Enterprise Hurt/Heal Game - Season One

[Defcon]

Since any other series has one of those and there is a tentative plan to have an all Trek final Final, I present to you the Enterprise Hurt/Heal Game:

The Rules

• Each episode starts on 10 points.
• 1 Vote every calender day per member.
• On each vote you must both:
• Heal your favorite episode + 1
• Hurt your least favorite episode -2
• You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa
• Once an episode reaches zero it's out
• Episodes are ranked in order of elimination
• Please indicate which episodes you have hurt and healed
• The Top 8 episodes of each season will move on to the final

Season One

Broken Bow 10
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 10
Terra Nova 10
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 10
Dear Doctor 10
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 10
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 10
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Defcon]

Season One

Broken Bow 10
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8 -
Terra Nova 10
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 10
Dear Doctor 10
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11 +
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 10
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Michael]

Spamtastic!

Broken Bow 11 +
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8
Terra Nova 8 -
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 10
Dear Doctor 10
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 10
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[suebsg9]

Broken Bow 11 +
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8
Terra Nova 7 -
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 10
Dear Doctor 10
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 10
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Michael]

^
+ 1
- 2

 

[Orac]

Broken Bow 11
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8
Terra Nova 6
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11 +
Dear Doctor 10
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 8 -
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Hoshi's sis]

Broken Bow 11
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9 (+1)
Terra Nova 4 (-2)
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11 +
Dear Doctor 10
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 8 -
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

Heal Unexpected (I think its an underated gem)
Hurt Terra Nova (complete yawn)

 

[Bosch571]

Broken Bow 11
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8
Terra Nova 4 -
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11 +
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 8
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Michael]

Some of you have screwed up the ranking. Here's the correct list:

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
Terra Nova 2
The Andorian Incident 10
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 8
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[SFRabid]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
Terra Nova 2
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 8
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 9
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Bosch571]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
Terra Nova 2
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 12 +
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 6 -
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 9
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[suebsg9]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
Terra Nova 2
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11 +
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 6 -
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[Trippy]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
Terra Nova -2=0
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 11+1=12 (best ep of season one!)
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 6
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 10
Shuttlepod One 12 +
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 10
Acquisition 10
Oasis 4 -
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

Eliminated:
25th: Terra Nova

 

[Mallory]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 10
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 11 +
Shuttlepod One 12
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 8 -
Acquisition 10
Oasis 4
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 10

Eliminated:
25th: Terra Nova

 

[miriel68]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 9
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 8 -
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 11 +
Shuttlepod One 12
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 8 -
Acquisition 10
Oasis 4
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 11 +

 

[Orac]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 10 +
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 8
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 11
Shuttlepod One 12
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 8
Acquisition 10
Oasis 2 -
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 11

Eliminated:
25th: Terra Nova

 

[cultcross]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8 -
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 8
Fortunate Son 10
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 11
Shuttlepod One 12
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 8
Acquisition 10
Oasis 2
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 10
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 12 +

Eliminated:
25th: Terra Nova

 

[Flibble]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 8 -
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 8
Fortunate Son 8
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 11
Shuttlepod One 12
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 8
Acquisition 10
Oasis 2
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 12 +

Eliminated:
25th: Terra Nova
__________________

 

[Defcon]

Broken Bow 12
Fight or Flight 10
Strange New World 10
Unexpected 6 -
The Andorian Incident 11
Breaking the Ice 10
Civilization 8
Fortunate Son 8
Cold Front 10
Silent Enemy 11
Dear Doctor 11
Sleeping Dogs 10
Shadows of P'Jem 11
Shuttlepod One 13 +
Fusion 10
Rogue Planet 8
Acquisition 10
Oasis 2
Detained 10
Vox Sola 10
Fallen Hero 10
Desert Crossing 11
Two Days and Two Nights 10
Shockwave, Part I 12

Eliminated:
25th: Terra Nova