• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How would you feel if the final ep ended like this?

The Rock

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timeline......meaning that everything they see looks exactly how it did from TOS. And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.

I dunno, just a thought I had. What do you think of this idea? Is it dumb? It's OK if you think so, lol.
 
Last edited:
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timeline......meaning that everything they see looks exactly how it did from TOS. And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.

I dunno, just a thought I had. What do you think of this idea? Is it dumb? It's OK if it is, lol.

Well they came from the TOS Timeline already. So they'd just be going back home.
 
This would solve a lot of problems.

Don't get me wrong: my chief issue with DISCO isn't the "visual reboot" (not to mention the simultaneous "aural reboot," which nobody seems to be talking about). My chief issue with DISCO is its storytelling, which is aimless, childish, and boring.

But getting rid of the visual reboot and explaining it away would certainly improve things. Their new design isn't just disrespectful of what came before (which is a forgivable sin); it's really ugly. Overcrowded, garish, and fixated on a narrow color palette centered around gunmetal gray, Discovery has the worst visual design of any series to date, while its audio "design" appears to consist of downloading sound clips from TrekCore and dumping them in the soundtrack entirely at random. (Even Voyager's grim, sterile bridge was both a visual and auditory improvement on this.) Chucking all that out the window and retconning it into a parallel timeline would remove a major, constant distraction for me. Restoring the clean lines, warm & cozy sets, and heavy saturation of the Original Series (where they often have more color in a single corridor shot than Discovery has on the entire ship) would be an added bonus, even allowing for more modest visual updates to the original '60s design. That wouldn't actually save the stories, but it would make it far easier for me to keep my patience with them.

So, yes, I would be happy if this were how the season ended. But it would probably alienate the people who actually like Discovery, without turning people like me into real fans, so it might not be the best path for the writers to take if they want to maximize their audience.
 
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timeline......meaning that everything they see looks exactly how it did from TOS. And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.

I dunno, just a thought I had. What do you think of this idea? Is it dumb? It's OK if you think so, lol.
No.
 
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timeline......meaning that everything they see looks exactly how it did from TOS.

I'm not going to lie. I was wondering if they'd ever spore drive into a universe where everything looks exactly like TOS. I don't think it would happen but it did enter my mind.

And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.

I dunno, just a thought I had. What do you think of this idea? Is it dumb? It's OK if you think so, lol.

Yeah. That would suck.

I'd much prefer the finale for DSC have nothing to do with TOS beyond where it would make sense to (i.e. Burnham's foster family). Otherwise, no...

I'm not a fan of ENT but I have to admit I feel bad for them that their finale was framed by characters from another series.
 
Can you elaborate on your opinion that the storytelling is aimless, childish, and boring?

I found it to be none of those things so I'd be interested in why you feel differently. :)

[darn typos]
 
Last edited:
Cany you elaborate on your opinion that the storytelling is aimless, childish, and boring?

I found it to be none of those things so I'd be interested in why you feel differently. :)

he or she probably never watched all the episodes of TOS. I rewatched some of it last night, like Thorlian's Web and Mirror Mirror so I can relate it to DISCO. Then I made the mistake of watching more of the final season 3. Have you watched Spock's Brain? OMG, it was so bad, I can't believe it was even aired! No wonder TOS was canceled after 3 seasons. What a garbage, 1960 or not.
 
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timelinel.

Do you mean in the timeline with USAF Capt. John Christopher and Gary Seven? ;)

My chief issue with DISCO is its storytelling, which is aimless, childish, and boring.
I don't see them as any more childish than Star Trek stories have been in the past (which at times were childish and simple, but still entertaining). I mean, Star Trek has never been "serious television" in the past.

I'm not saying that DSC is necessarily serious television, but it is at least as serious as past versions of Trek, and (IMO) has the potential to present us with stories that are more serious, given the characters that have been laid out in the first 10 episodes.

I mean, it's certainly less childish and aimless than TNG was after its first 10 episodes (some might argue after TNG's first season as a whole), although TNG eventually found their stride and identity as time went on.
 
Last edited:
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timeline......meaning that everything they see looks exactly how it did from TOS. And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.

No, they'll jump back and think they're home, but they'll actually be in the Universe of Misleading Portraiture:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
No, they'll jump back and think they're home, but they'll actually be in the Universe of Misleading Portraiture:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
This is literally the first thing I thought of when I saw this thread.

And there was also the Simpsons universe, the Claymation universe...

If Discovery visits a straight up TOS-style universe, I would expect it to be in a series of hilarious mishaps that also includes a visit to the Animated Series, the Kelvin universe, the Galaxy Quest universe, and one incredibly ironic universe where all of their actions are actually the subject of a television show.
 
In an attempt to get back to their own universe, the spore drive messes up yet again for some reason, and they end up in the 1960's TOS timeline......meaning that everything they see looks exactly how it did from TOS. And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.

I dunno, just a thought I had. What do you think of this idea? Is it dumb? It's OK if you think so, lol.
your idea sounds very expensive from a production standpoint (somewhat ironically, since TOS sets, props, etc were "cheaply" made by today's standards)
 
Sounds like the worst idea since deciding to turn the Enterprise finale into fodder for terrible TNG cameos.
 
And since they're stuck there with no way of getting back, they decide to destroy the Discovery.
Was already done. In re-imagined BSG that's pretty much what ended up happening (no time travel, but they did send the whole fleet into the sun). As I recall, The Internetz reaction was exactly what you would think it would be.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top