• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Euthanized Dog Comes Back To Life

I have had to have two of my pets euthanised, a 14-year-old dog with a spinal tumour which was inoperable and causing immense pain, and a 10-year-old cat with complete kidney failure which wasn't responding to veterinary care. Both times the vets checked for a heartbeat before declaring my pets dead, so I was under the impression that all vets did this. Apparently not. Ye gods, the though that, had my vets not been so diligent, I may have buried my pets alive makes me feel sick.
 
OMFG. That would have freaked the shit out of me!!!!! Can you imagine?? And, not for anything, but it would have been really really icky if she was dead..to leave her body in the garage (or whatever that was) overnight while he decided what to do with her body? She would have been a bit ripe at that point.

I hope he doesn't have her put down again. That dog has a serious will to live.

It would have freaked me a bit too, I hope he got his money back.
 
I don't like the idea of mercy killings, whether it is animals or people. It just seems somehow unethical in a sickening kind of way, more so than just shooting the thing and eating it as might be the case with a cow.
They shoot cows?
 
I, for one, welcome our zombie dog overlords.

/end thread

(We really need a zombie smiley. This is the closest I can get: :borg:)
zombie.gif
 
Sometimes dead is better...it's a real life Pet Sematary!!!!!!!!!!!! ARGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHH! Run for your liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiivvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssss!
 
Missed opportunity...

You should have called this topic:

All dogs go to heaven, except this one!
 
OMFG. That would have freaked the shit out of me!!!!! Can you imagine?? And, not for anything, but it would have been really really icky if she was dead..to leave her body in the garage (or whatever that was) overnight while he decided what to do with her body? She would have been a bit ripe at that point.

I hope he doesn't have her put down again. That dog has a serious will to live.

Not overnight. If it was a few days, then yes she would start to stink. But overnight doesn't really matter.
 
^ Not true. When our beloved 16-1/2 yr old Westie had to be put down, we took her body home to be buried in the yard. I held her for an HOUR while my husband dug her grave. By the time we put her in the ground, she already started to ripen. After an hour.
 
It's a good thing they didn't bury the dog yet! Poor thing would have woken up underground, and then died slowly from starvation, suffocation, and terror.

If a sick dog survives euthanasia, could it really have been that sick to begin with?
 
I don't like the idea of mercy killings, whether it is animals or people. It just seems somehow unethical in a sickening kind of way


Why the hell do folks say "I had my dog euthanized"? They say it because it somehow soothes their super-sensitive feelings; as if giving it to someone else to kill in a special way behind closed doors makes the act deserving of a different term. Foolishness! Just tell it like it is. "I killed my dog because its life isn't worth paying for, and I'd rather have Starbucks than pay for dog costs. If it comes to life again, I'll fill it full of bullets or smash its skull." Of course, nobody says that... because we want to believe some hogwash about happy places in which there is a soft, appealing term for everything. The people who "euthanize" dogs are also the people who believe that ham is made by happy smiling animated disney character pigs that never die. You "put your animal to sleep"? Liar! YA KILLED IT!

There is no more twisted perversion that the subtle self-tricking which weak-minded people do to themselves through illusion; and it usually works, except for in cases like this when their fragile, weak sensitivities are forced to become fully aware of reality.

Have you ever had a family pet that you had to make that decision for?

In March, I had to take my 14 year old lab to the vet for the last time. For nearly 2 years he struggled with ever worsening arthritis and hip problems. Medication and diet were helping alleviate the symptoms and he was able to move around. He started getting much worse over a relatively short period of time, to the point where he could hardly stand up on his own. We tried a new, stronger medication that had no great effect.

He was still eating and drinking and up until the end had the brightest eyes. Whenever we came home, we could hear his tail thumping on the hardwood floor, even though it was a struggle to get to his feet. The spirit was willing, but the flesh was weak.

The week we made the decision, I slept on the kitchen floor next to him in a sleeping bag one night because he wouldn't stop whining. He wanted to be with his people and couldn't move to get there.

I knew it was time when he couldn't get up to get to his food and when I went to get him off the deck and he was laying in his own urine. I slept next to him again that night.

The next morning I took him to the vet and stayed with him the whole time. He had been with us through 14 years, it was the least I could do for him.

I knew what I was doing and I knew it was the best thing for him. When you take an animal into your family, you promise to take care of it, up until the end.

It wasn't an easy decision and regardless of what it was called, it was still the same result. When I left the vet's office, all I would have left was his collar and he'd be dead.

I'm guessing you haven't been there before.
 
Of course it is sometimes necessary to put a Pet out of his misery. Our Pets our completely dependent on us for their food, shelter and care. If they are suffering , it's our responsibility to bring them comfort; if there is no hope of them being saved, then the only comfort we can give is to put them peacefully and painlessly to sleep, no matter how hard that is to do. I completely respect people who have the courage to take that step rather than let an animal live out his final days in pain and suffering.
 
^ Not true. When our beloved 16-1/2 yr old Westie had to be put down, we took her body home to be buried in the yard. I held her for an HOUR while my husband dug her grave. By the time we put her in the ground, she already started to ripen. After an hour.


Yep, same here. The difference being that he actually died of natural causes, right in front of us. He had water in his lungs and we didn't know anything wrong was going on with him until it was too late. We took him to the Vet who gave us medicine for him, and we intended to give it to him the next day, but the next day, he was hidden in his favourite spot behind the Lazy-Boy. He wanted to be alone. I was asleep, and my parents woke me up when they knew what was happening. When I got there, he came out of his hiding spot to see us for one last time, trying so hard to wag his tail, and then that was that; he collapsed.
 
Jason's Bro: I think it's a good guess that Joshua Howard has never even had a pet that he's loved, otherwise he would have never written that post. He is obviously clueless as to the love one has for their dog or cat, and the agony one goes through to have to make the decision to have one put down.

Our Westie was 14 when she blew out her back knee, but we didn't think twice about spending $2000 to have her get the surgery she needed. By the time she was 16 she was really slowing down. She was almost blind, arthritic, deaf and had alzheimers (diagnosed by the vet). She was diabetic and needed 2 insulin injections a day. I had to hold her so she could go to the bathroom without falling. But i didn't think twice about it...i did it all for her. I loved her. But then, at 16-1/2 she stopped eating one morning. I cooked everything i could to try to get her to eat, but she wouldn't. She didnt eat at all for two days and i knew everything was finally shutting down. She was giving up. By the third day i knew it was time to let her go with some degree of dignity. It was the most painful decision of our lives, but we went into the room with her and i held her while the vet gave her the injections. We took her home and i held her for an hour and then we buried her. I cried for weeks.

After a certain amount of time i started to feel guilty that i didn't have her put down sooner. Those last six months of hers were not happy ones for her. I don't know if we waited too long or not....i just couldn't let her go sooner. But as i say, those last three days she was telling us she had enough. I couldn't see having her caged for who knows how long, with an IV, stuck at the vet for her last few days. IF i thought she had a chance, i would have paid any amount of money to pull her through it. But it was HER i was thinking of .....not me and my needs when we made the decision.

Clearly only animal lovers know what this pain is like....and i suspect Joshua Howard is NOT one of us.
 
I have had to have two of my pets euthanised, a 14-year-old dog with a spinal tumour which was inoperable and causing immense pain, and a 10-year-old cat with complete kidney failure which wasn't responding to veterinary care. Both times the vets checked for a heartbeat before declaring my pets dead, so I was under the impression that all vets did this. Apparently not. Ye gods, the though that, had my vets not been so diligent, I may have buried my pets alive makes me feel sick.

The way you lost your cat is VERY similar to what happened to my family's prior cat, with the difference that we think she may have been about 20 years old, give or take. That cat lived a LONG time, and had already beat cancer, in her "middle" age--and we did NOT just let that go because of the expense. We had her put down because the vet attempted treatment and then made it very clear that since that last treatment hadn't worked, that she could not be helped.

The other animals my family put down were because of untreatable, painful, and degrading conditions as well--leaving them to suffer without understanding what was happening wouldn't have been an option. One dog was epileptic, not responding to treatment, and went into status epilepticus and could not be saved. The other suffered a massive stroke--thank God, right in a vet clinic, when she was going to be boarded, and the vet techs saw it happen and made a medical judgment that it would be horribly inhumane to let her live after that.

I did feel tremendously guilty about what happened with our cat, though.

But here is the crazy thing. I know many of you won't believe me, but she came to me in a dream a month to the day after it happened, and told me not to worry anymore. It was very clear there was no sense of blame from her whatsoever--in fact, she was looking out for me (she was older than me, after all, and had always known I was the "baby" of the family). Honestly, I don't care what any of you think, but I think she knew that on some level, I was torturing myself about it, and didn't want that.
 
Have you ever had a family pet that you had to make that decision for?

[...]

I'm guessing you haven't been there before.

You are right. I haven't.

First of all, I'm not saying that people shouldn't kill their pets if that is the most cost-effective or merciful option.

If you have to choose between your pet suffering until it dies and killing it immediately, or if you have to choose between repairing your damaged pet and putting food on the table for your family, then I guess the correct solution is pretty obvious.

My only objection is to the psychological soft-footing which gets applied to things like this. Folks try to come up with a way to face the problem without having to address it head on. It's like meat at the supermarket. Everybody eats it, but half of the city folks who buy meat wouldn't have the stomach to kill and dress an animal if it wasn't delivered to them prepared with a bar code on it.

Case in point: The guy whose dog reawakened admitted that he wasn't sure what he would do in the aftermath of the failed killing. This proves his inferior mental condition. If it was logical to snuff the dog out yesterday, what makes it less logical to snuff the dog out a second time today? Obviously, he wanted to get the job done without having to face the reality of what he was doing. There is emotional compromise at play here, and the way I see it, the concept of mixing killing and sympathy together is ridiculous and embarassing.
 
He isn't being illogical. He has been through the grief of putting his dog down and now realises how much it pained him to do so, possibly he didn't realise until after the dog was dead just how much pain it would cause him and his family. Now they have to go through the pain all over again or else let the dog suffer as it was previously suffering.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top