• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Dalek vs Borg

1.>The Dalek's have been able to get past stairs since the 1980's.
2.>One Guy from just about the only race that is more advanced them.

The Borg will just go back in time to when the Daleks couldn't ascend stairs back in the days of flared trousers, then they will defeat/assimilate them. Imagine Borg with flares? The horror! :eek:
 
1.>The Dalek's have been able to get past stairs since the 1980's.

Although only shown in the 80's, Daleks have ascended stairs before then. Way back in their third appearance, 'The Chase', Daleks were shown in locations they could only reach by ascending stairs.

1. they hover, they still don't climb them.

2. he's still one guy, with no superpowers, superstrength, etc.

1) Your point being? What tactical advantage does physically climbing stairs offer that hovering does not? Daleks are capable of high speed flight. How will a Borg assimilate them when they stay out of reach?

2) The only times the Borg have been stopped, it's by people without superpowers, superstrength, etc.
 
1.>The Dalek's have been able to get past stairs since the 1980's.

Although only shown in the 80's, Daleks have ascended stairs before then. Way back in their third appearance, 'The Chase', Daleks were shown in locations they could only reach by ascending stairs.

1. they hover, they still don't climb them.

2. he's still one guy, with no superpowers, superstrength, etc.

1) Your point being? What tactical advantage does physically climbing stairs offer that hovering does not? Daleks are capable of high speed flight. How will a Borg assimilate them when they stay out of reach?

2) The only times the Borg have been stopped, it's by people without superpowers, superstrength, etc.


1) The Borg have typical biped mobility. The Daleks do not.

2) my point wasn't that the Borg were stopped by opponents with superpowers, my point was that the Daleks are repeatedly defeated by one really smart guy with a sonic screwdriver.
 
Daleks are the superior life form in the universe. The primitive Borg would be swiftly exterminated.
 
The Daleks posed a credible threat to the Time Lords, and have at one point attained the ability to unmake all creation. No contest, the Borg are fighting jet aircraft with bear skins and knives.
 
Yes, but the Dalek's do win battles, such as the Battle of Canary Wharf. WIth the Dalek's vs Cybermen, the Dalek's where winning that battle even though they were heavily outnumbered initally.

But the same could be said about the Borg who are repeatedly defeted by Starfleet ships.
 
Compared to us humans the Doctor does have various superpowers. Starting with his ability to regenerate.
 
(2) they repeatedly lose to ONE GUY who's usually unarmed except for a sonic screwdriver. Verrry intimidating.

The Borg were defeated by one guy telling them to go to sleep.

I believe the appropriate phrase is 'Boom, headshot'. That's pretty much it right there.

We know that, on multiple occasions, the Borg have been defeated by humans. It takes a Time Lord to defeat the Daleks. Therefore humans are superior to Borg, Daleks superior to humans.
 
Perhaps, but the Borg are supposed to be more advanced than the Federation, whilst the Time Lords are supposed to be more advanced than the Dalek's.

So in once case we have an alleged superior race (the Borg) being defetaed by a supposed inferor race (The Federation).

And in the other we have a supposed more advanced race (The Time Lords) defeating an supposed inferior race (the Daleks)

One would expect the more advanced race to come out on top.
 
whether or not dalekantium (the material their shells are made of) is dense enough to block a Borg nanoprobe injection tubule.

Actually seeing as the Daleks have something similar to nanoprobes and they also have a device that can block them I don't see why it couldn't be adapted to block Borg nanoprobes, so they wouldn't be reliant on just their casings.
 
whether or not dalekantium (the material their shells are made of) is dense enough to block a Borg nanoprobe injection tubule.

Actually seeing as the Daleks have something similar to nanoprobes and they also have a device that can block them I don't see why it couldn't be adapted to block Borg nanoprobes, so they wouldn't be reliant on just their casings.

I don't think we know enough about how Dalek nanogenes work in comparison to how Borg nanoprobes work to presume that the same technology that neutralizes the former could neutralize the latter. But you're correct in noting that this would be another relevant factor in determining Dalek susceptibility to assimilation.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top