• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

For the Empire!

Thanks! Well a few things I've learned about "warp" is Trek is that it is damn easy to achieve and It does not dictate the shape of the vessel that is doing it. And it can be achieved in many ways by many different races. It is not like Air, or Water, whereas the form dictates it's function... As any shaped vessel can equally achieve it: Form long necked winged ships, to Cubes, to asymmetrical boomerang ships, to ringed ships. So I would imagine that that ship can do it just fine.
The way I see it, optimized shaping does matter, it's just that the most basic shape, an elongated box, almost works well enough, just like a barge or raft works. If you want a fast or efficient design, then you need exotic geometry like the series of Enterprises or D7. But, if you care only a little then make a USS Raven, which is just a huge Danube class runabout, which is just a fancy Type 6 shuttle. Even the Holoship isn't a shoe box, it has obliquely pointy leading edges.

At the same time you are completely right, too. There is so much room for exotic shaping which must be just as right and effective as the Federation and Klingon designs, otherwise everything would be flying wedges. So, while blunt shapes don't work well, warp physics might like extremely complex shapes of any sort.
 
The way I see it, optimized shaping does matter, it's just that the most basic shape, an elongated box, almost works well enough, just like a barge or raft works. If you want a fast or efficient design, then you need exotic geometry like the series of Enterprises or D7. But, if you care only a little then make a USS Raven, which is just a huge Danube class runabout, which is just a fancy Type 6 shuttle. Even the Holoship isn't a shoe box, it has obliquely pointy leading edges.

At the same time you are completely right, too. There is so much room for exotic shaping which must be just as right and effective as the Federation and Klingon designs, otherwise everything would be flying wedges. So, while blunt shapes don't work well, warp physics might like extremely complex shapes of any sort.
That would be correct, except you have ships like the Borg Cube than can exceed the maximum warp speed factor of the galaxy without the use of a transwarp conduit, with it's blunt side as the leading surface in the chase. Warp fields seem to compensate for any shape that the vessel has. Now that could also be tied to a vessel's power output as well, like a Borg ship can be a cube that warps because it can generate a spherical warp field and force it's way into high warp, or reconfigure that warp field into a huge ellipse, which again we believe requires a much larger power output, although that may not be the actual case. Either way, with all the races that we have seen on Trek, we have only seen a few use anything else as propulsion other than warp. Even the Romulan artificial singularity drive (as one of the most exotic of power systems in the Alpha Q or Beta Q)can and is used to achieve it. Warp is so easy to achieve that practically every race in Trek has done it or uses it for their FTL...And judging from the myriad of shapes (even the smaller vessels, not just the squared off more utilitarian box shaped auxiliary of shuttles and some other vessels [i.e. the Raven, as she is actually a very large vessel] common to starfleet and some other races, but look at the ones found in the Delta Q) that it begs the realization that warp is not governed by structure, but fields and the means to manipulate those fields. Physical shape plays no role in it.
In a nutshell, and should go without saying, warp is just an in universe McGuffin, that every species achieves that is dictated by plot. That said, from what we have seen onscreen, is that warp is not anywhere as stringent to the physicality of a vessel.
The image below shows the basic layout of a Constitution-class starship hull/nacelle configuration from the bow/stern perspective in its classic layout (Configuration A) verses if it were turned 90 degrees (Configuration B). Both would create warp with out any issues as been established in Trek.
Hull-diagram.jpg

There is no difference. According to what we have seen on Trek, it does not matter what shape a ship has, warp can be and usually is achievable. Nacelle count, or shape does not matter. Or even if a ship has nacelles. Warp can be achieved without issue.
That is what I am saying.
 
Thanks! Well a few things I've learned about "warp" is Trek is that it is damn easy to achieve and It does not dictate the shape of the vessel that is doing it. And it can be achieved in many ways by many different races. It is not like Air, or Water, whereas the form dictates it's function... As any shaped vessel can equally achieve it: Form long necked winged ships, to Cubes, to asymmetrical boomerang ships, to ringed ships. So I would imagine that that ship can do it just fine. ;) Just saying.

Hmmmmm

Now here is a quick physical model mock-up of that Klingon Space-Folding ship I did today:
Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-00.jpg

Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-01.jpg

Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-02.jpg

Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-03.jpg

Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-09.jpg

Direct Links:
https://i.postimg.cc/N0g6tsPJ/Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-00.jpg
https://i.postimg.cc/KYZHWy7F/Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-01.jpg
https://i.postimg.cc/DZ4HrPdb/Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-02.jpg
https://i.postimg.cc/CMD9dJx3/Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-03.jpg
https://i.postimg.cc/hvqy9WtH/Klingon-Space-Folding-Prototype-Model-09.jpg

And if you are really curious, there are some more pics of this mockup in my DA gallery if you'd like to see more...
I'd buy it.
 
@Atolm - Curious, is the J'ej'Dhach-Class a spacefighter carrier or a troop landing ship? It looks like the port/starboard sides have some openings on front lower parts.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top