• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How does the Romulan government work?

Typical BS on Q's part. He was trying to impress Janeway when he said that.
What better way than to compare her to Cleopatra instead of a ceremonial functionary?
Amongst Romulan weaponry are such diverse elements as fear, surprise, ruthless efficiency, an almost fanatical devotion to the Praetor, and uniforms with REALLY big shoulder pads...I'll come in again.
The shoulder pads were an attempt to marry Roman with Asian culture I think. They were kimono / samurai-wear.
 
What better way than to compare her to Cleopatra instead of a ceremonial functionary?

The shoulder pads were an attempt to marry Roman with Asian culture I think. They were kimono / samurai-wear.
They watched too much Dynasty.
 
Amongst Romulan weaponry are such diverse elements as fear, surprise, ruthless efficiency, an almost fanatical devotion to the Praetor, and uniforms with REALLY big shoulder pads...I'll come in again.
You left out the comfy chair...:D
 
Last edited:
Empire is likely a holdover term, as with the Klingons (who in TNG era at least didn't have an Emperor until clone Kahless was given the role as a figurehead).
The British Empire also had as it's head a king rather than an emperor.
Often this is also a translation, the Swedish Empire in English was so called, but in Swedish it's official name never insinuated an emperor as head of state.
Japan's head of state is commonly translated as “emperor”, though it is seldom called an empire today — this is merely a convention that grew and the term used in Japanese simply means something along the lines of “heavenly ruler”.
 
The British Empire also had as it's head a king rather than an emperor.
Often this is also a translation, the Swedish Empire in English was so called, but in Swedish it's official name never insinuated an emperor as head of state.
Japan's head of state is commonly translated as “emperor”, though it is seldom called an empire today — this is merely a convention that grew and the term used in Japanese simply means something along the lines of “heavenly ruler”.

Empire is always a translation, since the only English (British) Emperor wasn't really an Emperor, outside of India for propaganda reasons. It's doubly a translation when applied to the Klingons or the Romulans or the Slavers or the Tkon. The use of the term "Empire" in modern English doesn't imply an Emperor, just an imperial system of government (usually a multinational state that has local rulers beholden to a central figure or authority).

Per Okrand, the Klingons referred to their ancient leader as the ta', and this was translated to Emperor. ta' is also a word that means "accomplishment" or "to achieve something", so we can assume that the ta' is the overall Achiever of Victory in Klingon etymology.

On the fan-derived Vulcan Language Dictionary, the word for Emperor is sa-eik-te'krusu, a compound word comprised of words that might mean something along the lines of male (sa') wide (eik) 100 (teh) part (krus), which implies to me that ancient Emperors were leaders of specifically defined partitions.

In Diane Duane's Rihan language (Romulan), emperor is rhiyrh, a word that shares some similarity to the words for tradition (rhiymn) and sentence (rhirh), which makes one wonder if there's some etymological connection there, perhaps as a Traditional Judge of the People. Curiously, the word for Empire is defined inbetween two types, Empires led by one person (an emperor) - nneikha, and Empires led by a people (a traditional Empire regardless of leader title) - aevumih. Both of which have no apparent connection to each other or the supposed emperor.
 
The empress could be ceremonial, but then why should Q care to mate with her?

He doesn't. He's citing her as an example of a humanoid with high status against whom he is judging Janeway's value in order to manipulate her into consenting to mate with him. And he's bad at that attempt at manipulating, because Q is kind of a dumbass when it comes to understanding Humans.

I like to think of the Romulans less sentimental than that. Prouder. More sophisticated. Per Senator Letant in DS9’s “Tears of the Prophets,” “Romulans don’t believe in luck.”They have their democratic senate, believe in individual rights like that “of statement,” and seem to be an advanced modern society for all their Roman trappings.

For me, the empress/emperors are figures from antiquity before their modern era. I’d love to read (or watch) the tale of that change. Maybe it would be some grand Antony & Cleopatra epic.

Or it could be one of gradual reforms...TOS’s Samuel T. Cogley quoted documents I imagine each had great stories behind them: “The Bible. The Code of Hammurabi, and of Justinian. The Magna Carta. The Constitution of the United States. The Fundamental Declarations of the Martian Colonies. The Statutes of Alpha III.”

There could be a rich history of Romulan struggles and reforms that elevated them to their advanced society capable of competing with something like the Federation.

Absolutely! But the Romulan Star Empire does seem to represent a period in their history when a relatively more regressive government holds sway, what with its brutal Tal Shiar, its citizens who worry about being seen as "disloyal," and the conflicts between the Romulan government and the Qowat Milat.

By contrast, the Romulans on Ni'Var in the 32nd Century seem positively progressive in comparison with at least one major Vulcan faction![/quote]
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top