• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

I Still Don't Get Decker's Decision

This is my understanding of the last scene. Decker says to Kirk I believe something to the effect, "as much as you want the Enterprise I want this." We are told in the motion picture why Kirk gets command of the ship, because of his experience, indicating that Decker is a less experieneced commander. We also see Decker as part of the central love story in the film and as a somewhat broken hearted individual. Perhaps losing the real Ilia, losing command of the Enterprise, and his family background, (his father sacrificing his life flying the shuttle into the doomsday machine) all lead to him accepting to merge with Ilia/V'Ger by physically entering the transmited signal and allowing the probe to 'touch' its creator. In this way Decker becomes the hero, getting the girl, saving the ship, saving the earth, by making this sacrifice in return he is rewarded by morphing into a higher human evolutionary life form and reuniting with Ilia.
 
I thought the film never adequately built up to having Decker merge with V'Ger. Given the story as presented, the film makes a much stronger case for Spock to be the one to merge---as his arc of failing Kohlinar to embracing his humanity would have paralleled V'Ger's quest very nicely and given the film the third act it so desparately needed.
 
funny about this subject.

I remember thinking the same when I first saw it (I was 11)
I didn't "get it" either.

but my natural reaction was:

Great! Get the 4th wheel outta here!
 
Yes, I just hated V'ger so much I just wanted it off the screen. That and the 'space pyjamas'
 
Yeah I was around 12 when I saw it in the theater and even though it was boring at times as a kid I got a kick out of seeing the scale of the Enterprise up against V'Ger. The other thing that as I got older made me truly appreciate the film is that it was very much an intellectual odyssey similar in tone to the episode the Changeling where the crew ecounters NOMAD. I like the fact there was no 'bad guy' and it made you think if you were only a kid. I really doubt JJ's film will have an intellectual thought provoking message.
 
Nomad is definitely a "bad guy" in The Changeling.

If it is an "intellectual odyssey", shouldn't Decker's motivation be a bi clearer?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top