• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Harry Potter-esque stories

the_wildcard

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Hello, does anybody have any recommendations on books similar to the Harry Potter series? Wizards, elves, humans, etc, etc.
 
Last edited:
Way back when I was referred to The Golden Compass et al. as being a sort of dark Harry Potter trilogy. In retrospect they're quite the reading experience (and things get much crazier than you'd expect at the outset), but I don't know whether they're really very HP'esque.
 
Way back when I was referred to The Golden Compass et al. as being a sort of dark Harry Potter trilogy. In retrospect they're quite the reading experience (and things get much crazier than you'd expect at the outset), but I don't know whether they're really very HP'esque.

I think there is a significant gap, the Dark trilogy as a series is one that sits in that grey area between juvenile and adult fiction and has some very particular arguments that it tries to advance (and we could argue about what they are). The potter books are books for children (and there is nothing wrong with that) which have been appropriated by adults in some way that I don't quite understand - I don't think beyond some superficial aspects of both featuring some similar fantasy trappings that they occupy anything like the same space.
 
Please, please, please!

Read the Discworld novels! Specifically the Tiffany Aching sequence: Wee Free Men, Hat Full of Sky, Wintersmith, and (soon to come out) I Shall Wear Midnight. These books are much, much better than the Potters. They place emphasis on when not to use magic, which is even more important than knowing when to use it, and in some ways teens can take something from that, a subtle lesson about character.
 
Last edited:
I have to add my two cents and suggest the Newbery Medal-winning The Graveyard Book.

I just read that this month and adored it. It's a one-shot, not a series, but it has such a sense of completeness, it doesn't need a sequel. It has ghosts, ghouls, a vampire, a witch and the sinister "Jacks." Surprisingly, it is one of the most touching, charming and entertaining books I've read in a long time, and I am a very, very hard to please reader.

It does have similar elements to Harry Potter--the young boy, raised in a strange world that exists side-by-side with our world, whose parents were killed by a mysterious villian that he, too, must some day face. But I have to say that I thought The Graveyard Book was actually better written and, in its own dark way, more emotionally effective.
 
Hmm, orphan with a destiny, magical powers, Dumbledore like mentor figures...

This may be hard to find. It's probably out of print, and it is pretty obscure, but you might want to try this story called, Star Wars... :p
 
Jonathan Stroud's The Bartimaeus Trilogy starting with The Amulet of Samarkand. It's a sort of alternative history where magicians are the ruling class of turn of the century England.
 
Hmm, orphan with a destiny, magical powers, Dumbledore like mentor figures...

This may be hard to find. It's probably out of print, and it is pretty obscure, but you might want to try this story called, Star Wars...

Hmmm... Sounds like the Hero's Journey to me. :D

Seriously, people, who cares? My junior-year college fiction professor did an in-class assignment showing how you can take something like the fable of the fox, the crow, and the cheese and use the basic underlying structure and fiddle with the surface to make it your own.

It's all about how you make something your own. Even Shakespeare, whose works have been re-made thousands of times, did repackaging of older tales himself!
 
Circle of Magic!

There are actually two series with this tittle. The more well-known one is a quartet written by Tam Pierce in the late 90s. They are all very good.

The other is a series of six written by James McDonald and Deb Doyle a decade earlier. It is an excellent series.

Be warned, both are meant for a slightly younger age group than HP. Like 8-11 or so. The last time I read them I was 13 myself so I can't say how well they translate to an older audience.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top