Heresy - Infamy - Outrage

[Plumster]

No, the trolling and flaming comes from calling critics of the movie "Fundamentalists", "zealots", "bashers", or anything along those lines, or for that matter suggesting all critics are alike and just a bunch of stereotypical basement nerds or what have you.

Agreed. It's particularly obvious when you look at the name of this thread that it is designed to inflame certain passions.

Besides Plumster, I'm not really sure what your argument is. The botanical garden windows didn't appear until the refit, so in fact their absence lends a greater air of canonicity to the movie.

Thanks for the attention to detail! You must really love canon.

Anyone feeling raped by the fact that the secondary hull does not have those nice big windows that we get to see in loving flypasts of the TOS movie big E?

From my original post on the topic.

It is my lack of attention to detail that you need to highlight actually big boy.

Are you saying, as well, that we cannot debate something because a few thousand get their comfort knickers in a twist over such a subject?

What was the point of your post? I've read it a couple of times but it's not saying anything.

Do you feel abused and dirty because of this film?

 

[Akiraprise]

Enter the killjoy.

I didn't see much good coming out of this thread when I first looked at it. I was just going to close it and finger wag for taking a jab at some members of the forum who don't care for the flick. Then I saw these two gems by you Plumster:

So knobby, we are not allowed to debate this are we?

So I'm clear?

Or is it actually self evident that there is, in fact, such a debate to be had simply by the indignation you feel?

Are you saying, as well, that we cannot debate something because a few thousand get their comfort knickers in a twist over such a subject?

What was the point of your post? I've read it a couple of times but it's not saying anything.

Do you feel abused and dirty because of this film?

They get you a trolling warning.