• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

GUARDIANS of the GALAXY - Grading & Discussion

Grade the movie...


  • Total voters
    249
All right, I finally got the opportunity to watch this today.

I have no idea how anyone couldn't have loved it. Seriously, what was there to not like about it? Not a single thing, that's what. Those who say otherwise are dead inside and have no taste whatsoever.
 
I LOVED this! It was on par with Winter Soldier for me! I give this an A.

Marvel Studios just humiliated FOX by giving us a great Cosmic Marvel movie, while FOX keeps giving us misfire after misfire Fantastic Four films.
 
I LOVED this! It was on par with Winter Soldier for me! I give this an A.

Marvel Studios just humiliated FOX by giving us a great Cosmic Marvel movie, while FOX keeps giving us misfire after misfire Fantastic Four films.
It's because Marvel actually cares about their properties. FOX and the other studios are just trying to make some cash. And it shows.
 
I LOVED this! It was on par with Winter Soldier for me! I give this an A.

Marvel Studios just humiliated FOX by giving us a great Cosmic Marvel movie, while FOX keeps giving us misfire after misfire Fantastic Four films.

Fox just had Days of Future Past. Give credit where it's due. I'm not optimistic about Fox's new FF film, but keep in mind they haven't released a single Fantastic Four film since Iron Man.
 
Y'know the whole "Ronan supercharged his Universal Weapon with the Power Stone" thing made me wonder: could Thor 3 feature the MCU version of Surtur wielding Twilight, a Fire Demon sword powered by another Infinity Stone?

After it was revealed that the Tesseract was the MCU version of the Cosmic Cube and an Infinity Stone, I was a bit surprised that the Casket of Ancient Winters wasn't an Infinity Stone as well.
I believe that the only Infinity Gems/Stones that we haven't seen yet are the Soul Gem and the Time Gem (assuming you believe that Loki's staff houses the Mind Gem, which hasn't been confirmed, I don't think).

I think the Soul Gem could easily feature in Doctor Strange.

io9 did an article on Guardians and had a section the stones. Apparently, James Gunn confirmed Ronan was using the Power Gem. They back you up on the gems and speculate that the Soul Gem will appear along with Adam Warlock. What appears to be a cocoon that Adam has been known to use is seen in the Collector's display case. Of course, it could be Kismet, which would be a big fake-out! But, since Adam has a special relationship with the Soul Gem, it would be nice if he were to show up with it. Especially given his role in the Infinity Guantlet mini-series and his frenemy status with Thanos.

But to further back-up these, here's what we've seen them do:

  • The Tesseract powered Hydra's weapons, but also was used by Thor to transport back to Asgard at the end of The Avengers. This most likely would make it the Space Gem.
  • The Aether seemed to control the portals that showed up leading to the Convergence. Since the Covergence involved different realities, it seems this would make the Aether the Reality Gem
  • Loki's staff, when utilized, allowed him to take control of others, including Hawkeye, Dr. Selvig, and a few S.H.I.E.L.D. operatives.
  • Ronan's stone was shown with the ability to destroy things. It was feared that simply allowing the stone to touch a planet could cause it's destruction. Seems pretty powerful to me. And, again, according to the i09 article, James Gunn confirms this to be the Reality gem.

I agree, a Doctor Strange movie with the Soul Gem making its MCU appearance makes sense. The Time Gem is a bit trickier. Given the success of The Winter Solider, I'd say it's likely we won't see the Time Gem in Captain America 3, though the storytelling possibilities of a Gem that would allow Steve to travel back to the 40's is interesting, if nothing else.

It's really too bad Sony owns X-Men because the Time Gem would help answer one of the main problems with Days of Future Past, namely, "Why was Kitty suddenly able to transport people through time?" Granted, they didn't want to use Rachael Summers (and rightly so, they don't need to further complicate things. Not to mention, it would have possibly spoiled a reveal at the end). But, I digress.

Honestly, I think they'd be best suited only having the Time Gem utilized for short jumps in time. While DoFP worked, time travel is tricky at best. It could be used well, and it could be used horribly. Though, going back to what I said earlier, it would be great to see Steve zapped by something in Age of Ultron and disappear during the climax. Then, during a scene during or after the credits, he awakens to find himself back in the 1940's.

Of course, those familiar with the comics know that Age of Ultron, the comic storyline, involved time travel, with Ultron attacking them from the future...
http://www.pinterest.com/pin/create/extension/
 
The Tesseract powered Hydra's weapons, but also was used by Thor to transport back to Asgard at the end of The Avengers. This most likely would make it the Space Gem.
Kevin Feige (I believe) confirmed in one of his interviews that the Tesseract was the Space Gem.

Of course, those familiar with the comics know that Age of Ultron, the comic storyline, involved time travel, with Ultron attacking them from the future...
I rather doubt that means anything.

Captain America 3 has a host of story points to deal with in the present day. There'd be nothing gained by traveling back in time.
 
I have no idea how anyone couldn't have loved it. Seriously, what was there to not like about it?
Groot's takedown of the Monstrous Inmate seemed excessively violent. (Seriously, ripping his nose off?)

The general large quantities of faceless mook deaths got boring after a while.

Gamora seemed to turn to the side of Good a bit quickly.
I liked the movie. I don't think I loved it.
 
  • Ronan's stone was shown with the ability to destroy things. It was feared that simply allowing the stone to touch a planet could cause it's destruction. Seems pretty powerful to me. And, again, according to the i09 article, James Gunn confirms this to be the Reality gem.
Uh, you must have made a typo because it's established that the Orb from Guardians of the Galaxy houses the Power Stone.

Of course, those familiar with the comics know that Age of Ultron, the comic storyline, involved time travel, with Ultron attacking them from the future...
Feige or someone has stated that Avengers: Age of Ultron only borrows the name of the comic storyline.

Here's ScreenRant's compilation of updates on the MCU Infinity Stones from yesterday. I can't find any errors in it.
http://screenrant.com/infinity-stones-gauntlet-marvel-movies/
 
But to further back-up these, here's what we've seen them do:

  • The Tesseract powered Hydra's weapons, but also was used by Thor to transport back to Asgard at the end of The Avengers. This most likely would make it the Space Gem.
  • The Aether seemed to control the portals that showed up leading to the Convergence. Since the Covergence involved different realities, it seems this would make the Aether the Reality Gem
  • Loki's staff, when utilized, allowed him to take control of others, including Hawkeye, Dr. Selvig, and a few S.H.I.E.L.D. operatives.
  • Ronan's stone was shown with the ability to destroy things. It was feared that simply allowing the stone to touch a planet could cause it's destruction. Seems pretty powerful to me. And, again, according to the i09 article, James Gunn confirms this to be the Reality gem.
The Tesseract also ripped open a portal in space and sucked the Red Skull into it (assuming he didn't just get vaporized, which I'm still not convinced happened since he's Cap's arch-enemy), which would also add to the evidence that it's the Space Stone. And while this has already been covered, on that last one I think you meant to say that James Gunn confirmed the stone in GotG to be the Power Stone.

I agree that it seems pretty likely that we'll see one of the stones in Doctor Strange; probably the Soul Stone. I wonder if they'll turn the Eye of Agamotto into an Infinity Stone. I think it'd fit right in with how they've adapted the other stones so far in the MCU, and help simplify things (cut down on the various mystical objects out there). I do wonder if they'll actually introduce Adam Warlock, or just have Doctor Strange cover some of Warlock's role in the Infinity saga.
 
I thought this was six out of ten - good but not amazing but nice to see a cameo from Hyperion.

I must've completely missed it. Where was the Hyperion cameo?


He's in a collector cage - you see his red cape and blond hair - he is on screen for about 30 seconds in total but always from the back.

The thing I thought was interesting/strange - Drax wasn't much of a destroyer.
 
  • Ronan's stone was shown with the ability to destroy things. It was feared that simply allowing the stone to touch a planet could cause it's destruction. Seems pretty powerful to me. And, again, according to the i09 article, James Gunn confirms this to be the Reality gem.
Uh, you must have made a typo because it's established that the Orb from Guardians of the Galaxy houses the Power Stone.

Would you believe I wrote "Power Gem," and someone used the Aether to change reality to the point where I wrote it wrong? :cool:

But to further back-up these, here's what we've seen them do:

  • The Tesseract powered Hydra's weapons, but also was used by Thor to transport back to Asgard at the end of The Avengers. This most likely would make it the Space Gem.
  • The Aether seemed to control the portals that showed up leading to the Convergence. Since the Covergence involved different realities, it seems this would make the Aether the Reality Gem
  • Loki's staff, when utilized, allowed him to take control of others, including Hawkeye, Dr. Selvig, and a few S.H.I.E.L.D. operatives.
  • Ronan's stone was shown with the ability to destroy things. It was feared that simply allowing the stone to touch a planet could cause it's destruction. Seems pretty powerful to me. And, again, according to the i09 article, James Gunn confirms this to be the Reality gem.
The Tesseract also ripped open a portal in space and sucked the Red Skull into it (assuming he didn't just get vaporized, which I'm still not convinced happened since he's Cap's arch-enemy), which would also add to the evidence that it's the Space Stone. And while this has already been covered, on that last one I think you meant to say that James Gunn confirmed the stone in GotG to be the Power Stone.

Yeah, I did. It is possible Hydra's weapons utilized the Space Gem's power to transport the molecules of those hit by the souped-up weapons throughout the Nine Realms, I guess. Perhaps the Red Skull ends up somewhere in the Nine Realms, stumbling upon the Time Gem, which he uses to get to the 21st Century.

I agree that it seems pretty likely that we'll see one of the stones in Doctor Strange; probably the Soul Stone. I wonder if they'll turn the Eye of Agamotto into an Infinity Stone. I think it'd fit right in with how they've adapted the other stones so far in the MCU, and help simplify things (cut down on the various mystical objects out there). I do wonder if they'll actually introduce Adam Warlock, or just have Doctor Strange cover some of Warlock's role in the Infinity saga.
The Orb of Agamotto was seen in Odin's Trophy Room. Would Odin have the Infinity Guantlet, the Tesseract/Space Gem, and the Orb of Agamotto/Possible gem, all in the same room? I realize the gauntlet is just a fancy glove without the gems in it, but given the destructive power of un-contained stones as seen in Guardians, would you leave around a handy tool to contain the six gems in a room with two of them?

Of course, the Collector was amassing them, so what do I know?

The Tesseract powered Hydra's weapons, but also was used by Thor to transport back to Asgard at the end of The Avengers. This most likely would make it the Space Gem.
Kevin Feige (I believe) confirmed in one of his interviews that the Tesseract was the Space Gem.

Okay, so we have confirmation! Cool!

Feige or someone has stated that Avengers: Age of Ultron only borrows the name of the comic storyline.

Oh, I know, I was just commenting on it. The kind of thinking that makes sense late at night, but not so much in the morning!

Of course, those familiar with the comics know that Age of Ultron, the comic storyline, involved time travel, with Ultron attacking them from the future...
I rather doubt that means anything.

Captain America 3 has a host of story points to deal with in the present day. There'd be nothing gained by traveling back in time.

Yeah, again, I was wildly speculating. I was just wondering how they could introduce the Time Gem.

And, yes, TWS set us up with plenty of modern day story points for Cap. And I did say earlier that it would never happen, but, it would be cool to see Steve deal with being back in 1940 again. Would he stay or try to get back to the present day?

With TWS having a more "grounded" tone to it, I doubt they'll re-introduce fantasy elements into the Cap movies. They'll save dealing with space/reality/time/mind/soul/power warping things in Avengers.

Sort of like how most Batman comics have him fight street/Gotham level craziness, saving his fights with aliens/robots/time travel/etc. for team-ups or his time in the JLA.

I love the scene in JLA: Classified where Batman reveals his Sci-Fi Closet and tells Alfred not to tell the Gotham PD about it!
http://www.pinterest.com/pin/create/extension/
 
First time in many years that I've heard a full theater laughing every few mins, Rocket Raccoon is my new favourite Marvel character (since his snarky and stubborn attitude resembles my nephew'a so well).

From beginning to end this film pleases on every front as the Guardians' humour was nicely contrasted by a genocidal maniac named Ronan (Lee Pace) and the epic introduction of another key Marvel player Thanos of Titan (brief cameo in Avengers 1). Also this entry was surprisingly plot/exposition heavy, weaving in back story for future Marvel-Cinematic-Universe characters and events.


Solid A for me.
 
Last edited:
First time in many years that I've heard a full theater laughing every few mins, Rocket Raccoon is my new favourite Marvel character (since his snarky and stubborn attitude resembles my nephew'a so well).

From beginning to end this film pleases on every front as the Guardians' humour was nicely contrasted by a genocidal maniac named Ronan (Lee Pace) and the epic introduction of another key Marvel player Thanos of Titan (brief cameo in Avengers 1). Also this entry was surprisingly plot/exposition heavy, weaving in back story for future Marvel-Cinematic-Universe characters and events.


Solid A for me.

Speaking of laughing. As much as I liked the movie, whenever I think about it the first image that comes to mind is always the scene with Groot and Drax at the beginning of the closing seconds. The whole theater seemed to enjoy that.
 
I just watched it today at the cinema. Its a good and fun movie that definitely stands out from recent series of blockbusters, but it is also kinda formulaic and the story is not really what I would call amazing.

And yes, dancing baby Groot is cute :) As for Howard the Duck, I still prefer how he looked in the first movie. It may have been a crappy movie, but Howard itself was cute. Not really digging the stretched out head in the post-credit teaser.
 
  • Ronan's stone was shown with the ability to destroy things. It was feared that simply allowing the stone to touch a planet could cause it's destruction. Seems pretty powerful to me. And, again, according to the i09 article, James Gunn confirms this to be the Reality gem.
Uh, you must have made a typo because it's established that the Orb from Guardians of the Galaxy houses the Power Stone.

Would you believe I wrote "Power Gem," and someone used the Aether to change reality to the point where I wrote it wrong? :cool:



Yeah, I did. It is possible Hydra's weapons utilized the Space Gem's power to transport the molecules of those hit by the souped-up weapons throughout the Nine Realms, I guess. Perhaps the Red Skull ends up somewhere in the Nine Realms, stumbling upon the Time Gem, which he uses to get to the 21st Century.

The Orb of Agamotto was seen in Odin's Trophy Room. Would Odin have the Infinity Guantlet, the Tesseract/Space Gem, and the Orb of Agamotto/Possible gem, all in the same room? I realize the gauntlet is just a fancy glove without the gems in it, but given the destructive power of un-contained stones as seen in Guardians, would you leave around a handy tool to contain the six gems in a room with two of them?

Of course, the Collector was amassing them, so what do I know?
The way I saw it, the Tesseract generates energy in order to open wormholes, and quantities of its energy can be channeled into other containment devices (i.e. battery packs for HYDRA rifles or as S.H.I.E.L.D. and NASA hoped in some fashion, the energy grid). HYDRA weapons utilized Tesseract energy to sustainably fire plasma. Since Red Skull was a mere mortal (as evidenced by the Collector's explanation of the Stones), handling it on his own triggered an energy discharge that disintegrated him.

How would you explain that if the crystal on Loki's scepter is indeed the Mind Stone, then why didn't Thor recognize it and take custody of it as well?

And I doubt the Orb of Agamotto is an Infinity Stone because Volstagg clearly stated that "It is unwise to keep two Infinity Stones so close to each other." in regards to the Tesseract and the Aether, so I don't see how the Orb of Agamotto could be excepted.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top