• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll Favorite Cover of Vulcan's Glory

Which Cover of "Vulcan's Glory" do you like?


  • Total voters
    21

tomswift2002

Commodore
Commodore
Just pulled the 2006 reprint of Vulcan's Glory off my shelf, and I was thinking which cover art was my favorite of the two? The 2006 cover I notice S&S used a still from The Cage of Spock and Pike on the bridge with the jewel and skeleton hands around them, whereas the original was a painting with Nimoy's likeness as Spock and Jeffrey Hunter's likeness as Pike, around the jewel with possible the lost alien city on display. It's been nearly a decade since I read this book, and some of the details have faded, however I do recall liking the Pike in this story and finding that he still matched up with Burning Dreams, The Cage, Final Frontier, and the Starfleet Academy trilogy. And glancing through the opening pages, I notice that Fontana also briefly recounted the events of Yesteryear (pg. 12, 2006 edition) which is surprising for a Richard Arnold-era novel and how Arnold and Roddenberry had basically outlawed any use of material from TAS. Selek, TAS-Spock's name in Yesteryear even gets mentioned!

But in terms of covers, I remember even back in 2006 (hard to believe that it's been nearly 20 years since this cover was released in August 2006! Seems like yesterday that this reprint appeared on the shelves of my local Coles bookstore---now, nothing for Trek! Not even reprints!) finding that I preferred the 1989 cover. It just seemed more inviting and welcoming, whereas the 2006 cover makes it look like it's suppose to be a prequel to Death's Angel from the Bantam TOS-era with it's 1981 and 1985 covers and the Angel of Death holding the sand timer in it's skeletal hands!

As far as I'm aware, Vulcan's Glory has never been reprinted in a omnibus edition or any other standalone edition with a different cover in Canada and the US. So this poll is only based on the Canadian/American cover artwork from 1989 and 2006. Other countries may have received different covers (has Vulcan's Glory received a German printing by either Heyne or Cross Cult?), but those may have just used the Canadian/American artwork.


 
picard-worthless-without-pics.jpg


1989 Cover
vulcans-glory-1989-small.webp


2006 Cover
vulcans-glory-2006.webp


I prefer the 1989 cover.
 

Thank you!

I think both are good, but I'm always going to prefer an original piece of artwork painted to a photoshopped one.

So I'm going to say I like the original better for its medium, though I do think that the new one is a more intruiging concept, and if it were executed in the same manner, I would most certainly prefer it. Better content, just not better execution.
 
I feel the modern one is "better", but I love the original for the nostalgia seeing that cover brings me.

I originally had the reprint, but I prefer the composition of the original cover. The focus is on Pike and Spock, with the jewel literally coming between them. And Pike's suspicious glance toward the jewel is a good touch.

The later cover shows them trapped inside the jewel, at a seemingly random moment in their lives. (Some dark force observing them?) It's not character-focused, and I don't think I'd have read it but for rave reviews of D.C. Fontana.
 
They couldn’t type in Memory Alpha’s address on their own?

I don't mean to pile on, but typically if you're making a thread about images, it's a good idea to actually include the images in the thread. Not everybody knows about sites like Memory Alpha, and for people who don't know a ton about the books and are new to all of this, it might not necessarily be clear which cover is which. I'm not sure about Vulcan's Glory but there are also a lot of books that have a variety of covers from different countries and then if you don't know what you're looking for there's always a chance there could be some fan covers that floating around out there that people have stumbled across, or some people could have gotten ahold of alternate in progress covers that are different from the ones we got on the final book.
 
Keith Birdsong made a number of Star Trek covers where something was just off and it spoiled the cover.
 
Keith Birdsong made a number of Star Trek covers where something was just off and it spoiled the cover.

Relevancy? The 1989 cover to Vulcan's Glory was by Enric Torres-Prat, the 2006 cover by Cliff Nielsen.

I found Birdsong's work quite impressive, since apparently he worked primarily in colored pencils, yet achieved immeasurably more realism and detail than I could ever manage to achieve in that medium.
 
Keith Birdsong made a number of Star Trek covers where something was just off and it spoiled the cover.
As @Christopher notes, it's not really relevant to Vulcan's Glory. But yes, sometimes I thought Birdsong had trouble capturing Shatner. Also, his Kelsey Grammer likeness on Ship of the Line left much to be desired, and I never understood why the Nexus was on the cover.
 
Hand-painted cover art rarely captures actor likenesses exactly -- and arguably it isn't supposed to, because then it would be photographs rather than an artist's interpretation. I don't think Birdsong was any worse at it than Boris Vallejo, say, and he was better than some.
 
Original, by a light year. It caught my attention and with Fontana's name sold it to me back in the day. That newer version is (metaphorically) drab by comparison, a turn-off really.
 
As @Christopher notes, it's not really relevant to Vulcan's Glory. But yes, sometimes I thought Birdsong had trouble capturing Shatner. Also, his Kelsey Grammer likeness on Ship of the Line left much to be desired, and I never understood why the Nexus was on the cover.
Shatner is a notoriously difficult likeness to capture - he has a lot soft features and his appearance evolves quite a bit over the years. Dru Blair probably captured him the best for Pocket.
 
As @Christopher notes, it's not really relevant to Vulcan's Glory. But yes, sometimes I thought Birdsong had trouble capturing Shatner. Also, his Kelsey Grammer likeness on Ship of the Line left much to be desired, and I never understood why the Nexus was on the cover.

...Huh. I never really thought of it as the Nexus. I think I always took it more like the Badlands, though I don't think that has any more of a connective tissue, either...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top