in some work to diffrentiate the future of world from Terminator's Post Judgment day world (just going by how the world looked in T1 and T2).

Its a shame that Fox never green lit Sentinels in any of the first Xmen movies.
 

I love how they have Angel in costume, there.

What did he get at the end of the movie? A room.

Anyway, I think you got a great idea there, JacksonArcher, but it's never gonna' happen.

And don't write the script. ;)
 
Something like this?

I've had this saved on my computer for a few years. Probably from after X-men 3 came out. Can't remember the artist. Can't make out the signature but want to give credit where its due.

Sounds like a great idea to me! Getting the right director would be the key in pulling it off.
2006-06-17_163449_XDOFPMovie.jpg

That's jaw-dropping.


Jaw-droppingly rediculous. It's photoshopped fanwank crap like this which is the reason why Days Of Future Past shouldn't be done (And X4...oops..I mean XO: Wolverine doesn't look good either).

But, in the unlikely chance that it might happen, I'd wait 15 to 20 years from now so that the memories of Jackman, Singer, Rothman, Ratner, leather suits and toads and lightning will be just that. A memory.

Yes, it is so rediculous that it is ridiculous! ;)

Seriously, the artwork is neat. Of course it was done in Photoshop. Who cares? Whether or not DoFP is a good or bad idea, whoever did that has some talent, and the artwork should be appreciated on at least that level.
 
Its a slick poster, JacksonArcher has a good idea and it would "clean-up" a lot of the bs that went into the last Xmen movie. Sadly, all of those points would/will factor in against anything like that being made. On a side note-I paid my rent one month in the early nineties by selling my mint condition 141-142. Wish I'd found another way.....
 
I would personally rather see an 'Age of Apocalypse' film (or two films if needed) first. It would probably be impossible to pull off, but the whole run of 'Age of Apocalypse' was the kind of thing that would be pretty easy to make into a blockbuster.
 
Seeing as how they killed Sen. Robert Kelly in the first movie I can't see this happening either.
 
It's a good idea, could make a great movie and is a perfect way to relaunch the X-Men movies without simply ignoring what's already occurred.

So naturally, there is no way on Earth that Fox would even contemplate it.
 
Speaking as a non-comics fan...

I think it's a bad idea. Terminator pretty much owns post-apocalyptic time-travel stories; the Matrix series came close to matching it, but ultimately failed. Besides, we saw DoFP in X3, in the Danger Room sequence.

Once the Jackman/Wolverine series runs its course, or even before (and don't get me wrong, I love his Wolverine and hope his solo movies will be good), I think a reboot is the right way to go. First Class and all... hire unknowns, like Watchmen did, so the cast can be controlled. Retcon the founding of the Xavier school and X-team to the present day, or even a 60s-era period piece could be cool.

But Singer's cast has dispersed, we don't need any more Halle Berry Storm, and X3 poisoned the well as far as sequels or non-reboots are concerned.. Time to start fresh, and DoFP is not an inaugural story.
 
I would personally rather see an 'Age of Apocalypse' film (or two films if needed) first. It would probably be impossible to pull off, but the whole run of 'Age of Apocalypse' was the kind of thing that would be pretty easy to make into a blockbuster.

I think I'd rather see that one tackled in some kind of animated mini-series or something.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top