Full Circle

[Finn]

I just finished reading the novel. I did like it more than the first book of the Destiny book (I only read that one). Only one nitpick got to me. They kept referring to Barclay as a Lieutenant. Wasn't he a Lt. Commander toward the end of Voyager?

And I have a nagging feeling Janeway may be alive somewhere, though I can't think of why, after it was shown that B'Elanna talked with her about how a hologram version of Kahless using a replicia of the mobile emitter was exposed. Am I alone on that? But again, I can't think of any reason why she'd fake her death, like B'Elanna did with her own.

 

[Christopher]

The scene with B'Elanna talking to Janeway about the holo-Kahless was a flashback taking place before Janeway's death.

 

[Finn]

Right...and your point being?

 

[Christopher]

The point is that it happened before Janeway's death, therefore there's no reason to assume it suggests she faked her death and met B'Elanna afterward.

Unless you're suggesting that the Janeway who died in Before Dishonor was a hologram? But that's impossible. Before Dishonor has many scenes inside Janeway's head before, during, and after her assimilation by the Borg. Neither the Borg nor the Q show any sign of doubt that she's the real Kathryn Janeway, and there's no way a hologram could fool either of them.

 

[kimc]

Bummer.

 

[captcalhoun]

Janeway's dead, baby. Janeway's dead.

 

[AdmiralSteven]

Janeway's dead, baby. Janeway's dead.

I knew something was going to happen when she went to the ship, didn't know what would happen, but I knew something was going to happen.

 

[JB2005]

I just finished reading the novel. I did like it more than the first book of the Destiny book (I only read that one). Only one nitpick got to me. They kept referring to Barclay as a Lieutenant. Wasn't he a Lt. Commander toward the end of Voyager?

And I have a nagging feeling Janeway may be alive somewhere, though I can't think of why, after it was shown that B'Elanna talked with her about how a hologram version of Kahless using a replicia of the mobile emitter was exposed. Am I alone on that? But again, I can't think of any reason why she'd fake her death, like B'Elanna did with her own.

I like to think of Janeway as a parrot...cue John Cleese.

 

[Finn]

Didn't read the other book. Got it. Thank you.