• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Curiosity finds "organic matter" and methane on Mars!

One might also argue that the evolution of complex life may require a series of near-extinction events that aren't quite extinction events. Things that make exceptional intelligence crucial enough to survival to create genetic bottlenecks.

Which, if true, would significantly lower the odds of getting to abstract intelligence.
 
One might also argue that the evolution of complex life may require a series of near-extinction events that aren't quite extinction events. Things that make exceptional intelligence crucial enough to survival to create genetic bottlenecks.

Which, if true, would significantly lower the odds of getting to abstract intelligence.
Hom Sap has been around for 200,000 years or so but seems to have taken his/her time foregoing hunter-gathering for farming - probably only since the last ice age finished 12,000 years ago. In that respect, any human "progress" appears inherently random and fortuitous like an infinite number of monkeys typing Shakespeare. Keep banging the rocks together, guys...
 
Appears random, but isn't. Forgoing hunter-gathering and taking on farming, and other such pivotal events, may indeed be random in their exact happening, but they were forced by there being species of humans for millions of years (yes, I am counting homo erectus, etc.) having billions of chances to do that, and by the inevitable evolution pressure put on all our closest hominids by the changing world, and the different conditions they faced as they spread out throughout the world.

And farming isn't the best example of a singular pivotal event, as we independently invented farming at least a dozen times. I was actually surprised that it happened this many times, as I searched for this only aware of the independent discovery of farming of the Amazon region, and in America in general.

I don't know for sure that it only first happened tens of millions of years ago like you say, but even if it did, it was precipitated by humans spreading around the world and increasing in numbers, thereby eventually making it happen again and again and again.

However, a lot of the required factors in the long haul may be randomly present so as to make us pretty unlikely. JirinPanthosa pointed to one – extinction events. We've all heard how Jupiter's position in the solar system may be critical, according to the vacuum cleaner speculation, too. Then there's the coincidence of hands and brains – I wouldn't be surprised if dolphins are almost as smart as us, or even smarter, but a dolphin civilisation would be impossible; probably a bad example, because those aren't independent evolutionary, so it is explained by evolution. But barely not going extinct back when we were endangered species isn't. Nor is running out of time before the planet is cooked by the sun.

If we had been killed off, leaving the dolphins as the smartest things on the planet, they are unlikely to have built ever cities, and even if they evolved into something better adapted to building things, it wouldn't have happened before plant and animal life is killed off by the heating sun in a few hundred million years.
 
Last edited:
Pessimistic hat on: Organic just means carbon chemistry, which is not necessarily associated with biological processes. Geologically, methane can be produced by heating olivine in the presence of water and carbon dioxide.

https://www.nature.com/news/2005/050531/full/news050531-10.html

Optimistic hat on: One of the Viking lander probes' experiments (labelled release) detected signs of possible life but this evidence was rejected because of negative readings from other experiments (gas chromatograph and gas exchange) and inorganic mechanisms were proposed for the "false positives". However, the subsequent discovery of perchlorate in Martian soil could explain the negative results.

Perhaps not so false after all, it seems. We need to dispatch modern experiments for testing for life on Mars. Unlikely to be anything more advanced than archaea or bacteria, of course. Eukaryotic life forms are way too complex to have developed as they seem to have evolved with very low probability on Earth.


But even if it was archaea or bacteria isn't that still life?
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top