• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Chronological rewatch from a historical perspective

Another point. The Starship repair yards that Picard was drawing his Fleet from was undoubtedly from the task force set up by Commander Shelby a year earlier, despite it not being overtly stated in the dialogue. She said she'd have the fleet up in less than a year, and Picard actually was able to muster 20 ships at short notice. Good job Shelby.

Speaking of Shelby, her future novelverse posting, the Excalibur, was seen in this episode under temporary command of Riker.
 
Ensign Ro is such an important episode. Besides introducing one of the best supporting characters in the show, it lays the groundwork of so much of what is to come. We meet so many aliens of the week on Star Trek but the Bajorans were destined to become one of the most well developed species in the entire franchise. Indeed, central to an entire branch of the franchise. And they will largely hold to what is established here moving forward in Deep Space Nine unlike, say the Trill, who will move into Deep Space Nine as essentially an entirely different species than what was introduced in The Host.

I know that Deep Space Nine was originally developed with the idea of Michelle Forbes character of Ensign Ro transfering into the station with Obrien, and while I wouldn't trade Kira Nerys for anything, the dynamic between Ro and O'Brien in Disaster makes me wonder what Deep Space Nine would have been like with Ro.

Speaking of Deep Space Nine, the first appearance of Molly! Yay! The next time we'll see her in a couple months she'll be 3 years old! :lol:

Disaster is also one of the most egregious examples of one of my least favorite Star Trek tropes. The log entry at the end of the episode that ends with, "and life is slowly returning to normal", or words to the effect. That's a cheap cop out way to end a story. It was a ship wide disaster. It's right there in the episode's title. Lives were lost all over the ship, but we only see one of the casualties on the bridge. Riker and Data reach engineering and there was no one on duty. The cosmic string must have wiped out the entire on duty engineering staff, but we see no sign of any casualties and no word about the loss of life is ever mentioned. God, I hate that. They really needed to own the type of story they were trying to tell. "And life is slowly returning to normal...":scream:
 
Strange New Worlds spoilers..

Well, this project fell to the wayside for various reasons, but the premiere of Strange New Worlds reminded me what I loved about watching the various prequel series with an eye towards adding context to previously established events and relationships.

I've stated in this thread and elsewhere that I think that Michael Burnham is the best thing to happen to the Spock character since the Genesis wave. The added texture given to the Sarek/Amanda family dynamic in episodes such as Lethe and Light and Shadows shed new light on events we thought we understood completely.

This continues in strange new worlds with the reintroduction of T'Pring. We see them at a point in their relationship where they were at a crossroads. Spock clearly was interested in T'Pring, or at least in scratching an itch, and the interest seems mutual, unlike during the events of Amok Time. If Spock had chosen to stay behind on Vulcan as T'Pring clearly wished, no doubt they would have had a long and happy marriage. Instead, Spock himself sowed the seeds of their eventual breakup by choosing his duty to Starfleet over his oath to T'pring. How different might the Galaxy have turned out if Pike had called only an hour later? And Spock presuming to speak for T'Pring? You can immediately see that she didn't care for that.

Of course, by the time Amok Time rolls around, he no longer seems to be too into T'Pring anymore given his response to being dumped, possibly due to his interactions with Leila Kolami, which should also fall into the time frame of the series. And, T'Pring tired of waiting for Spock, has moved on. Of course, none of this makes T'Pring any less of a cold calculating bitch in Amok Time.

And then there's the look that Chapel gave Spock when they first met in sickbay. Previews for upcoming episodes give us a sense that Spock and Chapel will be developing a friendship, which would of course lead Chapel's feelings for Spock. Suppose that Spock and Chapel actually were gravitating towards a relationship of some sort, but Spock's commitment to T'Pring and his meeting and developing feelings for Kolami is what drives her into the arms of Roger Korby in the first place? It would make their scenes together in TOS feel all the more emotional and even tragic.

And Sam Kirk? So suppose our theoretical first time viewer gets to know Sam here before they even got to know James. That makes Sam's death an Operation Annihilate! to be a shocking, sad and tragic moment to that viewer, rather than a largely inconsequential moment that's never referred to again.

I love that the narrative feels as if it picked up directly from Discovery season 2. I honestly hope that Strange New Worlds ends with some kind of a direct segue into the original series, providing a largely complete narrative from Discovery season 2, Strange New Worlds, the original series, animated series and TOS movies.
 
Last edited:
Strange New Worlds spoilers..

Well, this project fell to the wayside for various reasons, but the premiere of Strange New Worlds reminded me what I loved about watching the various prequel series with an eye towards adding context to previously established events and relationships.

I've stated in this thread and elsewhere that I think that Michael Burnham is the best thing to happen to the Spock character since the Genesis wave. The added texture given to the Sarek/Amanda family dynamic in episodes such as Lethe and Light and Shadows shed new light on events we thought we understood completely.

This continues in strange new worlds with the reintroduction of T'Pring. We see them at a point in their relationship where they were at a crossroads. Spock clearly was interested in T'Pring, or at least in scratching an itch, and the interest seems mutual, unlike during the events of Amok Time. If Spock had chosen to stay behind on Vulcan as T'Pring clearly wished, no doubt they would have had a long and happy marriage. Instead, Spock himself sowed the seeds of their eventual breakup by choosing his duty to Starfleet over his oath to T'pring. How different might the Galaxy have turned out if Pike had called only an hour later? And Spock presuming to speak for T'Pring? You can immediately see that you didn't care for that.

Of course, by the time Amok Time rolls around, he no longer seems to be too into T'Pring anymore given his response to being dumped, possibly due to his interactions with Leila Kolami, which should also fall into the time frame of the series. And, T'Pring tired of waiting for Spock, has moved on. Of course, none of this makes T'Pring any less of a cold calculating bitch in Amok Time.

And then there's the look that Chapel gave Spock when they first met in sickbay. Previews for upcoming episodes give us a sense that Spock and Chapel will be developing a friendship, which would of course lead Chapel's feelings for Spock. Suppose that Spock and Chapel actually were gravitating towards a relationship of some sort, but Spock's commitment to T'Pring and his meeting and developing feelings for Kolami is what drives her into the arms of Roger Korby in the first place? It would make their scenes together in TOS feel all the more emotional and even tragic.

And Sam Kirk? So suppose our theoretical first time viewer gets to know Sam here before they even got to know James. That makes Sam's death an Operation Annihilate! to be a shocking, sad and tragic moment to that viewer, rather than a largely inconsequential moment that's never referred to again.

I love that the narrative feels as if it picked up directly from Discovery season 2. I honestly hope that Strange New Worlds ends with some kind of a direct segue into the original series, providing a largely complete narrative from Discovery season 2, Strange New Worlds, the original series, animated series and TOS movies.

Spoiler tags need to be used if you’re posting any kind of spoilers.

There is a whole forum dedicated to the show as well, where you can discuss SNW openly.

Thanks
 
Spoiler tags need to be used if you’re posting any kind of spoilers.

There is a whole forum dedicated to the show as well, where you can discuss SNW openly.

Thanks
Yeah, sorry about that. I somehow screwed up the spoiler tags and everything I tried to repair them just seem to make the problem worse, so I just added the spoiler space. Thanks for fixing the problem for me.
 
Yeah, sorry about that. I somehow screwed up the spoiler tags and everything I tried to repair them just seem to make the problem worse, so I just added the spoiler space. Thanks for fixing the problem for me.

No worries.

Click the + sign, then select spoilers. It’ll ask you to name them, and then the cursor will automatically load between the tags. You can just type normally from there.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top