• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them?

23skidoo

Admiral
Admiral
The Huffington Post posted an interesting slideshow today of proposed, ultra-futuristic-looking skyscrapers. There's one that looks like a crystal, and another made from shipping containers. Here's the link:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/11/15-mind-blowing-skyscrapers_n_847427.html#s263074

Although entertaining I find these sorts of things ultimately frustrating. For years we've been seeing architects do these exercises in design - the skyscrapers of the 21st century, they call them - but no one has ever bothered to actually build any of them.

Closest we have seen, really, is the Burj Khalifi in Dubai. But they keep talking about things like the mile-high city that was planned offshore in Tokyo at one point, or, well, any of the ones in that slideshow. But no one's really make any obvious effort to make these things real.

Of course, there are the realities of budgets, government instability, etc. I get that. And there's no point in building something like the Burj Khalifi if no one will use it (an extreme example of this being the South Asia Mall in China which is the world's largest shopping mall with room for 1,500 stores, but only a dozen are actually open). And from what I've gathered, the BK was hell to construct. And there's also that thing in North Korea that was supposed to be the world's tallest hotel that went nowhere.

But I guess the point I'm making is when will these types of builds stop being mental exercises and start becoming real? Maybe not all the ones in this slideshow (that shipping container one looks a bit daft, and the one in Paris looks like a giant Gumby), but with all these high hopes (pun intended) for futuristic construction, is there actually any serious intent to make any of these structures real? Here in Alberta they made a big deal out of Western Canada's tallest building going up in Calgary - but it really looks no different than buildings put up 30 years ago.

It's not quite at the same level as "Where the **** is my flying car?" but I would have hoped to see a few more "megatowers" by this stage in the game, at least under construction, even with wonky economies and assorted wars.

Alex
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

If any city is going to be doing this, it's Dubai. They already have more high-rises than most American cities, and they're not all clumped together like in older cities, but spread fairly uniformly throughout Dubai proper and the surrounding cities.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Dubai is broke. Saudi Arabia is the latest place that claims to be building a"mile high" tower.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Problem is that such buildings cost much money.. tens of millions if not hundreds of millions and some of the designs are also quite experimental.

Now people willing to invest such sums of money tend to be really conservative and don't like experiments that may cost them money. At best they are willing to let some famous architect like Norman Foster do something unusual but really radical designs are very unlikely to get approval.

However some of them are very interesting.. especially those that try to take existing structures and re-purpose them like the oil rig (though i imagine a big part of the construction money would go to cleaning these structures before himans can live there).
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Dubai is broke.

It may not be overflowing with wealth as it once was, but it's still in a far better position to accept new construction than most American cities. It certainly didn't appear "broke" when I was there.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

I always thought it was amazing that the Burj Kalifa is the first building to be taller than the fictional Glass Tower from The Towering Inferno. I thought reality would have surpassed fiction much sooner.
Skyscrapers in the US are pretty much dead for now. Developers simply can't borrow the money. Potential tenants are also hard to come by now. The tragedy is that materials and labor haven't been this low for years. It would be cheap to build a big building right now if you could get one built.
As for my skyscraper, the One Franklin Street tower in downtown Boston, see the beautiful rain-filled hole that has dominated the site since 2008, and probably will for years to come. (sniff)
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Im sad the chicago spire is now defunct. :/
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Frank Lloyd Wright designed a sleek mile-high skyscraper in 1956. He believed it could be built with the technology available at the time. The only practical difficulty was that the necessary elevator shafts would take up so much space, there wouldn’t be enough paying floor space left to make the structure economically feasible.

y3fus9h.jpg
 
Last edited:
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Im sad the chicago spire is now defunct. :/
No kidding. The hole in the ground isn't very attractive.

3353257068_700e937a67.jpg


As others have said, this all ultimately comes down to money. Even with projects that do get built, their initial plans are almost always scaled back due to economics... much like sets on Star Trek.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

rrrrrrrrrrr.jpg


The Hydrothermal Skyscraper in Taipeilook like something that could be built with existing materials and technologies, and a beautiful design too.

It isn't too far out there.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

But I guess the point I'm making is when will these types of builds stop being mental exercises and start becoming real? Maybe not all the ones in this slideshow (that shipping container one looks a bit daft, and the one in Paris looks like a giant Gumby), but with all these high hopes (pun intended) for futuristic construction, is there actually any serious intent to make any of these structures real? Here in Alberta they made a big deal out of Western Canada's tallest building going up in Calgary - but it really looks no different than buildings put up 30 years ago.

It is going to be the world's tallest stalk of celery, that's why it's different!
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

/Users/sjk384/Pictures/One Franklin/Tower site in snow.jpg


One Franklin Street - Boston. An even LESS attractive hole than the one in Chicago
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Damn! How the hell do you put pics on this thing?
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Damn! How the hell do you put pics on this thing?
You need to upload your picture to an image-hosting site like Photobucket or ImageShack, then link to it.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

I'm not a big fan of modern architecture. They can be clever pieces of engineering, but most look ugly or absurd to me. A lot these modernist architects seem to be obsessed with tall spikes, overhangs, warped things, cuboids, and making buildings as unfriendly as possible.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

Most of those buildings looked incredibly impractical, except the one made of freight containers. There are already real-world instances of that, and I think it's a great way to reuse something that would otherwise have been scrapped.
 
Re: Futuristic skyscraper plans - look nice, but when will we see them

I'm not a big fan of modern architecture. They can be clever pieces of engineering, but most look ugly or absurd to me. A lot these modernist architects seem to be obsessed with tall spikes, overhangs, warped things, cuboids, and making buildings as unfriendly as possible.
Overhangs can be beautiful.

fallingwater.jpg
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top