• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Crazy Smallville theory/series finale idea

Sketcher

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
For those of us that follow or at the least know about the show, we all understand that Smallville has taken many liberties and turns that prevent it from easily translating to the Superman mythos we know from the comics. Clark is still not wearing glasses as a disguise, which at this point in time will make it easy for those who shouldn't but do know about Clark (such as Lois Lane, Lex Luthor, and about all of the Daily Planet staff) to see that Clark Kent is clearly Superman. Clark is also developing a romantic relationship with Lois far earlier than has ever been represented, especially considering he hasn't even taken on the mantle of Superman. But speaking of mantles, Clark has taken on the alter ego of the Blur, who uses the Superman symbol as his calling card. You would think someone like Lois would already be linking the S symbol with an S-sounding name considering this alien symbol is supposed to represent hope for humanity. There is also the issue of Lana being a complete departure of the woman she is in the comics. The show left her to become a Kryptonite-infused superhero who can never even as much as talk to Clark face-to-face.

Anyway, onto my theory of how the show is or could solve all these issues and still align with the Superman mythos. Way back in season 5 Clark first entered the fortress and began his training. Then Chloe came in and for a lack of a better term, interrupted the process. What if what really happened was that everything past the point of Clark being bathed in Kryptonian knowledge was all an elaborate simulation created by Jor-El as part of Clark's training? This means that Chloe was never transported to the Arctic and the black ship that crashed to Earth was never opened.

Think about it. This way Clark goes through all the trials and tribulations of becoming Superman as we have seen (and gaining knowledge of future adversaries such as Doomsday and Brainiac), but without anyone actually around to see it.
This way, when his training is finally complete and Clark emerges as Superman and returns to the real world, he can don the glasses with enough time having passed where certain people's memory may be hazy enough that they can't quite remember what Clark looked like without them. Certain characters and events like Green Arrow and Lois at the Planet can be explained off as Jor-El scanning the outside world to fuel the simulation for his son and make it as realistic as possible.

I know that this theory would seem like a cheat on the level of Dallas. I also understand that there would be many unexplainable continuity gaffes. But at the same time, I think it would be a better way to go than Clark simply putting the glasses on Lois suddenly unable to remember what Clark looks like without them. Thoughts/comments?
 
Why not? It sounds better than the inevitable mass memory wipe that is no doubt coming. That being said, I'm also fine with them also going the way of no wipe at all.
Let's face it, the only person that knows Clark's secret aside from people that should know (the JLA) are Chloe, Zod, Tess, and Lex Luthor.

Zod is no doubt going to be swimming with the fishies at the end of the Season; and the rest of the Kandorians will no doubt be gone as well.

I don't think Tess will be back after this year's finale as well.

Chloe has been on the hit list of the show since day one, and unless they find a way of introducing her into the DC mythos before the shows run is up, or taking the identity of an established DC character and merging the two (Chloe "The Oracle" Sullivan, anybody?) then she's as dead as my avatar by the end of the series.

That leaves only Lex, and we all know that he (along with Lois and Perry White) can't be killed off. And while it's easy for them to erase his knowledge of SuperClark, they can just as easily leave him with that knowledge. Hell it might even make him a more sinister villian, implied or otherwise.

Lois having first hand knowlegde of SuperClark mightn't be such a bad thing. Say what you will about "Lois & Clark", but Teri Hatcher's Lois knowing that Clark and Superman were one in the same didn't say (just everything else about the show did :-).

My biggest problem with the show is that Clark still isn't flying.

Let's face it, everybody on that show has taken to the sky by now, except for the one person who should. The whole "No Flights No Tights!" thing has become such a joke, and after NINE FLUCKING YEARS its damn insulting too.

You know what, Sketcher, the more I think about it, the last five season's being a dream mightn't be such a bad idea. It'll sure beat out whatever nonsence they have planned for us.

Urgh, why am I still watching this show?
 
they might as well show a giant shiny red RESET BUTTON, alongside a giant shiny red EASY button sponsored by Staples.

the way i see it. its already gotten past the point of no return where all these characters know his identity and such. They've established their own mythos and like you said took their own liberties to establish this universe. So there's really no need to go beyond the story of him actually being Superman (although it would be nice if they went in that direction) and whether or not these people know his identity would even be relevant.

Once the show ends after 10 seasons (lets hope). if they continue on with the mythos of Superman and make all of what they've established canon, then i see a huge issue, but since this is their journey of clark fullfilling his destiny and becoming superman, i dunno it basically is what it is.
 
That worked so well for Dallas and St. Elsewhere. Why not Smallville!


dont forget Roseanne

and Deadmeatdiggory, we still watch this show because we put in all this damn time, should see it through until the end.

or at least thats my reasoning, all in all im less frustrated with this show than heroes and im still seeing that until the end.
 
It wouldn't fix anything anyway. The problems arose as early as the first episode when we see Clark running around without glasses, saving Lex, and having him obsess over the guy who banged up his car while rescuing him.
 
No offense, but I can't see it. Better to let SMALLVILLE end on its own terms, in accordance with its own continuity, than to go nuts trying to reconcile it with other versions of SUPERMAN.
 
It all raised to and past the point of the point of Clusterfuck a Loooooong time ago.

I'm going with that mirror universe "Superboy" in full regalia turns up and again asks the same question which the legion did "Who the hell is Chloe Sullivan?"
 
It's just like in the Superman movie from '78, you know? In it, young Clark goes to the Fortress and begins his training with Jor-El. This training lasts years, in real time. When it's done, Clark emerges in his full Superman outfit.

Maybe the same thing will happen in the series. Hell, they could even use Brando's original dialogue. :lol:
 
No offense, but I can't see it. Better to let SMALLVILLE end on its own terms, in accordance with its own continuity, than to go nuts trying to reconcile it with other versions of SUPERMAN.

I agree with Greg. We know that there are multiple continuities in DC comics and related properties. Let them do their own thing.
 
I would feel cheated if it was this way...creative a solution as it is...I've been pretty emotionally invested in this series since the second season and I do want to see a proper resolution to the show no matter how they get there. While an interesting idea...kind of like Stewie killing Lois in the simulation gag in Family Guy. As much as I've been disgruntled about HOW they are moving Clark towards becoming Superman I do want a proper resolution.
 
Much better idea.

In the final moments, Dean Cain wakes up in bed next to Teri Hatcher.

She asks "What is it?"

He says "TERRIBLE nightmare. You don't want to know....PLEASE tell me you don't have a cousin anywhere named Chloe."
 
Enterprise ended on a similar note, didn't it? I don't remember. But yeah again i say as other people have that Smallville made their own story with a seemingly self contained universe, so they should end it however they see fit. Saying that everything we've seen never happened, and god i hope Lost doesn't end like this, would be a cop out and a huge slap in the face.

speaking of Dean Cain, I wonder if his character will ever come back.
 
I am really liking SMALLVILLE. I think the writing on this show is write up there with some of my other favorite shows...I havent watched Smallville, after giving up after season 4, but came back in time to watch ZOD story, and the perfect JSA story...

Smallville is definately on a roll!!!

Rob
 
and Deadmeatdiggory, we still watch this show because we put in all this damn time, should see it through until the end

That is true. And lets face it, I (along with the rest of us) give this show a whole bunch of shit, but I wouldn't watch it if I didn't enjoy it on some level (I stopped watching Heroes eariler this year for the same reason). Every now and then they get everything right (usually when they go back to the mythos), but sadly thats few and far between. But when they get it right, it's damn good telly.
 
and Deadmeatdiggory, we still watch this show because we put in all this damn time, should see it through until the end

That is true. And lets face it, I (along with the rest of us) give this show a whole bunch of shit, but I wouldn't watch it if I didn't enjoy it on some level (I stopped watching Heroes eariler this year for the same reason). Every now and then they get everything right (usually when they go back to the mythos), but sadly thats few and far between. But when they get it right, it's damn good telly.

too bad it couldnt be all mythos, i dunno if its because i enjoy serialized shows so much but i wish all shows just stuck to main plot and make it as tight and cohesive as possible.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top