Just got done rewatching it for the first time since seeing it in the theater and yeah, it's definitely the best of the new films. Leaves me with a "FUCK YEAH, STAR WARS!" feeling which TFA and TLJ both failed to do. The absolutely nailed the production design in recreating the look of all the OT stuff, while at the same time updating it all to look not as cheap under close scrutiny. And the Battle of Scarif is hands down the best Star Wars battle we've seen. Just amazing.