Creating a best DS9 episodes list... (opinions needed)

[DevilEyes]

And finally, here's the ranking:

http://www.rankopedia.com/ZID=3/251/Best-episode-of-Star-Trek:-Deep-Space-Nine/Step1/19588.htm

 

[Geck]

Rapture definitely needs to stay, I agree. It's one of my favourites, and a critical episode, in my opinion. Destiny is also easily in my Top 10, though I haven't seen it mentioned anywhere else in this thread, so that might be just me. I thought it was quite highly regarded though...

From your list, I'd probably cut the following (strongest cuts in bold):

Vortex
Facets
Starship Down
Crossfire
Looking for Par'mach in All the Wrong Places
The Ascent
Ties of Blood and Water
Sons and Daughters
Change of Heart
Wrongs Darker than Death or Night
His Way
Valiant
The Sound of Her Voice
Afterimage
Extreme Measures

Episodes I would definitely add:
Progress
Cardassians
The Collaborator
Soldiers of the Empire
Take Me Out to the Holosuite

 

[DevilEyes]

Well the ranking has already been made, but you can add those episodes or ask me to add them, and vote - if you register on Rankopedia.

 

[Geck]

^ Whoops, totally didn't see Page 2 of this thread when I made my first post

Can't quite figure out how to use Rankopedia yet but I'll poke around a bit! Interested to see the results, at any rate.

 

[jamestyler]

Just saw this thread...
...I tried to do a top five moments (here) and had a hell of a lot of trouble getting it down to five!

On the Ascent cut - I'd leave that in there. It's possibly one of the best episodes with Quark and Odo - though it would have been a hell of a lot better if they'd stuck to the original plan.

 

[DevilEyes]

Just saw this thread...
...I tried to do a top five moments (here) and had a hell of a lot of trouble getting it down to five!

On the Ascent cut - I'd leave that in there. It's possibly one of the best episodes with Quark and Odo - though it would have been a hell of a lot better if they'd stuck to the original plan.

The Ascent will definitely stay there, because Urluburlu has voted for it.

^ Whoops, totally didn't see Page 2 of this thread when I made my first post

Can't quite figure out how to use Rankopedia yet but I'll poke around a bit! Interested to see the results, at any rate.

Well as I said - you need to register (which is pretty easy) in order to vote.

It would be nice to have more than 8 voters... well, I can hope to get about 20+-30, eventually - at least judging from my earlier Best character from Deep Space Nine and Best Character in Star Trek franchise rankings.