• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

House: 7x15 "Bombshells" - Discussion and Spoilers

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
From TV.com:

Cuddy faces sobering news that forces her to reevaluate her priorities, while a series of dreams show glimpses into her relationship with House and her life overall. Meanwhile, while House is preoccupied with Cuddy, the team treats a troubled teen whose worsening symptoms and body scars indicate that he may have more than just a physical illness.

House Medical Reviews

This episode is either going to be really good or really terrible, based on the previews last week. So tonight we'll either finally jump that shark or we'll keep circling it.
 
The show is ever so close to jumping the shark, and have been for years and years but I don't think it ever fully went over it. Tonight's episode looks incredibly horrible. I wonder if Cuddy will die!? The suspense is killing me! :lol:
 
Darn -- with a title like "Bombshells," I was hoping it would feature the return of Olivia Wilde and Jennifer Morrison. :D
 
The narrative logic of the dream sequences didn't make a whole lot of sense to me. Some, like the My Two Dads rip, were interesting. Others, like the Julie Taymor/Across the Universe number at the end, were baffling. (Compare the sequence to Max's number in the hospital in AtU, and you'll see the similarities.)

While I'm no fan of House/Cuddy, I think Cuddy seriously over-reacted in the end.
 
I found the dreams kind of silly and unbelievable. Nobody's dreams are that linear. Even if you start out dreaming you're in a sitcom, a minute later some free association will change it to a totally different scenario. So I've never been a fan of the TV version of how dreams work. Still, they had their moments. The production number was interesting. And of course there was the Wilhelm Scream when Zombie Taub got blown away.

Overall, though, making us think Cuddy was dying and then faking us out was kind of a cheap move. I never really bought that it was for real. And then it ends up pounding the reset button, undoing all the progress House has made. We've had years of House being that person. It's worn out its welcome. He didn't become interesting again until he genuinely started trying to improve himself. Now he's probably just going to spiral back down, and I don't really see the point of that.
 
I have dreams that have a beginning, a middle, and an end. I figure that's because i read so much. We're all different. Her dreams seemed to be her subconscious trying to get her attention and she finally listened. House has always been a desperate person and next week it looks like he's going to act on that desperation. Where will they go from there?
 
I liked the dream sequences excluding the musical number which the production values and dubbing I didn't like. (Didn't sound like Hugh Laurie to me, but it may very well have been him.)

The POTW story, again, was mostly secondary and could've easily have been lifted out. I did like the use of the CGI inside-the-body thing to show us what was going on in the kid's body. I thought that was a neat way of showing this off.

I didn't buy that Cuddy was dying either and expected House to come up with some solution to save the day.

I say again for a 40-something woman Lisa Edelstein has almost flawless beauty.

I really liked the zombie dream sequence namely House's gun that was a cleaver and a shot-gun. That was fairly inspired.

Now the big ones:

House back on Vicodin. Depending on what they do with it I'm okay with it. Really, I am. House is non-discreetly inspired, in part, by Sherlock Holmes who recreationally used cocaine, Vicodin is supposed to be House's cocaine. So as long as they go back to the early-series way of him using it with little to no consequence they I'll be fine with it.

The problem I see is that the show saw what a popular character House was becoming and how Hugh Laurie was becoming a sex symbol and, I presume, decided to "lighten" his character to make him more approachable/likable as a sex symbol. (So that a drug addict wouldn't be a sex symbol.)

So the show then decided to treat the Vicodin seriously and made House suffer the effects from it, go into rehab, go through withdrawal and finally remission. So I think here with his relapse they'll treat the Vicodin "seriously" and make it a story-point again and treat his relapse with a lot of drama and impact. That I'm not so comfortable with.

This show is vastly different than the one it was even six years ago and is treading into "ER" territory where it's becoming more of a soap opera than a medical drama. So we keep. Getting. This. Huddy nonsense.

Look, I've been all for these two hooking up, I'm just not liking that it's what it seems like the damn show is about now. :rolleyes:

I suspect the Vicodin relapse won't be a big deal and he'll be able to give it up in order to be with Cuddy again who'll forgive House and then they'll be together again. But this relationship drama is just getting to be too damn much. The producers on this show need to go back and rewatch the first four seasons and learn what this show was when it was great. Now it's just "good" and I only tolerate it because it's my favorite show and House is still a bit of an interesting character (but no where nearly as interesting as he was in the first few seasons.)

I was afraid the "dream segments" were going to be much more of the musical stuff with Fox trying to appeal to the Glee audience but since the Sitcom, Zombie, and WW2 segments were interesting I was relieved. I just didn't like the musical segment. It was too corny, badly produced and the dubbing just wasn't very good.

I'd say the shark made a run for it but then like Grant driving a remote-controlled car on Mythbusters towards a ramp, it gave up at the last moment and is going in for another lap. The show is still flirting with jumping it but I don't think it quite has yet.

They need to get back to the medicine and the patients. It's focusing too much on Huddy and it's just making them both look like children that they can't make this work even when they've known each other since med school and seem to not understand the other's needs and quirks.

Again, Cuddy is seemingly surprised that House is a selfish asshole who has trouble expressing emotion. That's what you had signed up for honey, and even said you didn't mind it.

Ugh, this thing is getting frustrating but otherwise I give it a Good.
 
I liked the dream sequences excluding the musical number which the production values and dubbing I didn't like. (Didn't sound like Hugh Laurie to me, but it may very well have been him.)

That's funny because I thought it actually sounded like him and that they did a good job with it.

I have had a dream that had a true ending.
 
I liked the dream sequences excluding the musical number which the production values and dubbing I didn't like. (Didn't sound like Hugh Laurie to me, but it may very well have been him.)
That's funny because I thought it actually sounded like him and that they did a good job with it.
I also thought it sounded like Laurie.

The odd thing about the song was that Laurie (presuming it was Laurie singing) sang the song "straight." All the other examples of Laurie's singing I can think of off-hand (Jeeves & Wooster, A Bit of Fry and Laurie) have Laurie singing in a put-on kind of way.

Laurie has a blues album out this year. Let Them Talk. May in Europe, September in North America.

Overall, though, making us think Cuddy was dying and then faking us out was kind of a cheap move. I never really bought that it was for real.
For about two minutes, I thought they were actually going to go through with killing Cuddy. Something about the musical number -- probably its level of absurdity -- had me wondering if Cuddy were going to die on the operating table.

And then she didn't.

If the series had the guts it once had, Cuddy would have died.
 
I liked the dream sequences excluding the musical number which the production values and dubbing I didn't like. (Didn't sound like Hugh Laurie to me, but it may very well have been him.)
That's funny because I thought it actually sounded like him and that they did a good job with it.
I also thought it sounded like Laurie.

The odd thing about the song was that Laurie (presuming it was Laurie singing) sang the song "straight." All the other examples of Laurie's singing I can think of off-hand (Jeeves & Wooster, A Bit of Fry and Laurie) have Laurie singing in a put-on kind of way.

He's even sung once or twice in the series as House and when he's done it's in a fairly deep, gravelly, way that's much closer to House's voice.
 
Friend of mine who wanted to be a filmmaker used to have linear dreams of complete original movies, including title sequences.

I liked the Bob Fosse number at the end.
 
By the way, I forgot to mention how cool it was that they gave a shout-out to classic Doctor Who.


I liked the dream sequences excluding the musical number which the production values and dubbing I didn't like. (Didn't sound like Hugh Laurie to me, but it may very well have been him.)

It was definitely Laurie's voice. It just wasn't House's voice, i.e. Laurie wasn't singing in character.

Edelstein was clearly doing her own singing as well, but wasn't all that good, I felt. A bit reedy.


I did like the use of the CGI inside-the-body thing to show us what was going on in the kid's body. I thought that was a neat way of showing this off.

They used to do that all the time. I guess it's been a long while since they did.


House back on Vicodin. Depending on what they do with it I'm okay with it. Really, I am. House is non-discreetly inspired, in part, by Sherlock Holmes who recreationally used cocaine, Vicodin is supposed to be House's cocaine. So as long as they go back to the early-series way of him using it with little to no consequence they I'll be fine with it.

But didn't Watson eventually wean Holmes of his habit? Besides, just because Arthur Conan Doyle's era had much less understanding of the dangers and consequences of drug abuse than ours, that doesn't mean it's okay to ignore them in a modern show. This show has enough unrealistic medicine already.


The problem I see is that the show saw what a popular character House was becoming and how Hugh Laurie was becoming a sex symbol and, I presume, decided to "lighten" his character to make him more approachable/likable as a sex symbol. (So that a drug addict wouldn't be a sex symbol.)

I don't think that's at all likely, given that they didn't start to change House until the end of the fifth season. According to Wikipedia, the show's peak ratings were mostly in the second and third seasons, and the current season is getting the lowest ratings the show has had since the early first season. If the change were motivated by popularity, it would've happened years sooner.

If anything, it's more likely that it was motivated by the show's declining popularity. Like I said before, I think they made the change because the character was in a rut and they needed to give him some real growth and development in order to renew interest. Or at least to give themselves new material, since audience interest seems to be steadily declining.

After all, we're talking about a writing staff that hasn't been prone to pull its punches or fear taking risks. They do what they feel best serves the story. And a character who can grow and change and strive makes for a better story than one who just stays the same forever. Which is why I'm so disappointed that they evidently hit the reset button here.


This show is vastly different than the one it was even six years ago and is treading into "ER" territory where it's becoming more of a soap opera than a medical drama.

Historically, a large percentage of medical dramas have been soap operas.


I suspect the Vicodin relapse won't be a big deal and he'll be able to give it up in order to be with Cuddy again who'll forgive House and then they'll be together again.

An addict undergoing a relapse is always a big deal. It's not something that can be easily shaken off.


But this relationship drama is just getting to be too damn much. The producers on this show need to go back and rewatch the first four seasons and learn what this show was when it was great.

But part of what made it great was that it was fresh and new. Trying to recapture an old formula would just be imitative at this point. Stories and characters need to evolve or there's no point in continuing to tell them -- not if they're approached at all seriously as an artistic endeavor, as this show has always been.
 
This was one of their strongest episodes of the last two years. Lots of the episodes recently have striggled from not seeming to be moving forward with the plot quickly enough, this one was interesting from start to finish.

As for the finish, I'm disappointed about the breakup and the Vicodin relapse. But that's what the audience is supposed to feel about those things.

I disagree with the notion that the relationship had to end, the relationship wasn't over, it had hit the "boring" part. We've all been there, we've all gotten through it at one point or another. I think the relationship should have lasted at least a season, if not longer. Pretty much the entire relationship up till now was them worried the relationship would fall apart. They could've done better here.

As for the Vicodin, I hope this is a short term thing and not a long term one, I tend to think that Kutners suicide helped House hit bottom and hallucinations, getting him onto the road to recovery. Kutner means something in that case, if he stays on the Vicodin again, he was meaningless, which would be too bad. He was a favorite of mine on he show.

The dreams were okay, I read on TV Line that they started out with the itention of doing full segments of the show in different genres. I wish they had gone for that, it would've been awesome. As it was, it was interesting, but the potential was not fully realized.
 
Liked the episode very much. LOVED the zombie sequence! And i am sick to death of the rollercoaster aka huddy. For christs sake already, move on. Like someone else said, this is all becoming too soap opera-ish for me. I can't believe i feel this way, but i think this should be the last season. It's like they have no where else to go with the characters.
 
Liked the episode very much. LOVED the zombie sequence! And i am sick to death of the rollercoaster aka huddy. For christs sake already, move on. Like someone else said, this is all becoming too soap opera-ish for me. I can't believe i feel this way, but i think this should be the last season. It's like they have no where else to go with the characters.

The way things are with Universal and Fox there is a chance this will be the final season.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top