• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Game of Thrones 1.9 - "Baelor" - Rate and discuss

Grading


  • Total voters
    50

Out Of My Vulcan Mind

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Rate and discuss (with spoilers for the episode, but not for forthcoming episodes) "Baelor", airing on the 12th June on HBO and on the 13th June on Sky Atlantic.

[yt]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VwEQgMCmyeQ[/yt]
 
I watched this with my father, who has not read the books, and I cannot explain his shock. It had the same results as when I read it in the book. Amazing ending sequence.
 
I managed to finish the book last week, so I had an idea what would happen in this episode. Still, it was a shock to see Ned executed as his poor daughters had to watch. He really did not win the game.
 
^
What Martin said. Damn! I wasn't expecting that ending at all. Wow! I wasn't feeling the episode all that much, but the end totally floored me.


Spoilers below....






I'm going to miss Sean Bean. Not necessarily because I felt that his Stark was a great character, but he brought gravitas and a quiet, weary dignity to the role. I will largely miss him because his son Rob seems like a wet blanket. The Stark women are far more interesting characters than the Stark men. Hopefully we'll get the other Baratheon brothers involved soon in this rebellion.
 
Ahh, and here we have it, the biggest shocker of the first book. Great ending scene, HOWEVER... I was a little underwhelmed with the rest of the episode. Definitely not as good as last week's. The TV budget limitations really reared their ugly head here. The first two battles of the war, and we see NONE of the fighting, nor does Tyrion even get to fight, as he does in the book. And we don't even get an inkling of what happened at the Battle of the Whispering Wood, not even that it was at night, only that Jaime was captured. Really makes me worried about you-know-what at the end of season two.

-No real complaints about the Frey stuff (cept maybe the rather small audience hall), although Lord Walder sure doesn't look 90 does he?

-Heartbreaking to see Dany's world falling apart. The episode didn't quite capture the chaos of it all though. More killing in the book as I recall. I liked the sounds coming from the tent, but missed the imagery of the shadows moving within.

-Good stuff at the wall. Longclaw! Always loved the revelation that Aemon was a Targaryen.

-Was wondering where they were going with the drinking game scene until "Ahah, the Tysha story!"

-As I said, great scene to end the episode with, but... kind of lousy setting. Budget limitations again. Don't really even see the Sept of Baelor, and what the heck was that thing they were all standing on supposed to be anyway? Looks like we may possibly get a little bit of of the first ACoK Arya chapter next week?
 
I like this guy's reaction:

[yt]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOoA1OtcNjM[/yt]

I dunno, I was never a huge fan of Ned. To me it's actually refreshing to see all his idealistic bullshit come to an end at the whims of a little bastard fuckface. When I read the book I saw it coming, I forget if it was foreshadowed or if I just had more time to ponder what a fuckface Joffrey is.

I think HBO is doing pretty well, yeah I'd love to get big theatrical battle scenes... but it's TV, despite what the HBO marketing department tells ya.
 
:eek: :vulcan: :eek:

I liked it! Expected a lot of what happened, but damn it impresses me nonetheless.
 
Hmmm, not so sure about that, kind of like the last episode of Doctor Who, the "big moment" left me just scratching my head. More of a bemused "What?" instead of a "Oh my God!". I don't know where it occurs in the book but after nine episodes of following Ned with only one more left it seems like an odd place to end.

At least the epic battles kept me distracted, oh wait...

I would like to thank everyone for not spoiling anything though.
 
I have never hated a fictional character more than I hate this little inbred fucking Joffrey whatever-bastard-name-he really-deserves.

Great episode. I've read the book three times and still the scenes with Dany's world falling apart and Ned's death were emotional to me ...

I wonder whether killing off the biggest star of the show will have an effect on the ratings ...
 
Also, I remember seeing the guy who recognized Arya before, but can't place what he was all about.

He's Yoren of the Night's Watch, who Tyrion was drinking with back at the beginning, and in an earlier episode met with Ned to ask for men to take to the wall (hence his recognising Arya).
 
I have never hated a fictional character more than I hate this little inbred fucking Joffrey whatever-bastard-name-he really-deserves.

Great episode. I've read the book three times and still the scenes with Dany's world falling apart and Ned's death were emotional to me ...

I wonder whether killing off the biggest star of the show will have an effect on the ratings ...

Since the show is like the Wire who knows how long you have to suffer his existence.
 
I have never hated a fictional character more than I hate this little inbred fucking Joffrey whatever-bastard-name-he really-deserves.

Great episode. I've read the book three times and still the scenes with Dany's world falling apart and Ned's death were emotional to me ...

I wonder whether killing off the biggest star of the show will have an effect on the ratings ...

Since the show is like the Wire who knows how long you have to suffer his existence.
Joffrey's existence? I know how long we have to suffer him :)
 
Even having read the book, I was still shocked at Ned's death. Great build-up. The lack of seeing any of the battles was disappointing, but anticipated. I dealt with it in Rome and still loved that series, so I can see myself still loving GoT as well.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top