• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Gamma-Hydra Judges

Many of you may not watch American Idol; I do. I get into each year, me and my wife both. This year is no different. So I was watching the American Idol charity show last night, Idol Gives back, and I asked my self; which three characters spanning the known Star Trek Universe (meaning you cant select Zubby the Tribble, or Wazzo the fly) would make the best counter-parts two the established American Idol judges...

For example..

Simon Cowell..snobby, know it all Brit. I would go with Moriarty. I think his comments after each singer would be very interesting indeed.

Leetah...About as brainless as Paula Abdul, and bi-sexual also. Perfect for the 'you look great' useless comments

Randy Jackson...This person has to be hip, in with the younger crowd..hmmmmm..this one is tough..but I would go with either Guinan (in her younger years) or maybe the dude who Kirk neck pinched on the bus.


Robert Scorpio lives!!!
 
Right off I can't say... it will take some thought when I have the time, but an interesting idea.
Troi for the Paula Abdul spot
young Chekov was supposed to relate to the younger crowd, so I'd say him as Randy Jackson
Q would be the ultimate smartass Simon Cowell counterpart.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top