• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

favourite and least favourite doctor?.

pond is pretty cute, but i am looking forward to some new companions...

as for 11... he's grown on me, i'll admit that... i didn't think i'd like him, but he's actually really come into his own as a Doctor and i could stand for him to be around for a while...

also, runner up, if not taking the lead for 'least favorite companion'... River Song...

ugh, can't stand her... kill her off, die, rewrite her time stream, go back in time and steralise Amy... leave some condoms in the tardis for them to find on their honeymoon... anything... god, she's the worst thing to happen to Doctor Who since the costume department decided to borrow props from Joseph and his Technicolor Dreamcoat for the Sixth Doctor's regeneration...

M
 
River needs to just go already as her story has been covered and dealt with as far as I can tell. We know her story how she meets the Doctor and goes backwards to her death in the Series 4 two-parter. Pond is gorgeous but I understand she is definitely calling it quits after the next series which will be her third.

Never did like that colorful coat, either. But more than that the 6th Dr was moody and agressive and just not likeable, at least during his TV run. Either he or the 5th Dr are my least favorite Doctors.
 
can we at least see Pond in her police woman / kissagram outfit one last time before she leaves?

M
 
Last edited:
River's coming BACK?! Wjat on earth for? What can they pissibly hope to accomplish?

Yes I would dearly enjoy seeing a sexy Pond one final time before she goes.
 
^I think it's something we all expected. I've avoided all spoilers (to the degree that I can, yet still play with you guys) and I just naturally assumed that River was going to be back. To find out River will be in Series 7 is only slightly less a surprise than finding out The Doctor will be returning for Series 7.

Oops, did I spoil it?
 
I dont know I mean some on here might see it and frek about the no spoilers rule, but thankfully I am not one of them.
 
^I think it's something we all expected. I've avoided all spoilers (to the degree that I can, yet still play with you guys) and I just naturally assumed that River was going to be back. To find out River will be in Series 7 is only slightly less a surprise than finding out The Doctor will be returning for Series 7.

Oops, did I spoil it?



Well if we are couting spoilers, I did sort of say I heard Series 7 will be the last for both the 11 and Pond. Should I edit that? Or I could just say that is a rumor I heard somewhere...
 
edited just in case...

don't want to get in trouble on my first day here lol

M
 
I once got in serious trouble for editing my own posts at another site some years ago. *shudder* they restricted my access and banned me in the same day. But I deserved it even if the mods had it in for me from the getgo.

So does anyone like Melanie Bush as a companion? Is she better than, the same or worse than Ace also from the same era of Classic Who. What about Peri?
 
melanie was ok... weird dress sense, her polka dot dresses just confused the cameras lol

Ace was funny... a girl who runs around with Nitro 9 in her backpack to destroy daleks and willfully uses a rocket launcher at any given opportunity... whats not to love...

peri.... pink bikinis... enough said lol

M
 
Pretty much what I make of each one as well. Peri was smoking hot, Melanie was sort of cute and Ace was like this total tomboy that blew stuff to kingdom come in her earlier stories. What di you make of Paradise Towers? I have it and enjoyed Melanie to bits. what with her scenes with Pex.
 
Peri was great and so was Ace.

Mel is probably my least favorite Companion, though, I really enjoyed her in the Unbound Audio with the Valleyard He Jests at Scars
 
The popularity of Peri is uncontested, and Ace has her solid fanbase. I just worry that Mel will forever be regarded as less than out of this world. Then of course there is the real question whether-audio or TV-she worked best with either Baker or McCoy?
 
Romana will always be my favourite companion though... want her back in the new series :D

show the new fans what a companion is really supposed to be like

M
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top