• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Fav Superhero Comics of Past Decade?

I've always heard good things about comics like The Boys and whatnot, but never bothered reading them. I was reading comics from 2007 to about 2008, but stopped and I haven't read comics in almost a year, but I'm going to start again. I did enjoy Immortal Iron Fist, though.
 
X-Factor - My favorite comic of this decade. It's been a pretty solid run for this series, although a few months back were terrible with Larry Stroman's art and the crossover issues. It's gotten back on track again and has been highly entertaining with some really unexpected twists.
X-Men: First Class - A fun retro type comic that I really enjoyed. I didn't care for the recent mini series, but the series was great.

I used to read so many more titles in the 90s, but I've really cut back this decade.
 
I loved the 90s Peter David Joe Quesada run on X-Factor. Great art, funny as hell, Mister Sinister. I've gotten a smattering of David's new X-Factor run and it isn't quite to my tastes. The art is horrible, there's no action, and it's pretty morose.
 
Ditto on:

Busiek's run on the Avengers
The Planet/WW Hulk story lines

Adding:
JLA/Avengers crossover
House of M
The Hercules 12 Labors Mini-Series
Thor: Blood Oath and the new run by JMS
Annihilation Crossovers
 
Ultimates 1 and 2
Ultimate Extinction trilogy
Ultimate Origins
Ultimate Fantastic 4
Ultimate X-Men
Ultimate Spider-Man
Ultimate Power

you can tell what comics i read...
 
I know it's not superheroes (and on the no-no list), but...

The only comics that I've ever had a desire to read:

Angel: the Series (the last few issues of Angel: After the Fall tugged my heart right out--the only time comics have had that sort of effect on me!)
Buffy, the Vampire Slayer

I generally prefer AtS (show and comic continuations included), though I love early BtVS. Angel is my favorite character. I read it, but I'm not as ecstatic about season 8 (meh) continuing Buffy's downward character regression.

There's also several beautiful gems in the old series runs of both the Dark Horse and IDW comics, too.

I worship Alex Garner, Nick Runge and Jo Chen's gorgeous covers!!! And Stephen Mooney is my favorite inside artist.

I'm a big Whedonite and would never have started reading comics otherwise.

As far as superhero movies go, Burton's two Batman films are probably my favorites (and largely because of the Burton touches).
 
Last edited:
BKV's Runaways is a persistent joy (even though I actually miss the digest trades). Astro City has been great, if persistently late, with the Dark Age storyline. Saying Gotham Central is cheating, because it was about the cops of Gotham City, but the fact they were up against supervillains more often than not qualifies it in a backward sort of way.

Oh, and for an individual storyline? Go read Grant Morrison's New X-Men-Planet X, for his idea of a Shakesperean tragedy starring Magneto.
 
Oh, and for an individual storyline? Go read Grant Morrison's New X-Men-Planet X, for his idea of a Shakesperean tragedy starring Magneto.
One of the worst stories (on a meta-level) in the last 10 years (and I liked most of what Morrison was doing up until that point).
 
I hated "Planet X" fiercely, I'm afraid! I also don't really care for the Ultimate Universe and I've read a LOT of the Spidey and X trades cause they were $3 each or at the library. In those damn Spidey trades there's like a single fight scene in SIX ISSUES. WTF?
 
Oh, and for an individual storyline? Go read Grant Morrison's New X-Men-Planet X, for his idea of a Shakesperean tragedy starring Magneto.
One of the worst stories (on a meta-level) in the last 10 years (and I liked most of what Morrison was doing up until that point).

Lies! What, precisely, do you mean by meta-level? It's impact on the X-Men universe, its characterization of Magneto, its place within the Morrison run?

Because, I gotta say, if it's the first one, the Marvel universe as a whole makes no sense, never mind the X-Men--the story we're discussing gets brownie points for being accessible to non X-fans; there's a case to be made for the second, but not an incredible one; and there were worse and more ridiculous storylines before Planet X. I would remind everyone E is for Extinction and Imperial were about an evil twin. That is inherently worth minus one million points, no matter how great they were otherwise.

And, seriously, am I the only one who's noticed that Planet X is structured like a Shakesperean tragedy?
 
It's impact on the X-Men universe, its characterization of Magneto, its place within the Morrison run?
The first two, mainly. The arc is a deliberate attempt by Morrison to destroy Magneto; he fundamentally misses (or, more properly, dismisses) everything that makes him a compelling character (which others have certainly done as well).
I would remind everyone E is for Extinction and Imperial were about an evil twin. That is inherently worth minus one million points, no matter how great they were otherwise.
I liked Cassandra Nova. That's the sort of bizarre sci-fi concept that Morrison can make work.

Regarding "E is for Extinction", I've also been a bit ambivalent about the Genosha thing. It was an impressive catalyst for the major changes in mutant society Morrison had in mind (which was a great idea), but more and more its absence seems like a bit of a waste the further you get from the moment.
 
I thought Cassandra Nova was a good addition to the mythos. She was certainly something different in a drugged out psychedelic balls crazy kind of way. Meanwhile Magneto has been an anti-hero since what issue #150 of the original series and actually led the X-Men and the New Mutants for what like 50 issues. He's not ****ing Hitler.
 
I dunno how highly I would rank it but I just read the first trade of The Umbrella Academy and it was excellent. Beautiful Mignolia-esque artwork and a crazy story with crazy characters. I love the image of a massive gorilla body with a dude's head on top. And domino masks for everyone! Everyone should wear a domino mask in comic books.
 
Ex Machina - Take one part superhero comic, stir in a little West Wing spiced with a smidge of Spin City and you get one of the coolest comics I've read recently. The combination of Brian Vaughn's writing and Tony Harris' artwork are perfect. If nothing else, the last two pages of the first issue are must-see.
 
Chris Kent was returned to the Phantom Zone as you know Mr. Light at the end of Superman: Last Son and I think he's appeared recently in Action Comics as a teenager but I can't remember. Chris though is the son of General Zod and Ursa and possibly the basis for Davis Bloome (Doomsday) in Smallville. I turned to collecting trades once I was on disability and no longer could afford buying single issue comics anymore and that was about five years ago. Here are my favourite superhero comics though...

Green Lantern/Sinestro Corp War/Blackest Night: Geoff Johns is my favourite writer with Brian Bendis number two and Grant Morrison in third place. His mythological storytelling is great and making me appreiate the past as well by attempting to find older Silver Age Green Lantern stuff. I grew up with Kyle as my GL but am growing fond of Hal Jordan. The Sinestro Corp War was epic stuff and pretty close to my own ideas for a Green Lantern story. This arc along with Justice League Animated is what made me a Green Lantern fan.

Action Comics/Superman: Geoff Johns and Richard Donner's run on Action Comics was awesome, Last Son is easily my favourite Superman story in the last decade. I'd given up on Superman after all the 90's gimmicks and event based stories. Loved Superman: Brainiac, Johns treated Brainiac like the true villian he is. Looking forward to getting Superman: New Krypton but will get both volumes when the second comes out in September.

New X-Men:: Grant Morrison's run on New X-Men has been seen as contraversial and highly critized by many X-fans but at the time he was signed to bring X-Men back to the top of the sales ranking where it had dropped post AOA. My first problem with this entire saga is that Frank Queitly wasn't able to draw every issue, my second problem is that Grant felt the need to kill Jean Grey again. Oh well Marvel does have plans to bring her back and there's been much speculation about Hope Summers (the child that Cable has been protecting since Messiah Complex).

Civil War
House of M
Infinite Crisis
Idenity Crisis
Final Crisis
Batman and Son
Batman R.I.P.
52
OMAC
Ultimates
Ultimates 2
Ultimate Spider-Man
Ultimate X-Men
New Avengers
Dark Avengers
Dark Reign
Annilation Wave
Planet Hulk
World War Hulk
Teen Titans (Geoff Johns run)
Legion of Superheroes (Mark Waid run)
 
Oh yeah that was other terrible thing about Morrison's X-Men, all the HORRIBLE art. It's like one Quietly issue (who I think draws some of the ugliest women in the world) and then three "fill ins" by some absolutely terrible D-lister artist. Ugh.
 
Grant Morrison's X-Men run I thought was brilliant at first. I thought to myself, "This is the most hilarious satire and superhero parody work I've seen since The Tick." Then someone told it me it wasn't a joke. That it was actually serious. Then I went out a bought a gun. Oh, I never use it. But the way I figure if the end of the world occurs in 2012 like The Aztec Calendar predicts, then I can maybe beat God to the punch when it comes to Scotland's Favorite Egomanical Heroin Addict because everyone's going to die anyway. Either that, or I'll just get really fucking drunk. So when God comes knocking I might not be wearing pants. I'll die happy either way.

Anyway the topic at hand:

Garth Ennis's Punisher Run: Ennis is to Castle what Claremont is to The X-Men. It's just full of fire and testosterone filled fury. It pulls no punches while it rips modern comic book pretentiousness apart. It's a gleefully nihilistic joy ride to Hell. It's anti-military, anti-liberal, and anti-American. And I wouldn't have it any other way. It's everything I love about Ennis.

Geoff Johns Flash Run: Often overlooked because of the hype associated with the return of Hal Boredan. Most Flash villains pretty much sucked ass for the past 50 years. Johns was able to make them interesting for the first time since ever. He was also able to resurrect The Reverse Flash, the only good Flash villain, and bring him into the new age. All of which came together nicely in Rogues War. He added to and played around with the mythology while having nothing but respect for it, unlike other writers I've ranted about.

Garth Ennis's The Boys: Ennis going back to his superhero-bashing, dark comedy roots. The guy has such huge balls to mock and ridicule The Big Two, its a wonder anyone will hire him. In an era of Silver Age Nostalgia and Pretentious Intellectual Statements, The Boys cuts through all of that bullshit like Leatherface alone with a young Co-Ed. And it has a character modeled after Simon Pegg too.

Nextwave: This was probably the best superhero comic Marvel has put out in 10 years. Granted, most of their superhero books are awful but still. A lot of it had to do with the fact that it didn't do what Marvel books nowadays usually do. No shock stunts. No mythology or character rape. No big events. Just fun, sharp, hilarious writing and some of the best action around. So of course no one read it and it was canceled after just two arcs and declared non-canon.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top