• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers DS9: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko by Derek Tyler Attico Review Thread

Rate the Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko

  • Outstanding

    Votes: 5 41.7%
  • Above Average

    Votes: 5 41.7%
  • Average

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Below Average

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Poor

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    12
I picked this book up yesterday at NYC Wintercon and met the author. He's a very dedicated fan and really knows his stuff - he's written a couple of short stories for SNW. This was the bio that I wanted to read the most. I really like the Picard and Kirk bios, but not so much Janeway's or Spock's. I started last night. I like what I'm reading so far. I'll have to stay away from this thread for spoilers for now. I'm interested in what everyone thinks about it. May the prophets guide you.
 
Just finished the book, and I wanted to call out one decision that struck me as peculiar. In "Emissary," the scene of Ben meeting Jennifer is present-day Ben finding himself shocked at being back in time (apparently), and then just going with the flow and bluffing his way past his initial confusion so he could enjoy reliving the experience. The autobiography shows that as being what actually happened, except for one line where Sisko explicitly says "I have returned to an earlier moment in my life, every detail is exactly as it was, and I am overcome by this." It's a very strange read on the scene, and I'd almost wonder if it was some kind of late-stage note from Paramount that the scene had to match the one we saw in the show, if it weren't for the amount of set-up that went into creating a character called George, who threw a party, and setting up a near-miss so Ben could know Jennifer's name without actually meeting her. Plus, I feel like this concept robs the episode of some of its pathos, with Ben's lines about being sure Jen's mother will love him, and that he'd never before and would never again say a woman he just met was the person he was going to marry being recontextualized into smitten, cocksure flirting and not future-Ben already knowing that they're going to hit it off and being so happy at seeing his wife again he's not able to contain himself.

Another thing that stuck in my head was when Joseph took Ben to the Ruby Bridges museum, and the recorded message after the reenactment mentioned that it was one of 50,000 Remembrance Centers all around Earth, which just set my head a-spinning. The concept of a worldwide franchise (for want of a better word) of museum/memorials to racial injustices, and the staggering figure of 50,000 locations. I don't doubt you could find 50,000 notable acts of bigoted cruelty around the world but, wow, that's almost half the number of museums of any kind estimated to exist in the world today. That one sentence just raised a ton of questions for me about an aspect of life on Earth in Star Trek that I hadn't really thought about before.
 
So far, it seems to capture Sisko's voice quite well.

Loved the Preservation Hall scene. Although at least pre-Katrina, the standard PHJB lineup was a septet: clarinet, trumpet, trombone, banjo, piano, tuba (or string bass), and drums. A Vulcan captain who plays jazz trumpet couldn't find a banjo, tuba, or bass?

And I see Attico managed to work in a sentient species he'd created for a video game. I can't help but wonder if he named them after friends: in my own "First Contact Corps" short stories, I named the Lozadians (think of a cross between Kelvans in their natural form, and Sulamids) after a short story workshop classmate at the time I wrote them.
 
Last edited:
I think this may be my favourite of the Titan Trek autobiographies. Derek Tyler Attico was for sure the right person for the job.

We recently had him as a guest on the Positively Trek Book Club podcast, and it is now my favourite interview I've ever done. Check it out.
 
Got through Wolf 359, the aftermath, and the arrival at DS9.

Found a number of typos, including an entire paragraph that is effectively impossible to parse.
 
Is there an audiobook planned at all? I'm sure you can't get Avery Brooks, but it would be cool to be able to listen on my daily commute even with a different reader.
 
Is there an audiobook planned at all? I'm sure you can't get Avery Brooks, but it would be cool to be able to listen on my daily commute even with a different reader.

Don't be so sure. His last IMDB credit was from 2006.
 
I really liked this book it was really good how the author filled in Ben Sisko's background I liked the backstory of Ben and Jennifer's relationship that was one of my favorite parts of the book and his time on the Saratoga.
 
Just finished the book, and I wanted to call out one decision that struck me as peculiar. In "Emissary," the scene of Ben meeting Jennifer is present-day Ben finding himself shocked at being back in time (apparently), and then just going with the flow and bluffing his way past his initial confusion so he could enjoy reliving the experience. The autobiography shows that as being what actually happened, except for one line where Sisko explicitly says "I have returned to an earlier moment in my life, every detail is exactly as it was, and I am overcome by this." It's a very strange read on the scene, and I'd almost wonder if it was some kind of late-stage note from Paramount that the scene had to match the one we saw in the show, if it weren't for the amount of set-up that went into creating a character called George, who threw a party, and setting up a near-miss so Ben could know Jennifer's name without actually meeting her. Plus, I feel like this concept robs the episode of some of its pathos, with Ben's lines about being sure Jen's mother will love him, and that he'd never before and would never again say a woman he just met was the person he was going to marry being recontextualized into smitten, cocksure flirting and not future-Ben already knowing that they're going to hit it off and being so happy at seeing his wife again he's not able to contain himself.

Yes, I thought exactly the same. I've never got the impression that Ben was necessarily even at George's party the night before. Not only that, but the book misses the part about the sand burning his feet and him making a beeline for Jennifer's towel, with Sisko instead just accidentally kicking sand over her as he runs by. It may seem like a small thing but it's such a memorable bit of "Emissary", with his little burning-feet dance and, "I was carrying three lemonades... the sand was burning my feet, and I stopped here..."

I enjoyed the book overall but that really stood out.
 
I loved DEEP SPACE NINE more than any of the other Treks and was anxious for this one but it doesn't actually provide that much insight into his actions during the series. Instead, it more or less focuses entirely on his history in New Orleans for the first half of the book and then sort of skips past everything from the Dominion War. It's got a lot of really good stuff in there but a lot of it feels contradictory to the character we see on the screen.

For example, Ben Sisko finds out his mother was possessed by a Prophet for most of her marriage with his father and yet he acts like he remotely knew the "real" woman (indeed, had a deep as well as meaningful relationship with her--which is flat out not true since she runs away the moment she's no longer possessed). Ben Sisko is someone that also has a meaningful spiritual background when it's fairly clear he did not before encountering the Prophets. There's also a flat out INSANE line about Kai Winn being the kind of leader that Bajor needed at the end.

"However, in the end when Bajor needed her, when I needed her, Kai Winn became the true spiritual leader of Bajor it always deserved, and for that I am grateful."

Man, what? I believe the author must have misremembered the series because that doesn't describe Kai Winn's fate at all. She died heroically but never was any kind of leader. I also feel like we don't see nearly enough of Curzon Dax in the story for a figure that was supposed to be so incredibly meaningful in his life. Still, there's some good stuff here like the fact that Ben was originally an engineer and only moved into the command track reluctantly.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top