• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Charting the Stars: Civilians in Space

Thomas_Sullivan

Lieutenant
Red Shirt
So I was thinking about Star Trek earlier, as I'm apt to do, and a question occurred to me. The Federation has a scientific and pragmatic interest in keeping installations spread throughout the stars, even in space outside their own borders -- survey stations for regional studies, starbases for ship maintenance and resource management, relay stations for subspace communications, etcetera. The question that occurs to me, though, is whether or not any of these stations or installations are manned and managed by civilians?

We've seen various individuals throughout the franchise work in tandem with Starfleet in the pursuit of their research (Reyga in "Suspicions," Timicin in "Half a Life," etc.), Federation funded research stations (Carol Marcus in Wrath of Khan), Starfleet manned relay stations (in "Aquiel," for instance.) But have we ever seen anything to indicate that there are civilian manned relay stations, civilian run survey stations, etc. -- or anything to indicate that they do not exist?

I'm open to speculation, as always. The shows themselves don't always give us easy answers, after all.
 
The only example I can think of is Deep Space Station K-7 in TOS which seemed to be a wholly civilian operated facility.

Though there are limited examples, space is a vast place and Starfleet is only one arm of the Federation and not all its citizens choose to have a career in it, so of course there would be civilian stations and outposts for research, trade or cargo transferral, perhaps even a few maintenance and refuelling space ports, though I'd suspect they wouldn't be to the same scale as Starfleet facilities.

It's really a shame there's been little focus on civvies in space in Trek, people who choose to go out into the dangerous and unknown cosmos without the backup and resources of Starfleet.
 
It's sort of suggestive that the TOS adventures open with Kirk being outside the reach of Starfleet support, yet he can rely on civilian help even there out on the frontier (the Delta Vega refinery, the dilithium mine camp)...

Civilians no doubt loiter even farther beyond the border of the reasonable than the government, in search of riches or adventure or solitude or whatnot. It may not contribute much to exploration when the point is to not share, except perhaps for a price. But there's civilian presence out there, in most TOS adventures, and it's not considered unexpected even when it's mildly surprising.

...The one exception to that is "The Cage", where Talos is in the "We've no ships or Earth colonies that far out" zone. Except, well, the heroes do accept that the Columbia might have gone there anyway.

Timo Saloniemi
 
The Vico and The Raven were both civilian ships. Stands to reason there would be civilian stations

Was Yorktown Station civilian? Starfleet could still have a presence there.
 
I'm watching "Devil's Due" right now and the Federation anthropologists on Ventax II appear to be civilians. They are wearing the uniforms that @NCC-73515 mentions above.
 
People in such uniforms do operate ships that have the Starfleet arrowhead on the hull or say "USS Name" on the displays... Even if not actual soldiers, they might be on Starfleet employ somehow, and merely dressing casually.

Although they aren't. Dressing casually, that is. Being in uniform is suggestive enough, I'd think - perhaps this attire denotes the mysterious UESPA, an apparent "Agency" that does "Space Probing" or perhaps "Science Probing" in some sort of close cooperation with Starfleet? The civilian researchers might come from many fields of life, but would be expected to wear uniforms and bow to Starfleet-related bosses in a straightforward hierarchy of unknown specifics.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Everyone wearing the purple/white uniform in TNG was a civilian (as far as I know).

Edit: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Starfleet_uniform_(2350s-2370s)#Civilian_uniform

It's hard for me to say if those scientists and starbase technicians are civilian contractors or simply another branch of Starfleet service. There is a different costume right below those on the Memory Alpha page that is specifically identified as a civilian uniform, though. In either case, as Timo points out, it does seem strange that civilians would have a uniform to begin with. I suppose it could make some sense if they wore a uniform when working as subcontractors to Starfleet on Starfleet bases, so that they might be easily identified when moving about.

The only example I can think of is Deep Space Station K-7 in TOS which seemed to be a wholly civilian operated facility.

That's true. It was constructed by Starfleet, but seems to be entirely managed by civilians -merchants, administrators, and technicians alike. I know a few deep space stations have been mentioned throughout the years, but as far as I can recall we've only seen K-7 and Deep Space Nine (which is an example outside of the norm, surely, given the circumstances.) Given that, do we know enough to know if this is normal or not?

..of course there would be civilian stations and outposts for research, trade or cargo transferral, perhaps even a few maintenance and refuelling space ports, though I'd suspect they wouldn't be to the same scale as Starfleet facilities.....It's really a shame there's been little focus on civvies in space in Trek, people who choose to go out into the dangerous and unknown cosmos without the backup and resources of Starfleet.

I imagine that there would be civilian installations somewhere, for trade, cargo, and maintenance if nothing else. It's just so rare that we see anything more than the Starfleet side of things, especially when it comes to humanity. I don't object to that particularly because I enjoy the stories we've seen (at least most of them until recent times), and it makes sense to focus on Starfleet, but it does leave a big gap in our knowledge base, and I would absolutely love to see a civilian focused Star Trek series. I've actually had a few concepts in that regard myself, meant for tabletop roleplaying.

Solas, which is about a merchant (played by Jeffrey Dean Morgan in my head) who lost his wife in a terrorist bombing in the Cardassian DMZ and is struggling to keep his crew going through hard times that push his moral limits.

Frontiers, which is about a mix of Starfleet rookies (aboard the about to be decommissioned U.S.S. Earhart) and civilian archaeologists, engineers, and scientists uncovering the mysteries of an ancient alien space station that has been colonized by a group of Gamma Quadrant refugees.

Brave New World,
which is about a new colony established in the depths of non-Federation controlled space, far beyond the reach of easy assistance.

Odyssey,
which follows a group of civilians who awaken aboard an alien starship with no idea how they got there, why they were taken, or how to get home - a concept which has since appeared on Dark Matter from what I hear.

Obviously I like the idea of focusing on some civilians. A bit.

The Vico and The Raven were both civilian ships. Stands to reason there would be civilian stations.

Civilians can, of course, own their own starships and do what they wish with them. This doesn't necessarily equate to civilian managed space stations, survey stations, relay stations, etcetera.

People in such uniforms do operate ships that have the Starfleet arrowhead on the hull or say "USS Name" on the displays... Even if not actual soldiers, they might be on Starfleet employ somehow, and merely dressing casually.

Although they aren't. Dressing casually, that is. Being in uniform is suggestive enough, I'd think - perhaps this attire denotes the mysterious UESPA, an apparent "Agency" that does "Space Probing" or perhaps "Science Probing" in some sort of close cooperation with Starfleet? The civilian researchers might come from many fields of life, but would be expected to wear uniforms and bow to Starfleet-related bosses in a straightforward hierarchy of unknown specifics.

I think this is likely the case, that those who wear these uniforms are likely either from a different branch of Starfleet (which we do hear reference to with Starfleet Operations, Starfleet Medical, etcetera) or are essentially contracting out to them, meaning they're expected to wear specific clothes and follow specific rules while they're doing so.
 
Last edited:
That's true. It was constructed by Starfleet, but seems to be entirely managed by civilians -merchants, administrators, and technicians alike. I know a few deep space stations have been mentioned throughout the years, but as far as I can recall we've only seen K-7 and Deep Space Nine (which is an example outside of the norm, surely, given the circumstances.) Given that, do we know enough to know if this is normal or not?
Hard to know if that would be the norm or not. Starfleet serves the Federation and its interests, as such they have a lot of resources and personnel, and neither would want to waste resources if it could be helped so there would be civilian facilities (ie ambassadorial suites, governmental offices, etc) on Starfleet starbases and likewise on Federation stations (Starfleet security, engineering, or research personnel). That way no one is doubling the workload or stepping on anyone's toes.

I imagine that there would be civilian installations somewhere, for trade, cargo, and maintenance if nothing else. It's just so rare that we see anything more than the Starfleet side of things, especially when it comes to humanity. I don't object to that particularly because I enjoy the stories we've seen (at least most of them until recent times), and it makes sense to focus on Starfleet, but it does leave a big gap in our knowledge base, and I would absolutely love to see a civilian focused Star Trek series. I've actually had a few concepts in that regard myself, meant for tabletop roleplaying.
With Starfleet being the focus then shows can be somewhat 'procedural' with their characters and structure, so that we all know what we're getting every week, but with civvies, where they have no great doctrine to explore worlds and seek out new life then it's not quite so clear cut just who might do what or what they'll face each episode.

Solas, which is about a merchant (played by Jeffrey Dean Morgan in my head) who lost his wife in a terrorist bombing in the Cardassian DMZ and is struggling to keep his crew going through hard times that push his moral limits.

Frontiers, which is about a mix of Starfleet rookies (aboard the about to be decommissioned U.S.S. Earhart) and civilian archaeologists, engineers, and scientists uncovering the mysteries of an ancient alien space station that has been colonized by a group of Gamma Quadrant refugees.

Brave New World,
which is about a new colony established in the depths of non-Federation controlled space, far beyond the reach of easy assistance.

Odyssey,
which follows a group of civilians who awaken aboard an alien starship with no idea how they got there, why they were taken, or how to get home - a concept which has since appeared on Dark Matter from what I hear.

Obviously I like the idea of focusing on some civilians. A bit.
Some amazing ideas there, I've had a few similar ones over the years, though never got them out of my head and into a story.
 
There seems to be a few contractors in the assembled crew in the rec room on TMP.

the ECS is civilian. Those ships just have the Earth Cargo Authority as their operating licensee, kind of like the US Merchant Marine. It was never stated when or if the ECS ended. It is reasonable to assume they had their own facilities though.
 
Civilians can, of course, own their own starships and do what they wish with them. This doesn't necessarily equate to civilian managed space stations, survey stations, relay stations, etcetera.

If we go by real world examples, then civilian ships would imply civilian stations. I mean, we have civilian stations today. Someone has to build the civilian ships (although the Vico was an Oberth Class). The LA Sirena appears civilian design.

What would stop someone from building a Civilian Station?
 
There is only One Great Civilian Uniform in Star Trek.

Everybody knows that.

4hp644.jpg
 
Hard to know if that would be the norm or not. Starfleet serves the Federation and its interests, as such they have a lot of resources and personnel, and neither would want to waste resources if it could be helped so there would be civilian facilities (ie ambassadorial suites, governmental offices, etc) on Starfleet starbases and likewise on Federation stations (Starfleet security, engineering, or research personnel). That way no one is doubling the workload or stepping on anyone's toes.

Of course, that all makes sense. Starfleet is pretty well involved in most ventures outside of the personal lives of citizens (science, medicine, technology, exploration, colonizing, diplomacy, relief aid, engineering, defense, archaeology, anthropology, arbitration, trade negotiation, historical preservation, and a lot more than I could reasonably spell out here even if I wanted to) - it can make it difficult for people who aren't fans to understand the role they take on in their universe. I've had many conversations about the misinterpretation that they're a military organization.

Given the amount of business Starfleet finds itself involved in on a regular basis, it would be very smart for them to not waste resources (especially manpower) where it was unnecessary.

With Starfleet being the focus then shows can be somewhat 'procedural' with their characters and structure, so that we all know what we're getting every week, but with civvies, where they have no great doctrine to explore worlds and seek out new life then it's not quite so clear cut just who might do what or what they'll face each episode.

True. Starfleet officers can be drastically different from one another persona wise, but ultimately they're doing the same thing as each other for the same reasons. They share the principles that all life is sacred and the purest ambition is the pursuit of truth and knowledge. I'm not saying this is a bad thing because it's not, but it does mean the franchise is a little predictable -- not in the details of stories, but in the overall purpose of the characters in them.

Some amazing ideas there, I've had a few similar ones over the years, though never got them out of my head and into a story.

Thanks. That's always the hard part, though, isn't it? I've always been more of a muse oriented writer than a disciplined one, so I've dealt with that a lot. I spontaneously dream up great ideas, but my muse doesn't always want to give me the whole picture. It tends to focus on the big moments, or the character beats, and leave me the work of figuring out the rest myself. When you get it right, though, it's a feeling like no other. At least for me. Of course, I've wanted to be a writer since I was eight years old. Your mileage may vary, as they say.

There seems to be a few contractors in the assembled crew in the rec room on TMP.

The ECS is civilian. Those ships just have the Earth Cargo Authority as their operating licensee, kind of like the US Merchant Marine. It was never stated when or if the ECS ended. It is reasonable to assume they had their own facilities though.

I would agree it seems reasonable, especially since they predated Starfleet as we know it in the 23rd and 24th centuries. Archer and other members of Starfleet had knowledge of ECS activities, but no real inside information such as flight plans or encounters those ships had while they were engaged in carrying out their jobs. It makes me wonder, though. Do starships ever have to file flight plans like airplanes do?

What would stop someone from building a Civilian Station?

Nothing at all. Only lacking time, resources, or manpower. Those sort of things are likely carried out by Starfleet's corps of engineers more often than not, even when those stations are intended to be run by civilian administration (like K-7.) That would be the most efficient thing for all parties involved. Of course, that only applies to directly Federation controlled installations. Member worlds surely build things of their own volition without Starfleet oversight (though with assistance whenever requested, I've no doubt.)
 
Good idea in principle, but there is no guarantee other species will follow such guidelines themselves. The Ferengi really do not strike me as the type of civilization that would care enough to have some form of Prime Directive or first contact protocols.

Federation civilians certainly are not bound by Starfleet rules and regulations. And, by extension, the Federation does not have jurisdiction beyond it's borders.

Might make for some interesting story ideas - even if those ideas are how to prevent Federation civilians with a space ship from contacting pre-warp civilizations or establishing first contact.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top