• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How Conflicted Must Starfleet Be About Data & His Crew?

Mojochi

Vice Admiral
Admiral
So, after years of having personal liberties trampled upon, Data ends up being maybe the only sole known to the Federation willing & capable of hacking into the Borg Collective & saving everyone from assimilation after Wolf 359, for which he'd receive no promotion. (& never will) Which, on a side note, leaves me thinking Riker is a glory hog, who is happy to let years' worth of randos like Ben Maxwell shower him with praise, like everyone owes a debt of gratitude to him personally for it.

But I digress. Then, however, only weeks or maybe even days later, Data up and proves just as adept at hacking & hijacking the Enterprise. (however unknowingly) It makes me wonder if after the Earth/Borg encounter, Data WAS slated to be decorated & promoted for essentially being the only thing that stood between the UFP & utter ruin, but that stunt with Soong overriding him in Brothers, which came on its heels, maybe put the kibosh on the whole thing, because suddenly everyone got some serious cold feet about letting Data in the full commander suit aboard their ships.

It also gets me thinking about how everyone always criticizes the show for moving away from bold exploration in the latter seasons of TNG, to the point where even Picard's old professor is calling him a centurian to a bloated empire.

However, if you really think about it, who do they have in high-ranking positions on that ship? A Borg refugee as captain (Who isn't entirely over that ordeal) & the riskiest unknowable entity they maybe ever had in their service. Is it any wonder that though they owe the continuation of their entire way of life to that crew, they don't entirely trust them so much anymore & want to keep them in their line of sight?
 
Last edited:
Interesting... and, after reading the post intro you wrote, it makes me wonder, "...careful what you wish for, Data. Being Human has the potential to really blow for you, especially when you feel the emotion of getting scr*wed over..."
 
You know, it also goes a long way to explaining away why Riker is still a mere 1st officer after BoBW. Firstly, he liked being there in his current life & felt a kinship with his comrades, among whom is a captain who's now a recovering victim, needing all the help he can get. PLUS, maybe Starfleet was like "maaaybe having our hero stick around there between the guy who can have a Borg relapse & the guy who can go haywire & commandeer our flagship isn't such a bad thing after all" :lol:

And then... Riker spent the next few years proving to be an utter disappointment, who got discovered botching up a first contact, got captured & put in a mental asylum, got nearly the entire crew addicted to some invasive game scheme, proved to be nothing but obstinate & insubordinate when command was given to someone else, & then of course, being outed altogether for conspiracy to cover up a mutiny where almost his whole crew died. :guffaw:
 
Agreed!

Especially the “…liked being there…” and
“…kinship…”.

Regarding the utter disappointment; don’t even get me started on the whole Trombone/Minuet thing…

But, more seriously, I wonder if there were Writer conversations centering on some of the points you bring up? As far as evolution of Character and Who Would Lead?
 
Coincidental: happening or existing at the same time.
Sounds like a temporal anomaly thing to me…
 
Do Starfleet officers take the blame if they do something when coerced or under some kind of mind control?
Officially, I'd say no. Picard retains his command after the Locutus business. Data gets a pass on both Brothers & Descent, & many other examples of people being possessed or brainwashed or otherwise powerless as to their involvement get forgiven... at least on paper. It's a big nasty unforgiving galaxy out there, & they all know they're risking their butts out in it.

However, some circumstances can be tricky... & some things that happen might be forgiven, but they ain't forgotten. Sisko sure didn't forget about Locutus. Picard is even shown to have some kind of distant Borg dreams or whatever going on in St: First Contact. He's not entirely clear. Nobody is just going to not consider that, & while Data wasn't in control of himself in Brothers, it was still him & his capabilities that seized the ship, & forgiveness aside, it's going to be ongoingly scary to a lot of people, especially since Lore pulled it off a 2nd time in Descent.

It's not what he did they might hold against him, it's what he represents if either it happens again, or he goes rogue by choice, or is just an unknowable potential threat. The same is true for Picard's Locutus deal.

And the line is gray. Was Ben Maxwell or Tom Riker entirely culpable for their actions, or were they suffering after-effects/PTSD or whathaveyou? It's even in the case of Will Riker & The Pegasus. Surely, he's forgiven for his involvement in the loss of the ship & the mutiny due to his low rank & cluelessness, but is he also clear of culpability in the 12 year coverup? He himself has had time to reconsider his actions ("I'd turn the phaser on you instead of them")

Riker now knows what Pressman did, & yet never came forward, & likely only saved his own hide by being the whistleblower when it came to a head. On the record, he's cleared, but behind closed doors? People are gonna think what they think about what you do or are involved in, & that can have tangible impact. In his case, we hear nothing more about command offers until the Titan 9 years later, & maybe that was by choice, but maybe not

Even Wes seemed to feel the sting of people's judgement after his cadet mishap, & Picard himself felt he had to step in to see Sito Jaxa got a fair shake after it. Otherwise? Yeah, she was under some cult type coercing, but it still probably would've followed her

I'd think it's reasonable to assume many top folks at Starfleet would be wary of both Data & Picard after Brothers & BoBW respectively
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top