Hoshi versus Janeway

[iliescu]

Hoshi's skill enough to match a captain? Expertise against loyal talent kind of wonder which Trekkies more inclined towards most...

Any thoughts about which is better

Janeway commands the Voyager well but Hoshi would know ahead of time the moves the ship would make. So what outcome could there be.

 

[iliescu]

Mirror Universes are counted, so would give this to Hoshi Sato based on pure imagination.

 

[iliescu]

Janeway though has a wider array and the LCARS is more into the future. Base on intelligence, Janeway would win.

 

[F. King Daniel]

Janeway would annihilate her and eat her flesh, then turn back time itself just so she could destroy her a little quicker.

 

[somebuddyX]

 

[iliescu]

This one is Hoshi versus T'Pol.

Guess the 5th Combat contestant can be B'Elanna

 

[KimMH]

Didn’t realize your threads were fight threads. Will go with Janeway b/c old age and treachery will overcome youth and skill* and because JANEWAY.

* thx Ben.

 

[Sareesataka]

This one is Hoshi versus T'Pol.

Dang! Both T'Pol and Hoshi have really sexy midriffs.

As for Hoshi versus Janeway, I would have to give the nod to Janeway. When it comes to Janeway, not only is she the captain of Voyager, she is its matriarch. We all know when those maternal feelings of protectiveness kick in, there is nothing a mother wouldn't do to defend her family as we've seen Janeway do on a number of occasions. Hoshi grew more confident as the seasons progressed but in a battle with Janeway, my money would be on Janeway.

 

[XCV330]

Year of Hell Janeway is one hell of a survivor. I wouldn't bet against her in any kind of conflict.

 

[at Quark's]

By the time they can meet, Hoshi is like, what? 250 years old ? Even a Vulcan is quite, erm, decrepit by that age, so I'd vote Janeway ....

 

[Hopeful Romantic]

iliescu, though we appreciate your enthusiasm, keep in mind that...

a) starting 4 threads in 4 hours
b) posting more than 2 times in a row
c) posts with very little content

...are all considered spam here. Please ease down and take a little more time to participate in the discussions you've started. Thanks, and enjoy.

 

[iliescu]

Sorry for the breach, anyhow it seems Janeway wins with a side of Hoshi not giving out without a proper fight slight tendency to perhaps turn the tide. Yea year of hell was quite the arc and Hoshi meant more of should they be in the same timeline but guess age would be a factor should the timeline be normal...okay!

 

[Peter Polanski]

By the time they can meet, Hoshi is like, what? 250 years old ? Even a Vulcan is quite, erm, decrepit by that age, so I'd vote Janeway ....

And if you'll have starship with temporal reactor, which of one would you?
I would choose Hoshi. Definitely.