• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers God-level tech aliens and who wasn't mentioned

If the Organians were disgusted over that Klingon skirmish in Errand of Mercy, one only wonders what they thought of the Temporal Wars. We can presume now that the Q did not take part in all that. And as for the Prophets I'm curious how the Temporal War is perceived to them since they experience time in a different fashion.
 
Vance said the Q weren't being considered due to it being six hundred years since last contact with them and that the DMA wasn't really something in character for them. Presumably the list of aliens he provided are races that meet the criteria of capability, known motives and availability. Creating the DMA doesn't really seem like something the Prophets or the Organians would do, and if it's been too long since the last reported contact with either of them, then that would further disqualify them.

Interesting thoughts. So then, the Metrons, Nacene, and Iconians were considered the most likely suspects, based on motive and opportunity (and, of course, ability), but were ruled out by some unrevealed factor? Does Starfleet have some way of contacting those three entities, then? Or monitoring them in any fashion?

It's a fun reveal that the Iconians are a known entity in the 32nd century, despite being considered a long-lost civilization in the 24th.
 
Interesting thoughts. So then, the Metrons, Nacene, and Iconians were considered the most likely suspects, based on motive and opportunity (and, of course, ability), but were ruled out by some unrevealed factor? Does Starfleet have some way of contacting those three entities, then? Or monitoring them in any fashion?

It's a fun reveal that the Iconians are a known entity in the 32nd century, despite being considered a long-lost civilization in the 24th.
Vance: So, are any of you responsible for the anomaly?
Metrons: Not me!
Nacene: Of course not.
Iconians: We're innocent.
Federation Betazoid assistant: They all seem to be honest.
 
So then, the Metrons, Nacene, and Iconians were considered the most likely suspects, based on motive and opportunity (and, of course, ability), but were ruled out by some unrevealed factor?
Who said they were ruled out? Vance only said the Q were ruled out, presumably the Metrons, Nacene and Iconians are still considered suspects, or at least species of interest.
 
Who said they were ruled out? Vance only said the Q were ruled out, presumably the Metrons, Nacene and Iconians are still considered suspects, or at least species of interest.

You're right, my bad. I thought they were ruled out for some reason. The exact lines are:
Vance said:
Most important being who's behind this anomaly. Federation Security has identified a number of civilizations that may possess technology this advanced. The Metrons, the Nacene, the surviving members of the Iconian empire. The Q Continuum were considered as well. But as there has been no contact for 600 years and this is unlike anything they've done before, we don't believe it's them.

That suggests that the four civilizations (Metrons, Nacene, surviving Iconians, Q) are simply ones of the number of super-advanced ones that possibly could have done this. Not that necessarily would have.

But the fact that Vance rules out the Q for being incommunicado for 600 years and not prone to destruction (oddly), makes one think the other three, not ruled out, have been causing issues in the last 600 years, or have done significantly destructive or anarchic behavior of this magnitude.

I don't think Unknown Species 10-C will be any of these namedropped ones, but it's interesting to parse the words and see what it reveals about Federation history and these groups.
 
If the Organians were disgusted over that Klingon skirmish in Errand of Mercy, one only wonders what they thought of the Temporal Wars. We can presume now that the Q did not take part in all that. And as for the Prophets I'm curious how the Temporal War is perceived to them since they experience time in a different fashion.
They were only disgusted because the Feds and the Klingons were playing in their yard.
 
Pretty clear these were prime suspects and others were either ruled out, not likely, or known to be not involved. And doubt it’s a comprehensive list. It’s more of a way to say “fans, we did our homework, don’t worry”.

So it’s the whale probe builders. They really don’t like us. Or maybe that’s why starships have Cetacean ops!!!!!?!
 
There's also the Automated Repair Station from "DEAD STOP" (ENT).

It was obviously intelligent and processed advanced tech far beyond anything known back during Archer's time.
(it was also repairing itself at the end of the episode)

Over the intervening centuries it could have developed something akin to 'Godlike' powers.
(also, there have been a lot of ENTERPRISE references so far this season)
:shrug:
 
What about the Preservers, Species 8472, Sphere Builders, Borg, Cytherians, Founders, or Voth?
Well, we know the Dominion is being regularly monitored by Starfleet Command, as per a computer graphic in season 3. Presumably, that monitoring has provided sufficient enough evidence to rule the Founders out as suspects.
How about a race from the MU?
As per Kovich, contact between the Prime and Mirror Universes hasn't been possible since the 27th century.
 
Missed this topic earlier and haven't seen the new episode yet.

What about the Synths from Picard? I don't think it'll be them, but they might qualify.

The Paxxons from TNG "Clues" might be advanced enough, and if they thought species in local space had become too advanced to hide from, they might try different methods. The Lactrans from TAS would be another, Excalbians too. If you include the Nacene, might as well include Douwd. Edo god maybe?
 
Well, we know the Dominion is being regularly monitored by Starfleet Command, as per a computer graphic in season 3. Presumably, that monitoring has provided sufficient enough evidence to rule the Founders out as suspects.

As per Kovich, contact between the Prime and Mirror Universes hasn't been possible since the 27th century.

Didn't catch that Dominion mention last season. Thanks.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top