The Day of the Doctor itself was great, same with An Adventure in Time and Space, but other than those episodes, as a year I did feel short-changed. For a start the main series was basically just half a full series because Moffat has a delusion that "Doctor Who should be event television!" and most of the episodes weren't even that good because they were too short and the stories often sucked. I can't comment on the merchandise because I've not brought any since when I was younger, at the beginning of the Smith era (plus the whole era dampened the show for me) but the amount of merchandise seemed sensible. I just wish there was more. Personally I would have probably gone for a full feature film for the main special with a budget to match, as well as An Adventure in Time and Space I'd probably do another pre 2005 special, probably a full hour special with McGann and maybe something to do with Hartnel and the Daleks (prequel to An Unearthly Child perhaps but obviously the daleks couldn't be involved, at least not directly. For the record, I originally thought An Adventure in Time and Space was actually a prequel and was about the Doctor and Susan escaping Galifrey). Oh an a full series to top things off, one with decent episodes well thought out and to avoid large numbers of fans not liking it (say some RTD fans not liking it because it's typically Moffat), I would have a couple of episodes in different styles (some episodes resembling Moffat Who, some resembling RTD Who, some resembling classic who, an episode or two for each decade and writer). I'd probably use different writers, producers and directors for each of these episode/s too, that way it would be harder to run out of ideas, and it would give a variety of different styles which in turn would mean at least one episode strongly appealing to most viewers, instead of people like me only liking a handful of episodes, but other than Day of the Doctor none of them were amazing and worthy of celebrating the 50th anniversary of Doctor Who (although I did really enjoy Cold War, had some slight vibes similar to "Dalek", but yet again it needed to be longer).