• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Hells yeah! Moffat does it again! 'Blink' wins Hugo!

Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

This is GREAT news although I would've liked to have seen Paul Cornell win this still great news none the less. :cool:
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

One of my favourite episodes on TV of all time and of any show. It deserves all the awards that it gets.
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

Excellent news! I'm very happy Moffat got the hat trick! :D
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

This is GREAT news although I would've liked to have seen Paul Cornell win this still great news none the less. :cool:
Seconded. While I think Cornell's two-parter was the highlight of the season, "Blink" certainly isn't undeserving of a Hugo.
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

Congrats to Moffat on a job well done.

Personally, I'm surprised there was any doubt that "Blink" would win. While Cornell's 2-parter was excellent, think about how many items with "The angels have the telephone box" on it have cropped up. "Blink" latched onto fandom in a way that Cornell's 2-parter just didn't quite manage, and these are the fans voting here.

I would like to see the voting numbers, though. I wonder if it hit four digits?
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

Congrats to Moffat on a job well done.

Personally, I'm surprised there was any doubt that "Blink" would win. While Cornell's 2-parter was excellent, think about how many items with "The angels have the telephone box" on it have cropped up. "Blink" latched onto fandom in a way that Cornell's 2-parter just didn't quite manage, and these are the fans voting here.

I would like to see the voting numbers, though. I wonder if it hit four digits?

I would think that the degree to which something from the episode has "latched onto fandom" (and you mean "latched onto by fandom," surely?) has less to do with what should get a Hugo than the actual quality of the writing, right?

Not that I disagree; as good as "Human Nature" was, I think "Blink" is even better: more concise, more emotionally engaging (and again, in comparison to "Human Nature," that's saying something), and it manages superbly the difficult task of being an episode of a television series in which the lead character barely appears, but still manages to make his presence felt throughout the episode.
 
'Blink' wins Hugo

I haven't seen this anywhere else in the forum so I don't think it's a double post, but if it is please close this thread.

Anyhoo, 'Blink' won the Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form, on Saturday night, making it three in a row for a certain Mr. Moffat. Truly there can be no fears about him taking over as Executive Producer and Head Writer!
:techman:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/s4/news/latest/110808_news_01
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

Congrats to Moffat on a job well done.

Personally, I'm surprised there was any doubt that "Blink" would win. While Cornell's 2-parter was excellent, think about how many items with "The angels have the telephone box" on it have cropped up. "Blink" latched onto fandom in a way that Cornell's 2-parter just didn't quite manage, and these are the fans voting here.

I would like to see the voting numbers, though. I wonder if it hit four digits?

I would think that the degree to which something from the episode has "latched onto fandom" (and you mean "latched onto by fandom," surely?) has less to do with what should get a Hugo than the actual quality of the writing, right?

Not that I disagree; as good as "Human Nature" was, I think "Blink" is even better: more concise, more emotionally engaging (and again, in comparison to "Human Nature," that's saying something), and it manages superbly the difficult task of being an episode of a television series in which the lead character barely appears, but still manages to make his presence felt throughout the episode.

Actually, it's a little bit of both, fandom latched onto "Blink", but "Blink" definitely returned the favor.

With the Hugos, the quality product winning is never a given. I think many of us here remember the year Gollum's Acceptance Speech at the MTV Movie Awards won the Hugo for Best Dramatic Presentation-Short form over not one, but 2 episodes of Firefly and the finale of Buffy. Which really proves that there were far more rabid LOTR fans than Firefly or Buffy fans at that WorldCon and the one before it. (Seriously, it did. 2004, you can check. Possibly one of the most controversial Hugo awards ever, if the "WTF?" chatter going around the convention afterward was any indicator.)
If something has grabbed fandom the way "Blink" did, it's got a far better chance of walking away with the award, because the fans are going to vote for what they like, even if it's not the best piece in the batch or even really justifiably in the batch. And when you're only talking a few hundred or so fans actually voting, all it takes is the right people casting ballots. All it takes is an organized voting block to get something on the ballot. If that same voting block is then the dominant vote on the award, it wins.

The Hugos are like the People's Choice Awards, only with far fewer voters. That's why I was curious if it made 4 digits.
 
Re: 'Blink' wins Hugo

Oops, sorry. Dunno how I missed that I went back and checked all the other threads. :) Might as well close this one.
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

Don't suppose anyone has found a quote from Moffat. I'm curious to see if he visited Starlog offices again this year.
 
Re: Hells yeah! Moffat does it again!

I think the difference was that you had to already be a Who fan to get the most out of 'Human Nature'. With its bizarre aliens, and the way the story played around with time, 'Blink' was a story that could be appreciated by fans who might not even be familiar with the DW.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top